4 ms·
Neither of us have much of an argument because all you've got is anecdotal journalist linkbait, and all I have is experience on 2K footers not 30K footers and g
by VLM 13y ago
Neither of us have much of an argument because all you've got is anecdotal journalist linkbait, and all I have is experience on 2K footers not 30K footers and gossip from fellow (harder core) climbers. I'm more of a hiker than a climber but there is obviously huge overlap in the hobbies. Someday I'd like to do the 15 mile hike to basecamp but I'm not overly interested in the summit itself.
On the other hand I do agree that you have a sound theoretical argument that a famous summit like Everest is going to attract proportionally more crackpots than Cho Oyu.
I was thoroughly unimpressed by the Mail story and its implications. Here's a picture of about 100-200 climbers. Here's an explanation of why I think a whopping 2 of them don't belong there, although that's not very impressive. And here's a past glamour pic of two climbers who died but I very carefully avoid identifying the dead ones as being unqualified, which is bizarre because if they were unqualified it would certainly fit the predetermined conclusion of the article. So what the Mail implied was most of the climbers are noobs who die, but the facts of what it actually reported were very few climbers are unqualified or weirdos and deaths don't seem to correlate with qualification or lack thereof, so there really isn't much of a story. Just profiteering off tragedy.
I don't think anything can be learned from infotainment. Actual stats from reputable sources would be informative. Linkbait, eh, not so much.
- dalke 13y agoHah! You didn't see the clear cases of linkbait I rejected. There's plenty of people whose comments were more based in snobbishness than anything else, of the "I was into X before X was popular" or "No one does X anymore, it's too crowded" varieties. But honestly, it isn't that hard to find people who weren't mountaineers who decided to climb Everest. In http://reachingbeyondtheclouds.com/?page_id=18 http://reachingbeyondtheclouds.com/?page_id=18 , "I became drawn to climb that mountain: the beauty, the challenge. Please realize that at the time I had climbed only Mt. Kilimanjaro and was no mountaineer." Due to medical reasons, "I had do it as soon as possible. ... I had to climb as many mountains as I could in a short amount of time." She started training in 2006 and was at the top of Everest on 2010. She only lists a few mountains that she summited before then. http://mirandaluby.writersresidence.com/samples/on-top-of-the-world http://mirandaluby.writersresidence.com/samples/on-top-of-th... describes someone whose "first ascent, up [Kilimanjaro], happened purely on a whim." Some time later, after experience 'backpacking at a high altitude for weeks', Simon "decided to give Aconcagua a go to see if I would get sick again", and then going through the tallest peaks for each continent. "Between expeditions, he kept his day job as an anaesthetist, and outside of work hours trained by running and riding" .. that is, not by climbing a large number of other mountains. http://www.avagacser.com/ViewContent.aspx?mode=v&mediaID=23 http://www.avagacser.com/ViewContent.aspx?mode=v&mediaID=23 describes Medvetz who, a year after a near fatal motorcycle accident which left him temporarily wheelchair bound "That's when I just decided ... I'm gonna climb Everest." "I lived in the Himalayas for about six months in villages and all around the Everest region," Medvetz explains. "I climbed all the smaller peaks around Everest, just training and preparing for it." I don't see evidence that he climbed even a hundred challenging mountains before trying Everest. As it turns out, the group he went with was being filmed for the Discovery Channel. That, combined with other factors, let him to start a foundation to help wounded veterans do things like climb Everest. One of these in the near future is at http://theheroesproject.org/2013/11/sgt-thomas-charles-linville/ http://theheroesproject.org/2013/11/sgt-thomas-charles-linvi... . I see no evidence that Linville has any mountaineering experience. I found these with very little effort. While it's true that these people are physically fit, and have some training, it's pretty obvious that they are not highly experienced mountaineers who worked up to the Everest challenge by doing even a score of other technically difficult peaks first. Thus, it suggests that the anecdotal evidence from those "infotainment" articles has some basis in fact. Does that satisfy you? ;) There's another interesting wrinkle. Attempting to summit Everest unprepared is not a modern thing. Consider Maurice Wilson's 1934 attempt, based on little more than fasting and prayer. Or the 1962 attempt by Woodrow Wilson Sayre and 3 colleagues, described by Sayre in "Four Against Everest." One review says "This is a true, almost unbelievable story of a daring attempt by four amateur mountaineers - a college professor, a school teacher, a lawyer, and a geology student - to climb the highest peak in the world!" A more correct analysis might look to see if the percentage of attempts by inexperienced has increased over the decades.
- thaumaturgy 13y agoKeep going. 240+ people summited (not attempted, but summited) Everest in 2012 alone. You're still a long way from "most".
- dalke 13y agoNow where did I ever say "most"? ;) VLM claimed "Most of them have climbed a zillion other mountains." (I'll interpret 'zillion' to mean "very experienced mountaineers, with years of mountain climbing and 50+ difficult peaks summitted." Perhaps you have a better definition?) I was curious of the evidence which might back the validity of that claim. It's certainly true that some people who climb Everest are not highly experienced mountaineers. While VLM rejected my original references, I quickly found some counter-examples which show that it is not the case that all Everest climbers are very experienced mountaineers. ("Not all" is obviously not the same as "not most".) My point stands, which is there is no data backing the claim that "Most of them have climbed a zillion other mountains." It might be that 95% are very experienced, in which case VLM is justified in making the assertion. It might be that only 30% are so experienced. Ahh! Here's one possibility. http://www.wemjournal.org/article/S1080-6032%2806%2970297-6/fulltext http://www.wemjournal.org/article/S1080-6032%2806%2970297-6/... has in table 1 information about some of the people attempting in 2003. Of the 108 people surveyed, on average there were about 1.47 previous attempts at an 8000 meter peak, of which about 0.7 were of Everest. The standard deviation is 2.03, which means the distribution is very skewed. One person who did all 14 eight-thousanders balances out a lot of first-timers. They also asked about the highest previous climb, and report: > A histogram of previous altitude ever attained (Figure 1) shows a distinct peak at about 7000m. This is likely because of the influence of Mt Aconcagua in South America, a popular training ground for would-be Mt Everest summiteers. Although highest previous altitude ever attained initially appears to be a good measure of a climber's experience, the natural paucity of high-altitude peaks and the strong bias of climbers summiting Mt Aconcagua means that it is not possible, with our data, to determine depth of experience. Many of the climbers in this study may have climbed only once at high altitude, with very little other experience. That paper agrees with my belief, which is that there isn't enough information to meaningfully claim that "Most of them have climbed a zillion other mountains."