7 ms·
I'm confused. You signed on to be paid $X/month, you worked a month and were paid $X. Later you renegotiated the contract to be paid $Y < X/month, you worked a
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
I'm confused. You signed on to be paid $X/month, you worked a month and were paid $X. Later you renegotiated the contract to be paid $Y < X/month, you worked a month and were paid $Y. If you want to work elsewhere for $X or $2X or whatever, you can.
Downside risk: you signed on to be paid S shares/month or P% of profits. You worked a month and the share price tanked. You already took the loss.
- Adirael 13y agoEmployees are negotiating from a vulnerable position when the options are "take pay cut or good luck finding a new job".
- mattstreet 13y agoAdd to that the "American Dream" of owning a house and therefore being more likely to be stuck looking for work in only one area.
- pdonis 13y agoYou left out an option: start your own business. What the Reuters article tells me is that there is a large pool of available labor for new businesses to use. Why aren't more people taking advantage of this opportunity?
- unclebucknasty 13y agoFunny that you post that question on a forum full of people who know well from first-hand experience how difficult it is to start a successful business.
- pdonis 13y agoI didn't say it wasn't difficult. Of course if the choice is between having a steady, reliable job and starting your own business, it's a lot easier to choose the steady, reliable job. But the whole point of the article in Reuters is that the job is not steady and reliable any more; that changes the relative risks involved. Also, to the extent that it's hard to start a business because of government regulation (which is a large extent), the obvious response is to remove the regulations that make it hard to start a business. That would mean more people starting businesses, hence more new jobs available for other people who are currently out of work. Funny how the Reuters article doesn't mention that.
- unclebucknasty 13y ago>the whole point of the article in Reuters is that the job is not steady and reliable any more That's circular reasoning where this thread is concerned. People are saying here that corporations should be sharing the upside with employees. You are saying that since they are not, people should start businesses. You're changing the subject and giving the corporations a pass. >to the extent that it's hard to start a business because of government regulation (which is a large extent), the obvious response is to remove the regulations that make it hard to start a business. Sorry about the delay. Took me a while to wipe the vomit from keyboard. Seriously, while these regulatory complaints are something that we tend to hear from people with certain political affiliations, I challenge you to cite references to actual regulations that are to any "large extent" preventing actual small businesses from starting. In fact, the implication in the Reuter's article is that businesses are doing just fine in the current regulatory environment. They are more profitable than ever at the expense of the worker. And, I think the HN populace exemplifies the actual difficulty in starting successful businesses. I doubt many here will cite regulations as a key challenge. Instead, it's actual business problems, such as product development, finding market-fit, competition, marketing, lack of capital, inability to scale, etc.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoHmm. Downvoted, but no one actually refuted my assertions. Nice.
- alpeb 13y ago>Sorry about the delay. Took me a while to wipe the vomit from keyboard Not nice.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoAh. Style points. I get it.
- pdonis 13y agoPeople are saying here that corporations should be sharing the upside with employees. You are saying that since they are not, people should start businesses. That's part of what I'm saying, but not all. Another part of what I'm saying is that, if the premise is that current corporations are not sharing enough upside with employees, then one obvious response is to start a business that does share upside with employees. If that's really as big a deal as people are claiming, employees should flock to such a business. Only some of those who are now dissatisfied would actually have to start such businesses; the rest could simply choose to work for them because they treat employees better. I challenge you to cite references to actual regulations that are to any "large extent" preventing actual small businesses from starting. First of all, it's not just starting but growing businesses that should be less impeded by regulation. Sure, start a business with only a few employees and the burden might not be too bad (depending on what kind of business it is--see below); but hit a fairly small threshold number of employees and all of a sudden you have regulations galore that you have to comply with or a dozen government agencies will come after you. As for regulatory barriers to starting businesses, here are a few off the top of my head: professional licensing, even for professions like hairdressing where any putative benefit to the customer is far outweighed by the costs of the barrier to entry; zoning laws that clearly go way beyond any public benefit; government sweetheart deals for companies like cable providers, which prevent all kinds of competition in the ISP arena. That's just from a few minutes of brainstorming; I'm sure there are plenty more examples. the implication in the Reuter's article is that businesses are doing just fine in the current regulatory environment. That's because they (i.e., existing businesses) paid good money for the current regulatory environment. That does not at all imply that said environment is good for potential competitors of those existing businesses; if it were, they'd be complaining to their politicians that they weren't getting their money's worth. I doubt many here will cite regulations as a key challenge. Instead, it's actual business problems, such as product development, finding market-fit, competition, marketing, lack of capital, inability to scale, etc. But all of these business problems are also faced by existing businesses. Markets are not static; a product-market fit that worked fine yesterday might not work fine today, and businesses that serve their customers well often have to reinvent themselves. The response of many existing businesses (the music and movie industries being two outstanding examples), instead of reinventing themselves, is to try to outlaw their competition. The fact that those businesses continue to make profits even though there are obvious ways in which they are not serving their customers well (let alone their employees) indicates that their political efforts to get the playing field tilted in their favor have been successful.
- VLM 13y ago"If you want to work elsewhere for $X or $2X or whatever, you can." No, you can't. Government regulations and tax codes were purchased by the companies to eliminate competition and centralize capital, such that there is only one monopoly provider of car factory jobs in your area. The .com and .gov merger made the mess, they should have to clean it up. If there was a competitive commodity free-ish market, then your plan makes sense. Sometimes that exists. Usually, very intentionally, it is prevented from existing.
- VexXtreme 13y agoThere is nothing to be confused about, the scenario is pretty straightforward: you are presented with a (non)choice of either taking a pay cut or finding a box waiting for your on your desk. By being placed in this position, you have already been placed in a predicament where you have to accept the financial downside either in the form of taking a pay cut or having to find a new job. Again, the downside has already manifested and you are left dealing with the situation. So how exactly has being a salaried employee protected your from the said financial downside? When you're a 20something techie living in the Valley, it really doesn't matter since you'll have 5 offers waiting in your inbox tomorrow. When you're a 50 year old blue collar worker with a family, a mortgage and maybe a medical condition, this kind of situation can ruin your life. Most company owners don't readily share profits with their employees when their company is doing well but don't have a problem downsizing and cutting salaries across the board when they aren't doing so well. Since it's impossible to guarantee somebody income (even the best companies will go through rough patches), the only fair thing for managers to do is to share more wealth with the people who created that wealth when the times are good.
- yummyfajitas 13y ago...you have already been placed in a predicament where you have to accept the financial downside either in the form of taking a pay cut or having to find a new job. Again, the downside has already manifested and you are left dealing with the situation. You seem to be confusing your wages with a bond or perhaps a call option. Just because you sold something at a price $X does not mean you own some right to continue selling it at the same price. And if someone chooses not to keep paying you an old price, you have lost nothing - you simply have not gained as much as you thought you might. Being a salaried employee protects your 50 year old blue collar worker from downside because the 30 years worth of savings he piled up is completely safe even if the company goes insolvent.
- namdnay 13y ago> Being a salaried employee protects your 50 year old blue collar worker from downside because the 30 years worth of savings he piled up is completely safe even if the company goes insolvent Except that a blue collar family with children don't exactly "pile" up savings... and most of those savings are tied up in his house, whose value is closely correlated to local employment. It's obvious that you are neither a blue collar worker, 50, or with children, so try to see things from that point of view instead of simply projecting your personal political beliefs
- unclebucknasty 13y agoThe downside scenario you laid out also applies to executives who DO share the upside. Still confused?