3 ms·
This is a very good summary. Coming from a different angle I can relate to most of these points. The biggest issue is that people there view the USSR as the hei
by IgorPartola 13y ago
This is a very good summary. Coming from a different angle I can relate to most of these points. The biggest issue is that people there view the USSR as the height of Russia, and pro-Russian Ukrainians are glorifying what Ukraine was as a country when it was a part of the USSR. Remember, the propaganda machine was incredibly strong in the USSR. People were constantly told that the USSR is the greatest country in the world (much more so than in the US being told about exceptionalism). People there grew up on the idea that communism was the one true way.
Another point: most people currently in power in Russia and Ukraine were either members of or had strong connections to the communist party. You can change the form of government all you want but if you don't change who is in power can you really expect different results?
Finally, it is extremely important for Ukraine to break away from Russia and define its own identity. It is hard to provide an adequate metaphor for what 70 years of communism did to Ukraine as a country and Ukrainians as a people. As one example, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor. If Ukraine was to give in and be absorbed by Russia, the Ukrainian identity would be destroyed. I do not see that kind of ambition coming from the EU, which is why I am in favor of more close relationships with the west.
- SpaceRaccoon 13y agoWhat is the Ukrainian "identity"? Here is a map of the territory of Ukraine acquired by Czars or Soviet leaders: http://i.imgur.com/LAc1emR.jpg http://i.imgur.com/LAc1emR.jpg. And before the USSR it was part of the Russian Empire. Both Slavic peoples have a close and often intangible history, as far back as Kievan Rus' and the principality of Kiev. As for myself, my grandfather was a Ukrainian with the surname Kozak, while my grandmother was a Russian by the name Svistelnikov. All the relatives I know were born in Ukraine, including those pre-dating the October revolution. Furthermore, you mention Holodomor- yet this was allegedly the fault of Stalin, head of the SOVIET state. Are you implying Stalin didn't kill Russians? That Russians somehow benefited from Ukrainian misery? Or, that Russians also didn't starve during those difficult times?
- IgorPartola 13y agoYou are making my point. Ukraine has existed as a country for a very long time. It has been fought over and divided by neighboring countries for most of its existence. I am saying that it's time for Ukrainians to find, define, and defend their identity. > Are you implying Stalin didn't kill Russians? That Russians somehow benefited from Ukrainian misery? Or, that Russians also didn't starve during those difficult times? He did kill a fair share of them, but yes that is exactly what I am saying. Stalin wanted to assimilate the rest of the soviet republics into one homogenized Russian-based people. Holodomor was a part of it. Re-read the Wikipedia article and the primary sources. Re. Stalin: Let's not re-write history. USSR was Russia and Russia was USSR. No other country really mattered under Stalin and it was the Russian way or the highway.
- SpaceRaccoon 13y ago>Ukraine has existed as a country for a very long time. It has been fought over and divided by neighboring countries for most of its existence. I am saying that it's time for Ukrainians to find, define, and defend their identity. I ask, what is its identity? Because historically it has close ties to Russia and a shared history with all Slavic people. In fact, how do we define what Ukraine was over history, since if that image I posted is correct most of it's territory was given by the Russian empire or Soviet leaders. Furthermore, Kiev was just as much the birthplace of Russia as Ukraine- current Russia and Ukraine were once indistinguishable as the principality of Kiev: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rus_de_Kiev_en_1237.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rus_de_Kiev_en_1237.png >Stalin wanted to assimilate the rest of the soviet republics into one homogenized Russian-based people. Holodomor was a part of it. Re-read the Wikipedia article and the primary sources. Re. Stalin: Let's not re-write history. USSR was Russia and Russia was USSR. No other country really mattered under Stalin and it was the Russian way or the highway. Perhaps I am not familiar enough with it. Nonetheless, interesting how the hundreds of years of years of shared history should be disregarded because of the actions of one man who was ethnically neither Ukrainian nor Russian, and yet, according to you, killed Ukrainians in the name of Russians.
- 13y ago