5 ms·
Chinese engineer commits suicide after losing a 4th generation iPhone prototype
- a2tech 17y agoI find it interesting that the article seems to be pointing the finger of blame at Apple-however I can't Apple really being to blame here. This seems like more a problem with an extremely stressed individual and an extremely controlling corporation that is employing him. Something tells me that if the guy had lost ANY secret product (not just Apple's) the pressure applied to him would have been immense.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe article first and foremost blames chinese society and government. Apple's secrecy is mentioned only as a side note without assigning any blame.
- barredo 17y agoDisclaimer: i'm a Mac user and have nothing against Apple. Said that I guess we (and the companies) should start thinking if this kind of 'collaboration' or contracts with Chinese companies are not only profitable (that is the main -if not only- reason) but good for China, the Chinese company, the Chinese workers, the non-Chinese company and the end user. Because I guess, we are exploiting the workers in a country with a dictatorship just to get cheap gadgets, toys and such. And yes, I would say Apple is a bit to be blamed for this. Not that Apple were aware or that Apple would approve these (I'm 100% sure it doesn't) actions. But, if this Chinese company -and others- keep their contracts with American or European companies although things like keep happening (At least we know about this case! How many of them have happened?)... they (the 'first world companies') will become (if they are not already) part of the problem. ps. Sorry for my English (I'm from Spain and well...)
- jacquesm 17y agoApple is part of the problem here because they are positively anal about their product releases being kept secret to the point where they will sue left right and center if they suspect some kind of breach. Why the cult of 'new' is so crazy about having the latest gadgets and how much that drives sales is totally beyond me. If it works and I need it I'll buy it, otherwise you can keep it. I never realized how bad it really was until a good friend - who shall remain nameless - vowed to queue to be one of the first to have an iphone. Seriously, who cares. People think they're cool because they have cool stuff, not because they do cool stuff.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"People think they're cool because they have cool stuff, not because they do cool stuff." Very succinct expression of an idea that has been rattling around in my head for a while but I couldn't express except very verbosely. This is one of the reasons I read HN. People whose writing skill makes me think "I wish I could write as clearly as that".
- allenbrunson 17y agoWhen Apple announces a new product, it is almost always available for sale that very day. Almost everybody is hearing about it for the first time. The big wave of excitement hits, which probably leads to a big first few weeks of sales. Many (most?) other companies have talked a product to death by the time it is actually for sale. There is no excitement at this point, it has all been dissipated away. Consumers don't see much of a need to buy it right away. Maybe they'll forget about it altogether before making the decision. I'd say this works pretty well for Apple. You are trivializing their methods in an ugly way.
- geoka 17y ago"Many (most?) other companies have talked a product to death by the time it is actually for sale. There is no excitement at this point, it has all been dissipated away. Consumers don't see much of a need to buy it right away." Are you saying that expo demos and previews for the media actually hurt sales? I always thought manufacturers do it to build up interest and excitement; this way when the product is released everybody is rushing to buy it. Look at the games industry, for example. It seems to work. Why Apple thinks it works the other way around, is beyond me.
- seshagiric 17y agoWhile what you say is correct, it would be good if Apple did something about this. Sometime back HP had employed an agency that used illegal means in the US to trap peoples phones etc. While the contract agency committed the crime, HP did take responsibility for this. On similar lines Apple could investigate take action on their outsource partner. It should also see if its own staff gave such expectations to the outsource partner.
- aristoxenus 17y agoI'd put this a little more strongly: assuming what has been reported is true, Apple should step up and wield the power it has in this situation to strongly denounce and penalize Foxconn.
- TJensen 17y agoI think there would need to be proof that Foxconn did something, which I would imagine will be hard to get out of China.
- c0nsilience 17y agoThe article doesn't blame Apple as much as it blames the Chinese government and how it handled the matter. The article does state that it might not have happened in another country.
- makecheck 17y agoI guess what I find interesting is that someone so young (25) would be entrusted with such an important product, and entrusted alone. He could only have been with the company a few years at most. If I were in charge of that, I would at least send two people to pick up those phones, and they'd be people with bigger stakes in the company (maybe upper management or even vice presidents?).
- danw 17y ago25 isn't so young, almost a decade after a person can join the workplace It's strange to see how these days people in their twenties are expected to behave like adolescents. There was a recent NYT article gushing about how incredible it was that Obama's speech writer was only 27 whilst his peers played video games all day. By that age Darwin was already back from a five year voyage collecting samples and Einstein had written a paper on special relativity. Luckily the HN community expects us to do something worthwhile regardless of age.
- barredo 17y agoofftopic: I'm with you, I'm tired of people at their 30-ish and saying 'I'm still young, bla bla bla' :-)
- sriramk 17y agoI'm sad to say that this comment depressed me more (call me self-centered) than the original article (since I'm 25 right now).
- code_devil 17y ago[I am 25, moved to US for BS so worked since 18] I think work age is slightly different in Asia. Most people do not work till they have at least a BS Degree (21/22) or possibly even a Masters degree. And also, while they are in school/college they pretty much stay at home in the comforts of their family unless they go for an engineering college to a different city. So, indirectly they are pretty much protected from the real world issues for a major part of their youth. So, age/maturity also seems to have some cultural flavor to it as well.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoSimilar comments here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=715920 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=715920
- ram1024 17y agogoing to sherlock this one and say his superior stole the device for some black market green, he put the subordinate as the only one in charge because he'd be easy to blame. pretty sick
- jrockway 17y agoThis is why I like the OpenMoko phones. Open source hardware; nobody needs to kill themselves over revealing the details.
