3 ms·
>>You have a First Amendment right to speech. You don't have a right to a government job. It's hardly Orwellian. That's not how it works. Freedom of speech mea
by enraged_camel 13y ago
>>You have a First Amendment right to speech. You don't have a right to a government job. It's hardly Orwellian.
That's not how it works. Freedom of speech means you can say whatever you want without fear of being prosecuted by the government. And if firing the employee is not prosecuting them, what is?
- voxic11 13y agoSo what do you think the solution should be. Can government employees pretend to represent the government when they haven't actually been authorized to?
- enraged_camel 13y agoNo one is "pretending to represent the government." He simply said he works for the TSA. As an employee at the lowest level, the last thing he is doing is representing the organization's policy or philosophy.
- sliverstorm 13y agoif firing the employee is not prosecuting them, what is? Well, how about something like: pros·e·cute (verb) law : to hold a trial against a person who is accused of a crime to see if that person is guilty -- Merriam-Webster
- enraged_camel 13y agoI was using the term "prosecute" figuratively. But thank you for your pedantry. Sometimes I forget I'm on HN and comments like yours remind me again.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIt's hardly pedantry when it comes to legal documents... The first amendment does not protect against figurative prosecution, at least to my knowledge, so your premise is off. I realize you probably feel the actual text of the first amendment is needless pedantry, but what it actually says is congress shall pass no law...
- ewrgwerg 13y agomoron
- lbrandy 13y agoYou're committing an equivocation fallacy and (s)he's allowed to point that out.
- Bahamut 13y agoBut that's not how we define freedom of speech. You cannot just say anything without a context, for example inciting panic at a movie theater by yelling fire. But more relevantly, one is allowed to say what one wants in government - one just has to be ready to take responsibility for one' s actions. That is far from not having freedom of speech.