4 ms·
Regardless of legality the question you really should have asked is "how much will it cost me to purchase my freedom via the legal system, and am I willing and
by VLM 13y ago
Regardless of legality the question you really should have asked is "how much will it cost me to purchase my freedom via the legal system, and am I willing and able to pay it".
If you're only willing to pay $100 for your freedom, and they're willing to put up $500 worth of nuisance legal roadblocks in your way, they won. On the other hand, if they're only willing to spend $5000 max to own you as their property, and you're willing you spend $10000 to gain your freedom, you've won. Doesn't matter if its objectively legal or not, its shouldn't even be part of your decision. Now its very important to your lawyer and his strategy and the related costs, but figuring that stuff out is his specialty. Every slave has a sale price, the legal system will figure it out. Might be a lot more or a lot less than you think. Your legal rep will let you know.
It strikes me as a dumb idea from a liability standpoint to want to own a developer as a slave, thinking of malware and the like, or even just innocent bugs.
Good luck.
- kohanz 13y agoFor the employer, especially, the cost would extend beyond a direct financial one. It would be difficult to pursue such a legal path against a current/former employee without other current and potential future employees catching wind of it. I imagine it would be a massive blow to the reputation and hence recruiting power of any organization that was perceived as unfairly penalizing an employee for working on something unrelated to his day job in his own spare time.
- DanBC 13y agoOP is in the UK. Parties to a court case should show reasonable attempts to sort that out before going to court. Costs can be awarded. Your advice seems to fit a US, not UK, situation. (But obviously IANAL).
- walshemj 13y agoI would agree for normal employment disputes you have to use the "approved" procedures not quite sure if this applys for disputes over IP. For example if an employer ignores the rules on sacking /redundancy they can get additional fines on top of the normal penalty - courts do not like people taking this piss
- VLM 13y agoI'm well aware OP is in .uk but is there anything fundamentally different about their legal and economic system that blocks my basic argument of: They want to put X amount of roadblock in your way, and you are willing to put Y amount of effort to move the roadblock and all that matters is X<Y or X>Y. And depending on the strategy of the hired guns aka lawyers doing the fighting that effort could be measured in all manner of things, money, labor time, clock time, paperwork, nuisances, things of that nature. But fundamentally if they decide they own you, you need to figure out how much it'll cost to gain your freedom, and are you willing to pay it. And HN won't be able to estimate better than perhaps 4 orders of magnitude how much it'll cost, but your paid legal representation can probably figure it out pretty well. Lets consider the rules about sacking, if the company knows the court will fine them $100K but they've got $150K worth of hate to dispose of you, well, you're gone because 100 < 150. Your employer probably being much bigger than you are, they likely have better legal representation, and likely have an excellent idea how much it will cost them to provide a certain level of annoyance to you. My point still stands.. The legalities don't matter unless you're one of the hired guns working on your strategy, what matters is how much they're willing to spend to mess with you, vs how much you are willing to spend, vs what kind of deal and trades you're willing to make. It may very well be next to nothing if they don't really care. Or maybe if you're going into direct opposition with a better product, they'll spend their entire net worth, which likely exceeds yours.
- DanBC 13y agoPeople claim damages. They have to show that these are reasonable damages. They can also apply to have costs of legal action awarded to them. Thus a company could attempt to snow under someone bringing legal action, but that's just driving costs up so if they lose, and costs are awarded, they've just increased the amount they have to pay. Their lawyers + your lawyers + awarded monies.
- VLM 13y agoWell, I can try one last time... "Their lawyers + your lawyers + award" < "what the company is willing to spend as a roadblock" then the company does it. Doesn't matter if they'll win or not, just is the roadblock worth the cost? Or if its not, then it doesn't. Or, a slightly different formula for calculating costs doesn't change the rules of the game. Or an analogy... imagine taking the board game "monopoly" to the .uk, would changing the $ to pound-symbol and swapping the costs of houses -n- hotels really fundamentally change the game? No.
- walshemj 13y agoI dont think UK lawyers take $ its £ and for the really posh ones they still bill in Guineas (21 Sillings in old money)