6 ms·
One thing to be aware of is that the range of incomes in many countries is much more compact than the US. If you define social mobility by the ability to move f
by jandrewrogers 13y ago
One thing to be aware of is that the range of incomes in many countries is much more compact than the US. If you define social mobility by the ability to move from the bottom segment to the top, it requires a much smaller change in income in most industrialized countries than in the US.
For example, for the average person in Denmark to go from the bottom 10% to the top 10% of income requires earning a mere $40k more income. In the US, you would have to earn $90k more income. Consequently, it takes considerably more effort in the US to increase one's income in the US to the point where it would count as "social mobility" than in many countries even though you would be much better off in the lesser quintiles in absolute terms.
In short, there are many countries where moving from $20k to $40k is considered "socially mobile" but also others where moving from $20k to $60k income is not because the top bracket is $80k. Most people would probably prefer to live in the latter country. It may be a little harder to reach the $80k than $40k to meet the definition of "socially mobile", but in absolute terms they are far better off with $60k of income regardless of the definition of social mobility.
- DerpDerpDerp 13y ago> in absolute terms they are far better off with $60k of income regardless of the definition of social mobility. I'm not sure this is true, if the cost of living (or luxuries) is different between the two countries.
- jandrewrogers 13y agoActually, the studies adjust the incomes for purchasing power parity, so it is not just nominal income. Costs of living and similar are built into the relative income quintiles and deciles when comparing between countries. The US also has a wider income range because of the enormous differences in cost of living within the country itself, in large part due to its size, which skews the result. The top quintile in one region of the US may be the middle quintile in another.
- 001sky 13y agoCosts of living and similar are built into the relative income quintiles One way to break a correlation that uses an inflation index is to look at or carve out asset inflation. Once you correct for asset inflation (which is NPV'd income), only then will you have properly adjusted income measures.
- Tarrosion 13y agoYes, after reading the article I'm not sure how they correct for the stark differences between places. Are the quintiles done locally or nationally? If they're done locally, then people who migrate are a problem for the statistics: it's very easy to move from bottom quintile to top quintile, just move from Palo Alto to rural Oklahoma. Or by excluding people who migrate, perhaps there are skewed effects. But if the quintiles are national quintiles, not local quintiles, variation due to location still throws things off. The group of people in the 3rd national quintile living in Silicon Valley probably have quite different statistics than the group of folks in the 3rd national quintile living in a mid-size town.
- waveman2 13y agoOne of the criticisms of the study is just this point. A lot of the "upward mobility" is people moving to more expensive areas where they get somewhat higher pay but the cost of living is much higher. They may well be worse off, but in $USD terms they have moved up.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoGiven that physical mobility is down in the US, this means that income mobility for reasons other than physical mobility must have increased. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/magazine/why-are-so-many-americans-staying-put.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/magazine/why-are-so-many-a...
- scarmig 13y agoTrue and to the point, as far as it goes. But I think you discount the importance of relative change a bit too much. Imagine a country with a fiery economy: within a generation, real incomes will triple or quadruple, and at an equal factor across all income groups. Let's say also this country also has an incredibly rigid caste system, where you can predict that a person falls will fall within the same single percentile as their parents with 100% accuracy. Your absolute measure fails to capture a situation that I think you'd agree shows very little income mobility, while the one you're criticizing succeeds at it. What I think you're getting at is that people can be much better off despite lack of intergenerational income mobility. Sure. But people are looking for a measure that will capture the fact that some societies have parental income that's much more predictive of children income than other societies. It's an interesting reality that many people find problematic, and it has a real impact on other social systems--race, class, geographic mobility, educational outcomes, and elite networks--that are very interesting to analyze and potentially useful to understand.
- rayiner 13y ago> In short, there are many countries where moving from $20k to $40k is considered "socially mobile" but also others where moving from $20k to $60k income is not because the top bracket is $80k. Most people would probably prefer to live in the latter country. I don't think that's actually true. Having the rich be a lot richer has a lot of sociological impacts, particularly within a democracy.
- harryh 13y agoEmpirical evidence is not on your side here considering net immigration from Mexico to the US (or many other poor country / rich country pairs).
- rayiner 13y agoThere is a big difference between the medians in those two places. I'm thinking more like the U.S. versus European countries.
- harryh 13y agoIs there data on this? I'm having trouble finding it. Do we think that, say, more people move from US -> France than the opposite every year? I'd bet money on the reverse.
- thirsteh 13y agoIt sounds like you're looking to feed confirmation bias. Picking a country that most Americans love to hate isn't really going to give you accurate results. Try comparing the U.S. to Germany and Switzerland, or the U.S. to the Scandinavian countries. Also, keep in mind that statistics on emigration only show you how many people moved between the countries. It doesn't show you whether people in Germany are more likely to be curious about the U.S. than vice versa, or whether the people are happier and have more freedom. I am a European living in the U.S., and I agree the U.S. is a terrific country to be in if you are making a lot of money. But most people don't. The poor here are far worse off (and the rich are far better off--indeed, that is the definition of inequality.)
- RivieraKid 13y agoSo most people would prefer to live in a country with a massive income inequality? I don't think that's true.
- collyw 13y agoMost rich people seem to want it that way.
- thirsteh 13y agoMost people aren't rich. "America is the wealthiest nation on Earth, but its people are mainly poor, and poor Americans are urged to hate themselves. To quote the American humorist Kin Hubbard, “It ain’t no disgrace to be poor, but it might as well be.” It is in fact a crime for an American to be poor, even though America is a nation of poor. Every other nation has folk traditions of men who were poor but extremely wise and virtuous, and therefore more estimable than anyone with power and gold. No such tales are told by the American poor. They mock themselves and glorify their betters. The meanest eating or drinking establishment, owned by a man who is himself poor, is very likely to have a sign on its wall asking this cruel question: “if you’re so smart, why ain’t you rich?” There will also be an American flag no larger than a child’s hand—glued to a lollipop stick and flying from the cash register. Americans, like human beings everywhere, believe many things that are obviously untrue. Their most destructive untruth is that it is very easy for any American to make money. They will not acknowledge how in fact hard money is to come by, and, therefore, those who have no money blame and blame and blame themselves. This inward blame has been a treasure for the rich and powerful, who have had to do less for their poor, publicly and privately, than any other ruling class since, say Napoleonic times. Many novelties have come from America. The most startling of these, a thing without precedent, is a mass of undignified poor. They do not love one another because they do not love themselves." — Kurt Vonnegut (1922–2007)
- collyw 13y agoI didn't claim most people are rich. Rich people have a lot more influence over our "democratic" system, and they seem to be the ones that want to preserve the status quo of massive inequality.