3 ms·
Does this really happen? Does this count? Another soldier, Staff Sgt. Daniel Shannon, told CBS that his PTSD changed him completely. "I started smashing furni
by gruseom 17y ago
Does this really happen?
Does this count?
Another soldier, Staff Sgt. Daniel Shannon, told CBS that his PTSD changed him completely. "I started smashing furniture, very rapidly; so I didn’t know what I was doing ‘til it happened. I’d get mad so fast, so angry fast, and just lash out." (http://www.thecommentfactory.com/irregular-army-the-prevalence-of-mental-illness-in-the-us-military-2217 http://www.thecommentfactory.com/irregular-army-the-prevalen...)
It only takes a bit of googling to find all sorts of information on suicide, substance abuse, domestic violence, and so on, in the military. Here's a pretty compelling and sad story:
http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2007/02/11/told_to_wait_a_marine_dies/ http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2007/02/11/told_t...
The problem has gotten so bad that the US military has embarked on programs to try to destigmatize therapy and to convince soldiers to do something about suicidal mates.
So yes, obviously this stuff really happens.
Edit: as it happens, NPR led with a story tonight about violence and mental illness among veterans: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=106789003 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1067890....
- byrneseyeview 17y agoI don't doubt that people flip out. I don't even doubt that thousands of people among the millions who served in the military have flipped out. What I'm wondering about is whether otherwise undamaged people who repress their emotions eventually go nuts, or whether people who control their emotions end up in control of their emotions. People who eat small portions generally don't suddenly devour a turkey. People who only have one drink a night one night a month don't suddenly become alcoholics. Self-control doesn't necessarily mean that a problem compounds; it can be the solution to a problem, instead.
- gruseom 17y agoUnless I'm missing your point, the argument seems circular: if someone "flips out" then they must have been "damaged" in the first place. Aren't emotions part of being human? Long-term negation of one's being isn't likely to have zero consequences. I think a better analogy might be sex, repression of which certainly does mean that a problem compounds, at least for most people. But this discussion is possibly too abstract to be resolvable.
- kareemm 17y ago> What I'm wondering about is whether otherwise undamaged people who repress their emotions eventually go nuts, or whether people who control their emotions end up in control of their emotions. imho the opposite of repressing one's emotions is not controlling them; it's bottling them up. to me, controlling one's emotions means feeling the pain, happiness, sorrow, anger, whatever, and then choosing how you want to act based on feeling that emotion. most people assume that emotion dictates behavior, but you always have a choice about how to react. i.e. you can feel the sting when someone insults you, but you can choose not to punch him even though you're feeling hurt. bottling up one's emotions, otoh, represses them. you choose to ignore (usually negative) emotions. these are the ones that tend to come up in destructive ways later on.