8 ms·
I've found it interesting that nearly every anti-protestor comments about the Ukraine situation here have been Russians (as per their profiles). A solid 75%+ an
by girvo 13y ago
I've found it interesting that nearly every anti-protestor comments about the Ukraine situation here have been Russians (as per their profiles). A solid 75%+ anyway, for the last three threads. Why is that?
- austenallred 13y agoI don't know if I can answer your question, but I lived in eastern Ukraine for two years (yes, I speak fluent Russian), and my frustration with the media and journalism there has sent me on a three year (so far) journey to make everyday people the driving force of journalism instead of governments and corporations. And please take note, it's impossible to speak for a group of people or boil down what's happening to anything concrete when it's very disparate and unique to each individual. But I'll point out a few trends I've seen. For some background, eastern Ukraine is very pro-Russian, and was (and is) very pro-Yanukovytch. The majority of the people I talked to pined for the days of the Soviet Union, when bread was cheap, everyone had what they needed, etc. They viewed the fall of the soviet union as a psychological infiltration from the west, and, apart from a short rendezvous to defeat Hitler, the west is still the enemy and full of corrupt capitalist blood suckers (which, to be fair, can be not-too-far from the truth at times). It's hard for most westerners to imagine that many of the major cities in Ukraine have a 30 ft + statue of Lenin or that many of the major streets are named "Lenin" street, but it's not uncommon for me to see poems or images praising Stalin from my Russian Facebook (or Vkontakte) friends. The Soviet Union was the good ol' days, not grouped together with pre-WWII Germany as it often is in the States. Stalin is decidedly not Hitler. I include this information not to say that anti-protest comments come from Soviets/Communists, but the influence of the Soviet Union and how information was relayed still lingers, even today. When most of the people there, especially the older generations, talked about the media, they would often reference a transmission from Moscow (передача из Москвы) as the only source of reliable information. Think of it as "published in the New York Times." And bear in mind that the New York Times has been just as involved in Propaganda as was Pravda in its heyday. The battle, in the mind of Russians, is one of information, and of each side trying to deceive the other. Americans look at pro-Communist posters as "propaganda" but at the western side's as simply "promotional posters." Russians see it as an ideological battle being fought with information. For many Russians this is the same battle being fought. It's not revolutionaries vs. evil dictator, it's east vs. west. It's Russia vs. the Europe/United States. And when a battle of information leads to such sharp contrasts, you defend your side, in a similar way to how Republicans defended George Bush when he did stupid things and Democrats defend Barack Obama when he does stupid things. It's not about the particular circumstance, it's about ideology. You'll notice a common thread of "Well, sometimes Russia sucks, but America sucks sometimes too." Which, again, is completely fair. And again, this is not something that only happens in Russia. But this leads to trying to sway the facts in favor of one side, and that often leads to gross misinterpretation of what is actually going on. Russia Today and Pravda are state-sponsored PR organizations dressed up as journalistic institutions. When the protests began, according to RT it was "a handful of people" gathered, angry at "a failed trade law," and not the bubbling over of frustration as a completely corrupt President threw his enemies in jail and deepened relations with Putin. Take, for example, the naked protestor who was mocked by police, photographed, slapped, kicked, and put in a van (graphic video:) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSt4kAItj4Q http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSt4kAItj4Q. Many of my Russian friends would tell you he was trying to set himself on fire, the police saved him, took pictures "in memoriam," gave him a few friendly slaps, and let him go. They would leave comments like "Let him burn next time!" or "Be careful, police, you're only giving the terrorists more psychological ammunition!" So, to answer your question, in the mind of a Russian it's because we're still fighting a war of information, and the west likes to deceive and destroy Russia psychologically. They defend their ideology the same way we defend ours, and sometimes information and facts are left out to dry.
- mtrimpe 13y ago> The majority of the people I talked to pined for the days of the Soviet Union, when bread was cheap, everyone had what they needed, etc. This seems to be the thing most Westerners find hard to grasp. For many people communism was good. If you didn't want too much you would get everything you wanted without struggle, which for many was heaven.
- maratd 13y ago> This seems to be the thing most Westerners find hard to grasp. For many people communism was good. This is naive. Please don't pay too much attention to those who weren't there. It was heaven for Russians, because a nation that has been historically at the bottom of the ladder, got to play in the big leagues. Who cares if your standard of living sucks? It always sucked. > If you didn't want too much you would get everything you wanted without struggle, which for many was heaven. If you want to find out how Communism gives "to those according to need and from those according to ability", then I urge you to visit North Korea. I assure you, that is exactly how communism worked in the past and continues to work today.
- malkung 13y ago> It was heaven for Russians, because a nation that has been historically at the bottom of the ladder, got to play in the big leagues. Who cares if your standard of living sucks? It always sucked. For anyone interested what Ukrainian nationalists have to do with this, this is an example of their thinking.
