9 ms·
Business income is volatile. The business made a $2B profit in one particular year, whereas in other years they made losses that nearly destroyed them. Somehow
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Business income is volatile. The business made a $2B profit in one particular year, whereas in other years they made losses that nearly destroyed them. Somehow I suspect when the business took losses, the employees did not return their wages.
Unless you want employees to share the downside of business income volatility, it's unreasonable to expect them to share the upside.
- valisystem 13y ago> Business income is volatile. Yet, a very few concentrates a bigger share every year.
- andyjohnson0 13y ago"Unless you want employees to share the downside of business income volatility, it's unreasonable to expect them to share the upside." Can you justify that? It seems like one of those statements that is designed to appear correct without provoking concious analysis. Kind of like "truithiness" [1]. Isn't there rather a lot of evidence that properly implemented profit sharing results in more motivated, productive employees? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe justification is simple - a call option is worth more than a forward with the same strike price. If employees are to receive their market rate in cash (call it $X), they can receive $X worth of forward contracts, or $X worth of call options. If they choose call options, either the value of the contracts or the strike price will need to be lower. So more precisely, the reasonable choices would be wages, profit sharing in upside and downside, or lower wages + profit sharing in upside only. Profit sharing works great when employees have the ability to significantly affect profits. Traders/hedge fund managers are a great example of this. For manufacturing employees, a piece rate (rather than hourly rate) would be a similar way to create such incentives.
- eru 13y agoThe employees do sell a put option in the form of "employee can be fired", though. And the shareholders are only liable up to their equity invested.
- erichocean 13y agoSo more precisely, the reasonable choices would be wages, profit sharing in upside and downside, or lower wages + profit sharing in upside only. In another comment, someone asked about the executives who get paid and then "only have upside", as if that somehow proved that employees should also get an upside. Not so: executives are the last option: lower wages + profit sharing in upside only. Employees are—literally—taking the first option. If they want the last option, they can become executives. We don't have a legally-mandated cast system in this country, anyone who is competent can become an executive and take option three. And the wages really are lower for executives who only have upside potential. If you are an executive (not a manager, an executive) you can either run your own company, or run someone else's company. If you run your own company, you've got upside and downside risk. If you run someone else's company, you have (much) smaller upside potential, but that's compensated by: (a) lower, but guaranteed, wages + (b) no downside potential. It's a reasonable trade for a lot of executives to make.
- Quequau 13y agoYou are of course obviously correct. Employees, at least those earning income from real labor, always share the downside of business income volatility. In fact, it's arguably an outsized share. One simply needs to observe the various employment metrics, and their rate of change. Particularly those tracking layoffs, discharges, and other involuntary separations initiated by employers. What's perhaps even more illustrative are the comparisons of job requirements and starting salaries for positions with similar responsibilities; found in employment advertisements before, during, and after a "business cycle". In fact I've read several studies showing that people who happen to graduate and enter the workforce during the nadir of financial crises earn, over the course of their entire career, substantially lower wages as compared to people who simply happen to enter the workforce at any other point of the business cycle.
- syntaxfree 13y agoThey share some risk in the form of correlations to the actual risk to their employment contracts. But employees who are fired during downturns walk away with all of their human capital and most of their future earning potential (minus what the firing signals in their CV), while the downturn chips away at the firm's capital. Let me put this another way: no one is really entitled to a job; not in the way their entitled to their properties, which have a _title to their name_. Capital, on the other hand, risks its very entitlement. Employees don't have any assets seized during a downturn. If they wanted to share in the risk and return, they could have bought stock.
- wycx 13y agoI think the word you are looking for is "sophistry". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophistry#Modern_usage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophistry#Modern_usage
- pjc50 13y agoEmployees _do_ share the downside, when job cuts are made.
- vidarh 13y agoThese people did share in the downside: They cut extremely substantial wage cuts. Now they are not sharing in the upside. Guess why many of these unions play hardball?
- ams6110 13y agoMaybe they would have been better off buying stock instead of paying union dues?
- simonh 13y agoBecause doubling your exposure to the risks in a business by both working for it and tying up your savings in it as well is such a brilliant idea?
- twoodfin 13y agoSo they should get the rewards without the risk? By claiming it would be a poor investment for someone who can't afford the risk, you're implicitly arguing that the actual owners are taking a bigger risk than the employees, and thus it's unsurprising that they capture the rewards from growth.
- simonh 13y agoWorking for a company that could go bust at any moment isn't sharing in it's risks? Really?
