11 ms·
Who wants competition? Big cable tries outlawing municipal broadband in Kansas
- jonaldomo 13y agoTIL that you can submit bills and not be a politician.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 13y agoI dug into it out of curiosity, and I don't believe that's technically true, but is sort-of true in practice. Only members of the legislature may formally introduce bills. But, Kansas, like some other states (especially those influenced by popular-democracy principles of the progressive era), has developed a convention where legislators often convey bills to a relevant committee when requested to by a constituent. In that case they submit the bill but decline to sponsor it, to indicate that they're just conveying it. Here's the relevant section from the Kansas Handbook of Legislative Procedure (http://www.kslegislature.org/li/m/pdf/kansas_legislative_procedure.pdf http://www.kslegislature.org/li/m/pdf/kansas_legislative_pro...): 16. Who May Introduce a Bill. Any member or any standing committee, an interim committee of either house, and certain statutory committees may introduce a bill. Sometimes bills are introduced by two or more members (of the same house) as joint sponsors. All regular appropriation bills are introduced by the Appropriations/Ways and Means Committees. Bills sometimes are introduced by a member or committee at the request of a constituent with the notation “By Request” appearing after the author’s name on the printed bill and in the journal. A “By Request” designation often suggests that the member or committee who introduced the bill is not necessarily an advocate for it.
- pyrocat 13y agoIt happens at the federal level too. Lobbyist groups write the bills themselves and submit them to members of Congress in closed door meetings. Congress can then edit the bill, but they often just introduce it as-is. We only know this because people have leaked the Lobbyists version of bills and compared them to the ones introduced by Congress.
- _delirium 13y agoYeah, in practice I think it's converged to a similar sort of thing, though the Kansas version does have better-intentioned origins. Rather than having a bill covertly written by lobbyists and then sponsored by a Congressman who claims to be advocating it but actually had little to do with its drafting (as happens at the federal level), the original idea of some of these state-level practices was to open up the legislature to citizen-proposed legislation. Some states (like California) went all the way with a robust citizen-initiative system where citizens can directly propose legislation that has to receive a vote. Others developed conventions more like Kansas's, where the norm was that legislators are supposed to forward reasonable legislation for a vote even if they don't personally advocate it, and this was done quite openly ("I'm forwarding this bill by request of so-and-so"). So the response to a citizen asking the legislator to sponsor a bill becomes three- rather than two-valued: the legislator could draft and sponsor legislation in their own name to that end; could reject it entirely and refuse to introduce anything along those lines; or third, they could pass the citizen-written bill along for a vote as-is, without working on or endorsing it themselves. I doubt it really works like that in practice anymore, if it ever did (my guess is that, if you aren't important, your chances of having a bill you send be seriously considered are pretty small), but I can see why it was an attractive idea.
- jessaustin 13y agoI doubt it really works like that in practice anymore... Yeah TFA makes pretty clear that in this case the bill was written by the greasiest lobbyist in Kansas.
- IvyMike 13y agoA huge number of bills are done on the "Written by industry, submitted by sympathetic politician" model. It's pretty much ALEC's whole deal, and they're really good at it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Legislative_Exchange_Council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Legislative_Exchange_...
- izzydata 13y agoScrew this. I'm only a few miles away from where Google Fiber is supposedly in construction. I just want my fiber in a couple years or less. Is that too much to ask?
- rayiner 13y agoArs' coverage isn't very good on this issue. There is a tremendous amount of context Ars ignores, namely all the franchise agreements between municipalities and cable companies whether these sorts of proposals run afoul of those agreements. Also, consider the Kansas City example, where the city gave a single favored company massive regulatory concessions to install fiber. I know "Google can do no evil," but it isn't good precedent. Cheering on the municipalities is boneheaded. The municipalities and their franchising agreements are a major part of the reason we're in this mess to begin with: http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa034.html http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa034.html (note the article is from 1984).
