3 ms·
Maybe vertically integrated ISP service doesn't work as an investor-owned enterprise. Maybe all last-mile facilities ought to be owned by the municipality and m
by Zigurd 13y ago
Maybe vertically integrated ISP service doesn't work as an investor-owned enterprise. Maybe all last-mile facilities ought to be owned by the municipality and multiple providers can be chosen for ISP services.
- jbuzbee 13y agoI recall that in the late 90's there was a regulation in place that forced the phone and cable companies to lease their coax or DSL lines to competitors who wanted to offer service as an ISP. I recall getting mailers from various little companies with offers. There was a difficulty in determining what the proper lease rate would be for the little guys. And in the end it apparently didn't work out. I don't know if the law was changed or if the cable and telephone companies were able to set the lease rate so high that nobody else could be profitable.
- Zigurd 13y agoProblem is, the "retail" ISPs were competing with the owners of the DSL lines. You would have to get the "wholesale" ISP out of the retail business.
- ensignavenger 13y agoI think it is still the law, but like you said, the wholesale prices are set way to high to be competitive.
- _delirium 13y agoI agree. I'd rather look to how deregulated electricity markets work. The last-mile infrastructure is owned by either a municipality or a regulated utility, billed at fixed utility rates, and the generation/service portion is floated on the open market. ISPs aren't identical, but I don't see a strong reason a competitive ISP market couldn't follow the deregulated market that states like Texas use for electricity. Have the last-mile infrastructure owned by some boring regulated entity, and then let ISPs compete to provide connectivity over the pipe, like generators compete to provide electricity over the wires.
- girvo 13y agoThat's how my countries new network is set up. Makes sense to me, tbh.