- Oompa 17y agoThey're a great idea, but sadly no where near as nice as the iPhone, or even the Palm Pre or G1 for that matter.
- hitthewashboard 17y agoThis is true and as much as I like the project and am with the original commenter in terms of enthusiasm the statement might be slightly going in the wrong direction as there could be secrecy about hardware features as well. I think what our fellow hacker wants to point out though is the fact that there is a completely different culture around the openmoko project where tragedies like this would be a lot less likely to happen. Openmoko has less of momentum simply because there isn't as much money behind but still I would dare to say it might be almost a duty for the open (source) minded hacker to own one (EDIT: device, like the Neo Freerunner "GTA02") and hack around. For the sake of a new culture.
- Oompa 17y agoOh, I completely agree, I just don't think you could compare it, since the OpenMoko is just so subpar.
- yan 17y agoIs that really the reason you like OpenMoko phones? "nobody needs to kill themselves over revealing the details" I completely don't understand that statement. Like anyone associated with the iPhone can say "someone needs to kill themselves over this project." Suicide is never the result of outside details, it's a personal disorder.
- hitthewashboard 17y agoI concur on the criticism of the statement but I wouldn't be so sure as to call every suicide a personal disorder. Obviously his environment(/his mistake?) put him under a lot of pressure which has been clearly UNBEARABLE to him. This is not happening in the US this is happening in a different culture, there are factors to be counted in we might not even know about. Not every suicide is a personal disorder.
- polos 17y agoOK, sad, but the problem here is identifying yourself too much with your job (which is always interchangeable and finite, as opposed to identifying yourself with the real value of your person, which is always infinite).
- freetard 17y agoNo, that's not the problem. Did you read the article? The guy was going to be tortured and beaten probably to death.
- bumbledraven 17y agoI wonder if it was actually suicide?
- ice5nake 17y agoWe all support the Chinese way every time we buy a product made in China. A business supports these methods every time they sign a contract with a company that produces its goods in China. It's implicit. I am not sure how you can feign having your head in the sand. Apple is absolutely part of the problem. We are absolutely part of the problem. Yes, even myself. To say otherwise is foolish. Apple should hold Foxconn to high standards not only in protecting its secrets but how to properly treat human beings.
- Tichy 17y agoPeople kill themselves in "the West" over losing jobs or pressure at school, too. I've heard that students in Cambridge have a high suicide rate, for example. Also the question is would the people be better off without the jobs from foreign companies? Surely they put up with pressure at their jobs because they don't have a better alternative?
- nailer 17y agoThe pressure people are under to work in the West is generally smaller than the pressure to work in second world countries including China. And the Cambridge students chose to be under that pressure.
- adw 17y agoOr were pressured to be under that pressure - we're talking about seventeen-year-old kids here. But, still, it's nothing like this – and, flawed thought it is, there is support for students.
- Tichy 17y agoNot saying that I'd rather live in China, just thought that particular example was a bit off.
- omouse 17y agoIt's extremely difficult to avoid Chinese-made products when you buy electronics...
- huherto 17y agoA guy who works at Foxconn here in Mexico told me that Chinese executives that come here are surprised and somehow annoyed but the difference in cultures. Here, people come to work, talk to each other, joke around, etc. In China, people just stay in one place, do not talk to each other and just look straight down even if the line is stopped and they don't have work to do. It sounds like one of those futuristic movies where we are just robots doing the same thing over and over. I do not know if they are repressed or if it is pure fear. I guess that can make you crazy. I know that he (Sun) was an engineer and it is not exactly the same, but still I can imagine a situation where he was extremely scared.
- startingup 17y agoYou may be surprised to hear this: that part about "stay in one place, do not talk to each other and look straight down" is true even in Japan and Korea, even in many high tech office settings. My vivid recollection when I worked in Japan was "These people are so nice outside the office, why do they become such expressionless robots inside?" I have many close friends in Japan (and we have done a lot of fun stuff outside the office), and so I would ask them this. They would shrug and say "At work we have to wear a mask, that is just the culture here, everyone has to conform to it." It felt oppressive to me, but they seem to take it in their stride.
- LogicHoleFlaw 17y agoChina is historically the cultural juggernaut of east Asia. I don't know why the culture has taken on this aspect, but yes, it is ubiquitous in these nations.
- robak 17y agovery weird. I have the same feeling about places I worked in the US compared to Europe. People wear mask, are quiet and pretend someone they're not, don't trust anybody.
- mahmud 17y agoPerhaps an imperial history explains it? The early industrialists looked around for a social model for the "factory" and the people gathered there in, and the closest thing they found was the military and the warrior classes. The industrialists often refer to themselves a "moguls" and their large businesses as "empires"; you can see how their little ego might take on a whip and shape people in the imperial master/server image. You never see the same thing in ancient trades; agriculture, education, restaurants, etc. specially in China. Family or community owned industries. It's businesses operated by "forward looking" management that's learning and applying this robo-militaristic attitude. Henry Ford did the same thing, the man pretty much removed workers from society and built walled cities in the jungle. Though I think Henry the Great might be shooting for a "benovelant dictator" sort of title.
- trevelyan 17y agoN = 1.
- ajg1977 17y agoSad, but I wonder what really happened to it...
- mattmichielsen 17y agoThe article neglected to mention that the next generation iPhone will be a current one with U2 colors and signatures.
- Luyt 17y ago"Many Chinese died to bring you this iPhone".