- mladenkovacevic 13y ago> I assure you, that is exactly how communism worked in the past and continues to work today. I assure you it is not.
- zhemao 13y agoI assure you it is. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor)
- pm90 13y agopossibly because the number of Russians>> no of Ukrainians and Russians are the group that has more than a cursory knowledge of the situation
- viach 13y agoDid you really check all the profiles? :)
- rtpg 13y agoMight explain why they keep on referencing "your country's laws", since a lot of the anti-protest laws seem to be the norm in Russia.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> I've found it interesting that nearly every anti-protestor comments about the Ukraine situation here have been Russians (as per their profiles). A solid 75%+ anyway, for the last three threads. Why is that? Because they can read primary sources... Most of the supporters of the protesters know nothing of the situation except what the English-speaking media filters to them, and what some protester writes on a blog (because that wouldn't be biased at all...).
- PavlovsCat 13y agoSurely you don't mean to say Russians couldn't possibly be biased as well?
- Mikeb85 13y agoEveryone has their biases. It's not as if Russians in the US are particularly pro-Putin.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> Everyone has their biases. True. But that also means to say certain opinions are flawed because of bias is kind of pointless, isn't it? what some protester writes on a blog (because that wouldn't be biased at all...) At least it's first-hand bias. Those people put their lives on the line, literally, so while I agree one shouldn't just take a handful opinions and believe them, I think you can't just easily dismiss them for being protesters, either. It takes a lot of material to come even to a tentative conclusion, but it's possible. Then you'll still be biased but I guess that's the price of being human.
- mtrimpe 13y agoAnd Russian media is likewise heavily propagandized. The truth is that it's simply a complex issue about a country with a deep ideological divide which is being pulled on by the two super-powers it's wedged between. There's a lot of power-play going on here, especially with Putin's desire to have Sochi (the winter games) look good, which is evidenced by things such as the massive discount on natural gas offered by Russia in exchange for not signing the treaty with the EU (which sparked the protests originally.) That's why Russian media focuses mostly on the fact that the majority of people on the street are extremists (i.e. people who love to fight,) conveniently ignoring the fact that a large amount are also just normal citizens truly representing the movement and a much, much larger amount of people are expressing their support on social media.
- vetinari 13y agoMaybe because Russians can read texts like this: http://vk.com/14po_programme_deda_moroza88?w=wall-18785005_20308 http://vk.com/14po_programme_deda_moroza88?w=wall-18785005_2... Most Europeans and Americans cannot, they must rely on what their media tell them.
- translation1 13y agoA Google translation of the linked text with a little bit of post-editing: http://pastebin.com/bF2J619N http://pastebin.com/bF2J619N. Nice hatred of Jews and Tatars there. Are you saying this is what Russians believe?
- vetinari 13y agoUkrainians, not Russians. I take it as hatred of oligarchs. It is just coincidence, that none of them is Ukrainian. I think that if Ukrainian had a chance to become oligarch, he would use it.
- korzun 13y agoCitation needed? I'm pretty sure most Russians are probably posting from North America anyways.
- malkung 13y agoDo you mean ethnic Russians or Russian citizens or are Russians those who make anti-protestor comments?
- IgorPartola 13y agoBecause what Yanukovych is doing is very pro-Russian. In simplest terms Ukraine is facing a choice between Russia and the EU. Russia is obviously not too keen to lose Ukraine, since the Russian government and most Russian people consider Ukraine to be a part of Russia (or at least a Russian territory). The protesters are fighting for a more independent Ukraine, one not dependent on Russia for every political decision, and one that has more connections with the EU (in this case a trade agreement). I noticed the same trend. If you see someone saying something against the protesters they likely identify as Russian in their profile or have a slavic name. It is unfortunate, since opinions are being formed on HN, and the few anti-Ukrainian comments are making their way to the top.
- guard-of-terra 13y ago"Because what Yanukovych is doing is very pro-Russian" Whoa, so him almost signing euroassociation papers (doing all the necessary work) was a very pro-Russian move?
- IgorPartola 13y agoHim not signing them was pro-Russian. The EU treaty was ready to go, when Yanukovych suddenly turned around and refused to sign it. That was the pro-Russian move.
- guard-of-terra 13y ago"The EU treaty was ready to go" Did it mystically became ready to go, or did Yanukovych's apparatus made concrete steps to getting the EU treaty ready despite being Russian puppet? If he is a Russian puppet, how this EU treaty ever got on the table?
- forgottenpass 13y agoOK, you already provided clarification for his statement. Now it looks like you're being pedantic for no good reason or just trying to start shit with IgorPartola.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]