- twoodfin 13y agoAny company could go bust at any moment, and the only risk to you is the transactional costs of finding a new job. Those could be high, but it's not your current/prospective employer that's determining what that amount is, it's a function of the labor market and your own value. Beyond that, it's not as if you're putting any of your own money on the table. Ownership (whether that be private management or shareholders) is putting their money on the table. If you'd like a higher risk/reward level, negotiate for equity or other variable compensation.
- teh_klev 13y agoSurely businesses and the people who run them (i.e. board level) should have a moral and fiscal responsibility to bank cash to cover for the lean years rather than splashing out their profits on shareholders and senior board members. Most employees (other than trying to be more productive) have no control over what decisions business owners make (such that they roller coaster between profit and losses year by year) so why should they share the downside? It's not as if they get the same magnitudes of rewards as board level staff do to allow them to buffer themselves financially for downturns.
- mhurron 13y ago> moral and fiscal responsibility Left to their own devices there are no morals in business. The only fiscal responsibility is to keep profits high. > Most employees ... have no control over what decisions business owners make ... so why should they share the downside? You mean the Human Resources. You don't complain when any other resource is sold or retired to save money, why should the business care specially about this resource type?
- gjm11 13y ago(I am having trouble figuring out whether you wrote what you did with tongue in cheek and deliberate cynicism. I'm taking it at face value, and apologize if I've misconstrued.) > why should the business care specially about this resource type? Because people are often hurt when they are "sold or retired to save money" whereas, so far at least, other "resources" don't have that capacity. This is also the reason why, generally, people cannot be explicitly bought or sold as other resources can. This is widely considered a Good Thing, although indeed an idealized amoral business (or its owners) might well think it unfortunate.
- mhurron 13y ago> whether you wrote what you did with tongue in cheek and deliberate cynicism No it was unfortunately serious. > people are often hurt If you still believe that any business still cares about this you haven't been paying attention. If you are not at the top, you are just a cog in a machine and will be treated as such. You are just a human resource, a resource that is one of the largest, if not the largest, singly money drain. As I said, left to their own devices a business does not have any moral duty and the only fiscal duty they pursue is maximizing profits for themselves.
- VexXtreme 13y ago> Unless you want employees to share the downside of business income volatility, it's unreasonable to expect them to share the upside. This is an incredibly dishonest statement. Employees DO indeed share the downside of business income volatility by being forced to take pay cuts when their company is going through a rough patch. I see it all the time and I've had it happen to me. Why are we pretending this is not the case?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI'm confused. You signed on to be paid $X/month, you worked a month and were paid $X. Later you renegotiated the contract to be paid $Y < X/month, you worked a month and were paid $Y. If you want to work elsewhere for $X or $2X or whatever, you can. Downside risk: you signed on to be paid S shares/month or P% of profits. You worked a month and the share price tanked. You already took the loss.
- Adirael 13y agoEmployees are negotiating from a vulnerable position when the options are "take pay cut or good luck finding a new job".
- mattstreet 13y agoAdd to that the "American Dream" of owning a house and therefore being more likely to be stuck looking for work in only one area.
- pdonis 13y agoYou left out an option: start your own business. What the Reuters article tells me is that there is a large pool of available labor for new businesses to use. Why aren't more people taking advantage of this opportunity?
- unclebucknasty 13y agoFunny that you post that question on a forum full of people who know well from first-hand experience how difficult it is to start a successful business.
- jbooth 13y agoThere's a graph out there, or several, showing annual real median income plotted against productivity gains. Income has lagged in the aggregate, significantly. It's also lagged when plotted against GDP. Both since the early 80s. Volatility's a red herring. Look at the 3-decade trendline.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIt's true that median income does not well correlated with mean productivity. What is the relevance to this topic?
- jbooth 13y agoYou can slice it any way you want, the preponderance of evidence points to median and average wages both trailing productivity in the long run. Arguments about short-run volatility that don't address this fact are hand-wavy.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWhy would productivity be related to wages? To put it concretely, if I replace 4/5 workers with a small shell script, does that mean the 5'th worker deserves a pay raise? (For the sake of argument, say his work and output has not changed at all.)
- jbooth 13y agoIf you're working there, it would be a case of the 6th worker, you, replacing 4/5 of his peers with a shell script. Would you deserve a raise? If you're being anecdotal, you can justify whatever you want. In the aggregate, wages have lagged productivity, corporate profits have skyrocketed while US wages have stagnated relative to inflation.
- nkoren 13y agoEmployees routinely share in the downside risk by losing their jobs.