7 ms·
As Argentine Peso Falters, President Keeps a Low Profile
- spindritf 13y agoJoke told at a talk: there are 4 kinds of economies: rich economies, poor economies, Japan, and Argentina. https://twitter.com/daschloz/status/427917763588677632 https://twitter.com/daschloz/status/427917763588677632
- coldcode 13y agoIt's always amazing to me that people continue to think they can cover up a failing economy by insisting everything is fine. For hundreds of years people have tried this. In the end it never succeeds. Money goes where it wants and eventually it eats your lunch and your cake.
- gaius 13y agoEventually might be a long time. How long have the Kim dynasty held power in North Korea? Or Castro in Cuba? Britain fought a war to free Argentina from Fascist dictatorship (and, err, get our islands back), they had a chance for a clean slate then, and they blew it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ezequiel-garzon 13y ago"Britain fought a war to free Argentina from Fascist dictatorship (and, err, get our islands back)" Your parentheses make me hope your main statement is sarcastic. For the record, the dictatorship was already declining in popularity when it decided to take a bold gamble against the British Empire. Sadly, human nature shows that victory would have granted the regime additional years, if not decades, in power.
- gaius 13y agoThe rhetoric coming out of Argentina of late suggests that history is repeating.
- danmaz74 13y agoAnd as a matter of fact, it was Argentina that fought a war to keep the Fascist dictatorship in power... not the other way around.
- mistakoala 13y ago'Bold' should never be used synonymously for 'stupid' or 'reckless'.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ezequiel-garzon 13y agoThey are all different concepts, but not mutually exclusive. I used "bold" since I feel the regime believed there was some positive probability of winning that war. Although I have no respect for the regime or the war they came up with, I feel "stupid" is the term that applies the least of all three.
- slgeorge 13y agoAnd, in the UK it had the impact of ensuring that the conservative government led by Thatcher won at least another election. Before the war it wasn't looking that good, but due to the patriotic pay-off from the conflict her popularity numbers shot up. So there you go, as long as you 'win' a war it's beneficial to your election chances. We're all tribal underneath!
- tsotha 13y ago>In the end it never succeeds. Yeah, but the first part of that sentence, "In the end", is the key. Delaying the collapse gives the current office holders time to finish out their terms and it gives people with money time to move it offshore.
- rz2k 13y agoHowever, sentiment is vital to understanding economic conditions and what the effect of current 'fundamentals' will be. To understand the dynamic in a primitive economic sense, imagine that you can either farm and produce an excess of food to store away, or you can learn a specialized skill. In one scenario, you were too optimistic, and there will turn out to be no demand for your specialized skill. In another one, you can sell your excess food to other people in return for their skilled services. (Or maybe you're the one selling your services) And in yet another scenario, everyone has tried to save up wealth in the form of food, and extra food ends up being relatively worthless relative to other goods and services they need to buy for a high quality of life. When there is poor confidence about the future of the economy, people will tend to save rather than invest in the future. While, on an individual level it makes sense to store up safe assets, for an entire economy pessimism and poor sentiment can be self-fulfilling. Furthermore, those stores of wealth whether grain, currency or diamonds only maintain value as long as people are confident that they can be traded for other goods and services they need—something that becomes an increasing challenge when those goods and services simply aren't being produced in sufficient quantity. So, while you can't lie your way out of problematic fundamentals, underinvestment due to uncertainty is also an impediment that must be overcome, regardless of whether it is created by gloom about the prospects for the economy as a whole, or fear that markets will collapse, or fear of political upheaval where your potential gains will be confiscated.
- CapitalistCartr 13y agoI love Argentina, the people, the cities, the mountains, the food. But the government is absurd; petty corruption is endemic, the politicians are expected to behave like Roman leaders taking care of "their" people. Until popular expectations change, the government will continue to tank the economy.
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoIt's not just Argentina, it's most of south america. Politics is dysfunctional here. "Socialism" is the default, and the best way to get votes here: welfare programs (that never work) gets you the votes of the poor and the intellectual elite, while a big and wasteful government is the #1 client of the private sector in a weak economy. It's triple win. Then, when the economy fails (because of taxation, evading investment, unprepared workforce) they can always blame on "the man", "USA", "neoliberalism", whatever... And another term begins. Argentina went downhill because they've been in this process longer. Ignoring the pathological cases (Venezuela, Bolivia), if the other countries here like Uruguay or Brazil don't rev up, we'll have another Argentina 5-10 years down the line. This year the Brazilian government was caught masquerading economic indicators for 2013 to keep inflation inside the goal.
- oscargrouch 13y agoEquating Brazil, with Argentina, Venezuela, Bolivia and Uruguay just because they are in the same continent, is a very common mistake analists from The Economist and other specialized media with the same ideological values does.. without really knowing what they are talking about.. I can understand the fact they cant understand it very well because of the lack of a cultural perspective to do it right.. (and the people they represent) What i dont understand is people from inside, reverberating that sort of speech.. making clear you dont know very well what are you talking about.. or which class you are defending with this speech.. (and its probably not yourself, unless you are part of the top 1%) But its very simple to measure how bad we are.. Take a look at your own economical condition, to see if you did not improve it with time..
