4 ms·
There is a conflict between letting people use tags for whatever meaning is natural to them, and mildly enforcing a 'consensus' meaning. I'm currently working
by gojomo 17y ago
There is a conflict between letting people use tags for whatever meaning is natural to them, and mildly enforcing a 'consensus' meaning.
I'm currently working on a system where starting a tag with a specific character implies 'consensus definition'. Each such tag has a corresponding wiki page where users can hammer out the common standards for its use/meaning.
For now, the special character is ':' -- the '#' of '#hashtags' presents problems mapping into neat URLs.
So for example, the tag 'photowalk' would mean whatever each user individually intends it to mean. There's no expectation of common meaning, even though in many cases a useful concordance may occur (as in any mixed personal/public tagging system). OTOH, ':photowalk' means exactly what the matching /wiki/:photowalk page documents it to mean. If you use it incorrectly, people and the system will nudge you to clean up your usage. (In particular, later users can essentially nullify your mistaken tag in a manner analogous to correcting a wiki edit, by applying a '-:photowalk' tag.)