3 ms·
Do you think the externalized costs of car-sharing services are greater than the externalized costs of government-regulated taxi services?
by baddox 13y ago
Do you think the externalized costs of car-sharing services are greater than the externalized costs of government-regulated taxi services?
- rayiner 13y agoDepends on the location. In New York City, cabs are required to carry $100k per person/$300k per event liability insurance, versus the $25k/$50k state minimum, which is all you can expect Uber drivers to have. So more cost is passed back to the cab company in the form of insurance premiums, and less is externalized onto the public. Moreover, in return for indulging the fiction that cab drivers are independent contractors, the public extracts certain concessions in return for taking on the externalized costs of accidents. Cab companies have to accept regulated rates (that are lower than what Uber charges), and have to agree to serve the whole city.
- harryh 13y agoIt's worth noting that it was the SF cab system's complete failure to adequately serve the whole city that gave birth to Uber in the first place.
- rayiner 13y agoI think cab systems have a lot of problems, for example the under supply of medallions in New York. I would favor abandoning the scheme altogether, and just requiring Uber-like businesses to carry a lot of liability insurance and meet certain requirements for driver identification. But while the existing system exists, and cabs have restrictions Uber doesn't, I don't think its fair for Uber to basically run a cab company while ignoring cab regulations.