- deleted 13y ago
- thisiswrong 13y agoThis time round things could be very different. Remember how the Cyprus savings confiscations in 2013 provoked a previously unseen rally on bitcoin [1]. When Argentina's financial system implodes a significant part of the economy could well switch to bitcoin [2]. For many in Argentina this would be a better option than 'rebooting' yet again into fiat. [1] http://siliconangle.com/blog/2013/03/21/bitcoin-value-hits-70-and-keeps-climbing-cyprus-bailout-connection-speculated/ http://siliconangle.com/blog/2013/03/21/bitcoin-value-hits-7... [2] http://www.latinvex.com/app/article.aspx?id=1170 http://www.latinvex.com/app/article.aspx?id=1170
- wslh 13y agoBitcoin is not the solution. Good HN threads: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7100394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7100394 (search for the bitcoin threads) EDIT: surprised that someone downvoted this comment.
- msandford 13y agoIt's outside government control and in Argentina government control is the problem. So it sounds like it would be a hell of a lot better than just rebooting the currency again and just hoping that the government doesn't screw it up this time.
- wslh 13y agoYour comment is answered in the posted link. Basically Argentinians love dollars and we are not rational. Also bitcoin fluctuations and the difficulty to buy and sell bitcoins with a local bank account makes the innitiative very limited.
- msandford 13y agoI think you're referring more to this link about the difficulty of Argentinians getting their hands on bitcoin. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7100504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7100504 Even if that's true (there are ways, though) that doesn't somehow negate the idea that it would be better for the normal person on the street to be able to use a currency that -- while volatile -- retains its value better than the peso. The idea isn't that the US Government will step in there and say "Here's some bitcoins use these instead" but rather that the people will decide to end up using them on their own, irrespective of policy. Argentinians love dollars because compared to the peso they're a "safe" store of value that's not under the control of their government, and because so many people will accept them. Dollars are the de-facto secondary currency not because of policy but because of people. There's nothing that would prevent the people from deciding to use bitcoin or dogecoin or litecoin or argecoin if they so decided in the future.
- jbellis 13y agoArgentina is in trouble, but this article is not very insightful. A better one, out of many options: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/01/world/americas/as-argentine-economic-crisis-swirls-president-keeps-low-profile.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/01/world/americas/as-argentin... Another: http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21595471-latin-americas-weakest-economies-are-reaching-breaking-point-party-over http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21595471-latin-americ...
- cromulent 13y agoAfter all the shilling of gold and faux-economics that Bonner has written over the years, I have a hard time believing anything he says.
- slurry 13y agoI used to work for him. I agree.
- ye 13y agoArgentinian Peso: http://www.xe.com/currencycharts/?from=ARS&to=USD&view=1Y http://www.xe.com/currencycharts/?from=ARS&to=USD&view=1Y
- mmaunder 13y agoTDR has been prohesying doom weekly (and pushing gold buying) since the 90s.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mistakoala 13y agoReally? She had SO much to say about other countries last year. "Hey! Look at that thing happening over there in the distance, far away from here!"
- bobdvb 13y agoYep, pretty soon she'll find another reason to say something nasty about the UK, just to distract the people. Argentina's version of Bread and Circuses.
- lispsil 13y agoBitcoins are worth 2x the current price on bitstamp in Argentina. If you want a cheap vacation go there and trade btc for cash on localbitcoin.com They want litecoins too
- cromulent 13y agoThis post used to link to an article on the Daily Reckoning site, but has been changed to a completely different article on the NYT site. Old link: http://www.dailyreckoning.com.au/argentina-is-going-down/2014/01/29/ http://www.dailyreckoning.com.au/argentina-is-going-down/201... I must say I'm uncomfortable with the idea that an post can change title and URL to a different domain after comments have been posted.
- conanbatt 13y agoA major factor here is that they were steering the ship to crash right after they leave the office, trying to repeat the political disaster that happened to the UCR in 2001. Unfortunately in economy, when you know/think in the future something is going to happen, it affects the prices today. The devaluation, denial of inflation and expenditure of reserves paint a bad picture: they dont intend to change the direction of the ship, at least not yet. Of all the issues the US has with the political system, i wished we had the strong institutional presence they have. Politics in argentina are so cultist, and they always centralize power in a persona or figure. There's never a discourse that says "we are going to do this, so in the future this wont be corrupted, or this will be measured independently" etc. I havent heard that in my entire life. To explain the basic consequence of that to a typical american: there is no future planning in argentina. There is no forecast that ever spans more than 2 years, and those ones venture in black magic. Everything has to be about immediate effects because nothing is built for the long term.
- clockworkelf 13y agoWhat the heck is she supposed to do other than inflate the currency and lie about the inflation rate? Her hand is forced by finance oligarchs.
- brosco45 13y agoWhy was the title censored?