3 ms·
What you're saying is that the government should have control of any money transaction, because otherwise criminals can use it. I can only notice two things her
by smsm42 13y ago
What you're saying is that the government should have control of any money transaction, because otherwise criminals can use it. I can only notice two things here:
1. The argument can apply to absolutely any other aspect of life - if it's useful, criminals can use it, so the government should have tight control on it. For example, criminal enterprises are much easier to conduct if you can move around on the roads freely. We can not have that, ergo we have to institute regular routine checkpoints where you have to routinely prove to the law enforcement officers you are going around on legitimate business and they should keep the database of all your movements and require all road operators to report all your movement to the government movement tracking center, in case you later prove to be a criminal. Etc., etc.
2. You can not have both money laundering laws and bitcoin (or any non-governmental money system) as it is now. If you keep the former, the government will either subjugate or shut down the latter. Either bitcoin loses virtually all its anonymity and distributed control features and allows the government to control it the same way it controls regular money, with same regulations and roadblocks, or mere touching bitcoin or related technologies will become a crime. You can see how it works with drugs - anything that can be classified as related to drugs or precursor to drugs or can be used in relation to anything to do with drugs is outlawed. Bitcoin will inevitably follow one of these roads - or maybe both.
- nhaehnle 13y agoOn your first point: The world is not as black and white as you tend to see it. jahewson probably does not think that government should control everything related to money. However, society has a legitimate interest to keep a check on large flows of money [0]. Government law enforcement is a part of that. (edited to emphasize quantifiers) On your second point: Money laundering laws and bitcoin are compatible. You just have to make sure you comply with the laws when you run a business using bitcoin. Bitcoin is already only pseudonymous at best, and it practice it will be quite easy to eliminate anonymity; and distributed control features are not necessary to prosecute those who use bitcoin for money laundering, as the article under discussion clearly shows. [0] In case it isn't obvious: money leads to power, and society needs to keep power in check. Therefore, society needs to keep (large flows of) money in check.
- smsm42 13y ago1. This is not an argument, this is refusal to address the argument by repeating a platitude. The fact is that the argument "criminals can use it, therefore it must be tightly controlled" is applicable to anything. Yes, it is not currently applied to anything, because of political constellations and expediency and current needs of various power groups. But if you support this argument, you are supporting it wholesale, or abandoning logic and resorting to "I like this, but I hate that, logic be damned". You'll be in a big company with the latter, but it is nothing to be proud of. Same argument you are using for money can be applied to information, people, etc. What you are saying basically that everything should be controlled by the government as soon as the government feels it wants it. This is a consistent viewpoint, but you should not be refusing to admit it. 2. I never said money laundering laws and bitcoin are incompatible. What I said is the properties of bitcoin which make it attractive now as money (as opposed to speculative commodity, for example) - i.e. independence from government, anonymity, etc. - are incompatible with those laws and with the motivations that lie behind those laws. Just as we discovered that secure communications are incompatible with government's need for surveillance, and the secure communications lost.
- nhaehnle 13y agoActually, my response to your first point gives you a very clear and useful test for deciding whether "criminals can use $FOO, therefore $FOO must be tightly controlled" actually applies to $FOO. That test is: Is owning/dealing in large amounts of $FOO specifically relevant for having power? Three examples that lie on different points of the spectrum: Criminals can eat hamburgers. Should hamburgers be tightly controlled? Ask yourself: Is owning/dealing in large amounts of hamburgers specifically relevant for having power? Criminals drive cars. Should cars be tightly controlled? Ask yourself: Do large amounts of cars lead to power? Criminals use guns. Should guns be tightly controlled? Ask yourself: Do large amounts of guns lead to power? And so on...
- smsm42 13y agoOwning large amount of steel or wool or orange juice could make you a billionaire. Billionaires usually have a lot of power. >>> Is owning/dealing in large amounts of hamburgers specifically relevant for having power? Sure, if you control hamburger market for a large city, you would have lots of power. See also agricultural lobby - they produce a lot of food and have a lot of power because they produce food. >>> Do large amounts of cars lead to power? Definitely. Having large amount of cars, you could cause traffic jams anytime and cause immense economic harm. Or you could deliver stuff really quickly and earn billions of dollars and buy a dozen of congressmen with these billions, gaining a lot of power. Having a real lot of basically anything could give you power. And note that government controls even minute amounts of money which give you no power whatsoever - low boundary for reporting requirements if a puny $10K, which wouldn't even buy you a decent car.
- onetwofiveten 13y agoI think point 1 is to do with how you understand the argument. Logically the argument "X is bad, Y facilitates X therefore Y is bad" can be applied to pretty much anything. But I think the real justification is meant to be that the reduction in crime that results from regulating large money transfers justifies the loss of freedom involved. I don't know if that's true (I've never seen any statistics on this subject) but I think that's really what is being argued. edit: Also, of course, whether or not you agree with the argument strongly depends on the values you place on crime and freedom.
- smsm42 13y ago>>> I don't know if that's true (I've never seen any statistics on this subject) I don't think 99.999% of people that are arguing this ever seen any statistics about it, let alone can explain how exactly they know how much reduction in crime justifies how much loss in freedom. I think it's just thing people say because they read somewhere that it is something you say when those pesky libertarians ask you why our freedoms are being eroded. "Oh, it's justified by reduction in crime and safety of the children, go away!" - and presto, they go away.