- jbuzbee 13y agoYeah, I'm a bit torn on these bills. They sound awful, but there are issues that all the tech-sites seem to ignore. I'm all for competition, competition, competition. We need more competition! But when municipalities get into the mix, you have at least the potential for unfair practices. A city could give itself free access to utility right of way, condemn properties in its way and hide the true cost of running a network by lumping some expenses in general utility categories. And you might end up with a very poorly-run network that every single citizen pays for via higher taxes whether they want it or not. Since citizens have to pay the city taxes no matter what, they'll drop the potentially superior commercial Internet offering instead of paying twice. Likely? Maybe. Maybe not. But worth a discussion.
- Zigurd 13y agoMaybe vertically integrated ISP service doesn't work as an investor-owned enterprise. Maybe all last-mile facilities ought to be owned by the municipality and multiple providers can be chosen for ISP services.
- jbuzbee 13y agoI recall that in the late 90's there was a regulation in place that forced the phone and cable companies to lease their coax or DSL lines to competitors who wanted to offer service as an ISP. I recall getting mailers from various little companies with offers. There was a difficulty in determining what the proper lease rate would be for the little guys. And in the end it apparently didn't work out. I don't know if the law was changed or if the cable and telephone companies were able to set the lease rate so high that nobody else could be profitable.
- mgirdley 13y agoTexas already has these laws. Thank you, ATT.
- mhurron 13y agoAs does NC, since at least one municipality implemented municipal fiber and provided service better than Time-Warner and Comcast. But you know, it was for the good of the people.
- jbuzbee 13y agoI recall reading an article a while back about a neighborhood that had a fiber network that was put in when the community was built as a selling point. Every single house had fiber in place for TV, Phone and Internet. Sounds great! Right? In theory yeah, but not so much in practice. Every house had a network fee added as part of their homeowner's due. This fee went to an external company that ran the network. This company didn't have much or any incentive to properly manage, update or keep the network running. They had a captive audience. Everybody pays every month whether they use the network or not. Network down? They'll get to it in a bit after they take care of their competitive neighborhoods. And though fiber sounded great, the speeds they were getting weren't much different than other areas near-by on cable modems. So want to forget it and go with Comcast? Sorry, they don't serve the neighborhood as they can't be competitive when everybody in the neighborhood is already paying for the fiber network. I recall the neighborhood association had gone through a couple of different management companies, with pretty much the same result. In short - beware of turning over your network to someone without an incentive to make you happy. Of course, in many areas (like mine) there is no real competition for high-speed Internet. It's Comcast or nothing...
- ryanhuff 13y agoI see no problem with this setup if the homeowners association own the network, and can bid out managing the service to private ISP's. That's the ideal setup, IMO. Consider the data pipes a utility, but let free market forces drive service.
- jbuzbee 13y agoIf they were able to let multiple companies offer service over their community-owned dumb pipes, that would indeed be ideal. But my recollection is that were hiring a single private ISP to manage it all. Maybe they were too small for Comcast or Cox, etc. to bother with in this unique setup? I'm afraid the same thing would happen in small towns if the town itself owned the network.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI think the argument goes something along the lines of: Public enterprise, as we all know, is of course highly inefficient, massively expensive and badly organised. Which is why it is absolutely vital to ban it from entering industry as it would be unfair competition.
- minimax 13y agoThe title is sort of misleading. A municipality offering broadband service isn't really an economic actor since it can use tax receipts to subsidize the service. Offering a choice between service provided by local government and a private business isn't really the kind of competition most people have in mind when they think of healthy markets. The laws should incentivize competition between multiple telcos not between telcos and government. Also, generally speaking, running big telco networks is hard, capital intensive, and requires a lot of expertise that municipalities don't really have. I've never used a municipal internet service that was any good.
- PaulHoule 13y agoThe quality of private telecom services in the U.S. isn't that good. Try using your cell phone in a major city without making excuses like "everybody else was trying to hail a cab after getting out of a Pink concert" or "I was staying in a hotel that has a lot of metal in the frame". Private companies are consistently making bad decisions as to infrastructure. For one thing, they've wasted money building high-cost fiber-to-the-node and hybrid-fiber-coax networks. Yes, the initial cost of FTTH is more than the alternatives, but the running costs of FTTH are much less and if you consider a time span of five years or more, FTTH comes out ahead. In places like Austin where carriers have wasted money on xDSL deployments, they find they have to go to FTTH once a competitor goes to FTTH. Why? Since the running costs of FTTH are so low, an FTTH provider is the low cost provider and will win the value segment, not just the high-end segments. The main problem is that rich people are full of themselves and think they deserve credit card interest rates for their investments rather than the low market rates that capital markets provide (which are telling them that they've got too much money and nobody needs them.) They know they can build expensive (to run) networks because they can make their customers pay the operating costs, rather than putting some more money up front to produce something that will produce more profits in the long term.
