5 ms·
> What Iceland did is subtly different. It lets foreign > banks to fail, to bear the consequences of their own > risky and stupid investments, and refus
by peteretep 13y ago
> What Iceland did is subtly different. It lets foreign
> banks to fail, to bear the consequences of their own
> risky and stupid investments, and refused to tax its own
> people to cover foreign bankers loses.
What?
Hundreds of thousands of personal depositors across Europe saw their money go poof in Icelandic banks, and their local governments had to pick up the bill. If you are a tax payer in the UK, for example, you got a gigantic FU from the Icelandic government who said "nah, we're not going to bail out our banks, you guys should instead".
You can start with: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008–11_Icelandic_financial_crisis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008–11_Icelandic_financial_cri...
- dschiptsov 13y agoThe decision was about foreign, mostly UK, banks who gave (they call it "invested") money to Icelandic trading desks. These money were denied to pay back taken from Icelandic citizens. Keeping local banks from default on domestic deposits in favor to "foreign investors" (speculators) and letting them to face loses is what the govt of Iceland did, which was a proper decision. Overconfident, high ranked idiots who put funds in an obvious ponzi scheme are those who shall bear the consequences.
- randomafrican 13y agoThat's exactly what the OP said though..
- peteretep 13y agoA simple analogy for you: You are Engla, the mother of little Johnny. One day, at Johnny's school shows up a little girl called Bjork. Bjork seems to come from a nice family, and you like her Mom, Icelandi. One day Johnny comes home from school and says Bjork is running some kind of saving scheme, and can he put his pocket money in it? You remember some of the older kids at school doing something similar one time, so you say sure, because besides, Icelandi seems like a nice lady, and you're sure she's got her eye on it. Johnny gives a bit of his pocket money to Bjork every month, and Bjork's little saving scheme seems to be going really well. Bjork seems a little better dressed these days, and Icelandi is driving a new car. Icelandi is always prattling on at the PTA about how clever little Bjork is. One day, Johnny comes home in tears. Apparently Bjork showed up at school and said she'd lost track of her accounts, and she no longer had any money to give him. You ring up Icelandi, furious, and ask her to refund little Johnny's money. "No no", says she, "I think you'll find it's all on Bjork, and not my responsibility". You note she still has her shiny car. Later that day, you find out Icelandi completely refunded Thor, Bjork's little brother, for all the money he had lost, but every other child at school also lost all their money. Icelandi is hailed on the internet as some kind of popular hero.
- Shish2k 13y agoI don't think Iceland is popular for screwing the UK and saving themselves, I think they're popular for punishing their bankers, which is something your analogy doesn't seem to make any mention of...
- peteretep 13y agoYou're right. Little Bjork got grounded for a week. Yay!
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoAs opposed to getting off the hook totally free and having all the other kids in school, who were smart enough not to invest, put in their own lunch money to pay for everyone who was dumb (greedy?) enough to invest. Edit: How is that fair to the kids who weren't involved and now have less money for lunch?
- peteretep 13y agoYou appear to be referring to tax payers in the UK and Holland who aren't only footing bills from their own banks, but also Iceland's.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoReferring to the Icelandic public who would have been burned as well for the UK/Holland public's investments (at no tangible benefit to their public at large). While the UK/Holland investors, who lost their investments, lost a gamble and their country decided to minimize it for them (Edit: Likely to most of their population's chagrin). Or perhaps the people investing in the Icelandic banks were not investing? Was this some sort of special investment where you get a better rate than the regional banks without any sort of risk? When the entire game is rigged, and you're hoping to make a few quid out the side, you're probably going to get totally screwed somewhere, at some point. It totally sucks, I agree, but are you surprised that if someone could insulate themselves they would? Also there have been consequences for Iceland, particularly in terms of trust, and there won't be a lot of foreign investment in their financial structure anytime soon.
- prawn 13y agoWasn't the gigantic FU more from the Icelandic banks rather than the government?