7 ms·
True, and it's somewhat disturbing to see "environmentalists" tie themselves in rhetorical knots trying to argue for nuclear with a straight face.
by jessaustin 13y ago
True, and it's somewhat disturbing to see "environmentalists" tie themselves in rhetorical knots trying to argue for nuclear with a straight face.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI'm not against nuclear power, per se, but the way we do it is seriously warped, mostly by its associations with the weaponry. A uranium mine isn't just a fuel source, it is also part of a military arsenal at the highest level, so really it isn't that surprising to see so little care given to the externalities. Personally I think that solar/storage is about to outcompete the pants off most everything else anyway, given the ever falling price of modules and the existence of companies like lightsail and gravitypower. http://www.lightsail.com/ http://www.lightsail.com/ http://www.gravitypower.net/ http://www.gravitypower.net/ hot gravel edit; oh, and Isentropic - http://www.isentropic.co.uk/ http://www.isentropic.co.uk/
- zackmorris 13y agoI saw my first hybrid solar/natural gas (continually running) power plant commercial on TV the other night from a fossil fuel company (can't remember which one). I think you're right, that solar thermal storage (in hot oil for now and eventually salt) with trough reflectors instead of photovoltaics, will be the eventual winner, even against wind. My excitement for it is that it relies on 19th century technologies that anyone can implement and doesn't need a fab or another country to provide solid state solar panels.
- ars 13y agoNuclear isn't perfect. It's simply better. Go see just how much toxic and radioactive waste coal mining produces. WAY WAY more than nuclear power.
- schiffern 13y agoAnd solar is rapidly out-competing and out-innovating both.
- ars 13y agoMaybe. Photovoltaic solar produces lots of waste, more than nuclear. And it requires lots of land. Solar thermal is much more efficient but it's expensive and no one seems to be doing it in scale. And it too requires lots of land. And don't say we have lots of land, we do, but it's remote, so you need a lot of infrastructure to make use of it. We can do that (we did for hydrocarbons), but it's not a slam dunk. Because of that, nuclear produces less waste and is better for the environment.
- techdmn 13y agoI continue to be confused about how nuclear can be considered better / cheaper / cleaner without factoring the cost of storing the waste for 10,000 years. We seem to struggle with unintended consequences of waste management on the decade scale, let alone several millennia.
- saulrh 13y agoPlastic bags last longer in landfills than nuclear waste will last in a repository; plastic photodegrades in about 500 years, multiply by a two-hundred-meter-deep landfill and that plastic will finish going away in about a million years [1]. Nuclear waste is fundamentally static; unlike tailings, it pretty much stays where you put it. Coal plants actually produce titanic amounts of radiation, vastly more than nuke plants, thanks to impurities in coal, and that radioactivity is going straight into the atmosphere [2]. Nuke plants don't produce that much waste in the first place; thirty tons a year, compared to millions of tons of radioactive, caustic fly ash [3, 4]. And, finally, the kinds of nuclear reactors we can build these days simply don't produce waste that lasts that long; a good breeder reactor eats anything that's immediately dangerous (short half-life -> lots of radiation) or long-term dangerous (long half-life -> not much radiation) [5]. [1] http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2007/06/will_my_plastic_bag_still_be_here_in_2507.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_plant#Radioactive_trace_elements http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_plant#Radioactive_trace_el... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste#High-level_waste http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste#High-level_waste [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Environmental_problems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Environmental_problems [5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breeder_reactor#Waste_reduction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breeder_reactor#Waste_reduction
- mrottenkolber 13y agoExcuse me? Does one of those plants have to blow up in your neighbourhood until you can relate to the fact that some risks are not worth taking? These things are dirty bombs, period. Edit: To clarify, I am not arguing for coal. Just against nuclear power. I live next to a garbage->energy and gas turbine plant. It's not perfect, but I wouldn't want to live near a nuclear plant.
- jotm 13y agoCoal plants (and their supply chain) are just as dirty without having to blow up...
- gaius 13y ago... And actually emit more radiation, traces of uranium in coal just go straight up the chimney...
- mrottenkolber 13y agoGuess fukushima was too long ago. Oh wait, its still leaking a tons of gene-pool destroying toxin every day. I knew people first hand who died from chernobyl's toxic rain. Took 10 years for their faces to completely fall apart.
- ars 13y agoAnd coal power is like a constant never ending fukushima. It's gut, but un-informed feelings like yours that are the cause of so much environmental destruction. > I knew people first hand who died from chernobyl's toxic rain. And I know of people who today are suffering from asthma and lung cancer from coal's toxic exhaust. And newsflash: There are way way way way more of them.
- mrottenkolber 13y agoWhy do you assume I am defending coal? It's irrational confidence like yours that nuclear power is in any way safe, and therefore a good replacement. Coal doesn't need a replacement, we need to start using energy responsibly. That means not using energy when we don't have it. A nuclear plant is not an acceptable way to generate energy.
- jessaustin 13y agoWhen I said "it's somewhat disturbing" I didn't mean that I desired forthwith to be somewhat disturbed.