3 ms·
"the whole web startup concept seems broken. it's not about real solutions and sustainable businesses, but rather a giant get rich quick scheme." Well, somethi
by hga 13y ago
"the whole web startup concept seems broken. it's not about real solutions and sustainable businesses, but rather a giant get rich quick scheme."
Well, something like that is always going to be a motivation of your investors.
The real problem is that except for rare exceptions like Facebook, our government has destroyed the IPO exit, with SarBox in 2002 being the last nail in the coffin. I think a lot of people haven't internalized this yet, that that investment model which had a fantastic 4 decade run starting with late-50's legal and/or regulatory changes, is OVER.
Silicon Valley/the Bay area really became magic during it, but the game has changed, and in such a way that it threatens the whole ecosystem. In that every acqui-kill (thanks for the term, _random_) means N more screwed users, meaning that many fewer people willing to take a chance on a startup of this nature.
In my case, there are more than a few companies like this that I've thought I'd really like to use, but the risk/reward ratio is just too marginal. Those that have gotten successful, have a business model that looks viable, and have clearly decided not to get acqui-killed, like GitHub and FastMail, sure. A company like Picnik, forget it.
- binxbolling 13y agoI don't know much about this subject, so can you explain what "our government has destroyed the IPO exit" actually means? What was the investment model with a four-decade run that is now over, and how does it differ from the current model?
- hga 13y agoThis is rather a lot you're asking for, and this is widely and well documented. Although only of historic value now, which is sort of my point. Let's start with the most basic of basics, the "greater fool" principle. In that when someone makes an investment, they intend to get a return on it, perhaps interest and return of the principle for a CD or other loan, or being able to sell their stock to a "greater fool" then they. But investments in privately held companies are famously illiquid. If you own 10% of Brand New Web Startup (BNWS), ignoring whatever contractual conditions there may be on selling your share, you can only sell it to a "qualified investor", i.e. not a widow or orphan but a person of documented wealth (and that's been tightened recently). And for these sorts of small companies finding a buyer can be extremely difficult. This is generally true even if the company is well established, nicely profitable, and looks to have a good future. It's called the "cashing out" problem, and my father made more than a small amount of money helping founders and investors in small companies do that. So that's the general background. One route opened up in the late '50s (this is from memory, and I don't remember exactly what the detail was, venture capital preceded this), is an Initial Public Offering, where you use an investment bank to offer a fraction of your company to the general public, as shares of stock. If this transaction is successfully completed, you and the investment bank have big bags of money, and many generic, not necessarily "qualified", investors have shares of stock in your company. And your company is now "public", it has shares traded on an exchange, those shares are liquid, and you're subject to a whole lot of law and regulations, again, to protect those widows and orphans who are now allowed to buy a part of your company. Sarbanes-Oxley was the final nail in the coffin of going public with an IPO because it made being a public company unreasonably expensive, onerous, and legally dangerous. Almost all companies that would have previously paid back their venture capitalists through an IPO have to use another route, and being bought by a big company is the easiest and perhaps most common method (but one that most of the time is ruinous, the history of high tech mergers and acquisitions is horrible). Our host made his money this way, selling Viaweb to Yahoo, and you can look up some of the aftermath in his essays. This, BTW, no doubt has something to do with VCs' having flat returns for the last decade.