3 ms·
"A simple average of the findings of the preventive care studies shows that about 50 percent of people received recommended care. (None of the studies reported
by Alex3917 13y ago
"A simple average of the findings of the preventive care studies shows that about 50 percent of people received recommended care. (None of the studies reported a percentage of people receiving contraindicated preventive care.) An average of 70 percent of patients received recommended acute care, and 30 percent received contraindicated acute care. For chronic conditions, 60 percent received recommended care and 20 percent received contraindicated care. These values do not indicate exact levels of quality in the United States, but they do provide a quantitative sense of how much could be done in all areas to identify and eliminate overuse and underuse of care." Source: http://www.innovationlabs.com/summit/summit3/readings/Schuster-McGlynn-Brook_How%20Good%20is%20the%20Quality%20of%20HC_Millbank_2005.pdf http://www.innovationlabs.com/summit/summit3/readings/Schust...
In other words, the percentage of the U.S. population who receives medical treatment based on best practices isn't even close to 50%. And more often than not even doctors who follow clinical guidelines aren't actually following best practices, because most clinical guidelines aren't even correct:
"A study published in JAMA in 1999 evaluating the quality of [clinical] guidelines showed, ironically, that they often fall short of established standards. The following year The Lancet published a report that found that only one of the 20 clinical guidelines examined met established standards of quality for three simple criteria: description of the professionals involved in formulating the guidelines; description of the sources of information used to find the relevant scientific evidence; and grading of the evidence used to support the main recommendations.
In 2000, Canadian researchers from the British Columbia Office of Health Technology Assessment evaluated the quality of the guidelines that addressed the testing of cholesterol levels. They found that four out of five of these guidelines did not reflect the best scientific evidence available. The Canadian Researchers also found that 'the greater involvement of clinical experts in the development process of the clinical practice guidelines, the less of recommendations reflected the research evidence.'" Source: Overdosed America, p. 127
- vacri 13y agoHow does 'simple average of 50%', 'average of 70% receiving recommended acute care' and '60% received recommended chronic care' somehow mean 'not even close to 50%'? They're all 50% or higher. Also, there is a difference between 'not the best standards' and 'not evidence-based medicine'. What might have been the best standard when the doctor trained in 1980, gained from evidence, might have developed further. The doctor is still performing due to their evidence-based training; it's just not current best practises.