- minimax 13y agoIn places like Austin where carriers have wasted money on xDSL deployments, they find they have to go to FTTH once a competitor goes to FTTH. Why? Since the running costs of FTTH are so low, an FTTH provider is the low cost provider and will win the value segment, not just the high-end segments. I'm not sure exactly what you're trying to say, but I think that means you agree with me that competition between telcos leads to better/cheaper product for consumers? To your last point, that telcos don't invest in infrastructure basically because they're greedy (is that even what you're saying?), I think that fits into H. L. Mencken's idea that "for every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong." I have worked at the periphery of a big telco and from what I saw there are many challenges to controlling costs. To name a few: inefficient internal bureaucracies (ugh), strong unions (not a criticism, just pointing out that union labor is more expensive than nonunion labor), and mainly the fact that the network is enormously huge (like, physically huge) and it's extremely expensive to refresh the technology every few years.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VladRussian2 13y agoin the movie "Aviator" there is a scene where PanAm almost successfully gets monopoly on international flights. Watching it i could feel only "WTF?". The same way we'd be feeling couple decades later about monopolies that weak [in particular to the influence of industry] governments at all levels have been granting to telcos.
- eitally 13y agoSounds like the story that transpired in Wilson, NC a couple of years ago with their Project Greenlight, an attempt to offer municipal fiber to the home. TWC wasn't happy and lobbied hard against it. http://www.fiercetelecom.com/story/att-centurylink-face-1-gbps-challenge-wilson-nc-based-greenlight/2013-04-22 http://www.fiercetelecom.com/story/att-centurylink-face-1-gb...
- crazy1van 13y agoThe government giveth and the government taketh. They gave many of these companies near-monopolies by blocking competition from laying cable or accessing the telephone poles. Now the government has decided to crush the telco's industry by running their own service at prices impossible to compete with because they are tax payer subsidized. Live by the sword. Die by the sword. Personally, I'd rather shrink the sword down to around a steak knife.
- SourPatch 13y agoMaybe this is a stupid question, but why is it so bad to let people provide for themselves? Kansans should be prevented from running their own ISP? Why? Doesn't that idea seem contrary to self-governance? It's really depressing that people cannot legally say "screw you" to big telco/big cable and do their own thing. Somebody enlighten me, please.
- leot 13y agoBecause competition from outside the oligopoly is uncompetitive (apparently).
- bdb 13y agoWonder if an electric pole counts as a "facility."
- YZF 13y agoI'm not from the US but it seems like there's nothing stopping the big telcos from partnering with those same municipalities and offering a sweeter deal than Google does, is there? If anything, their existing infrastructure, from the age of the telegraph, gives them a huge competitive advantage over anyone coming in, with or without municipal involvement... IMO government's role should not be the protection of some specific business, it should be about improving the lives of the citizens, partly through improving infrastructure. If big company X goes broke while this happens why should we care? So billionaire Y will make more while billionaire Z makes less?
- balloot 13y agoThe government is so evil and incompetent that it should never be allowed to provide broadband, because it will do so with such low rates and great service that it will put cable companies out of business! Did I get that right?
- hippiehippo 13y agoInstead of becoming an ISP, wouldn't it make more sense for the town to wire up each house with fiber optics and then let ANY company provide services over those cables? The ISPs will have to pay the town a flat fee per subscriber for using the municipal fiber optics network, or they could roll out (or keep) their own (existing) infrastructure. This way companies will still be able to compete, but the "last mile" will become an utility like the sewage system.
- welterde 13y agoThat's the way it's done in the Sweden, Norway and switzerland and their FTTH deployment is far ahead of large portions of europe. So yup.. I would say that open access works.