4 ms·
I've graphed employee compensation and business profits on the same graph. Not seeing much correlation. Compensation mostly goes up. Business profits go up and
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
I've graphed employee compensation and business profits on the same graph. Not seeing much correlation. Compensation mostly goes up. Business profits go up and down.
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fredgraph.png?g=rnM http://research.stlouisfed.org/fredgraph.png?g=rnM
I don't get it.
- digitalengineer 13y agoCould it be pensions? After bankruptcy they can dump those expensive plans. (Like the city of Detroid and other states already did).
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNowadays you are only allowed to underfund government pensions (USPS excluded). Private sector pensions must be fully funded - i.e., if an employee has vested a pension with an actuarial value of $20k, the company must put $20k into a separate fund to pay for it. (Some old pension plans are grandfathered to escape this, however.)
- malka 13y agoExcept that $20K today may not have the same value as $20K in 30 years.
- erichocean 13y agoSo, lobby the government to enact a law that adds X newly-printed dollars to each pension each year based on the government's own inflation calculation. Then the value of the pension each year would stay the same, and even better, the pension would not need to invest in risky assets. (If you want, mandate that the pension invest in T-bills, and then cover the difference.) This kind of approach involves no new taxes, and there's absolutely no reason to "borrow" the money from the Federal Reserve either, or future generations, or the general public via T-bills. Literally, you just need to change the amount of money each pension "has" on the books. The banks are regulated, and they'd be forced to except the updated balances by law.
- mattmanser 13y agoLook at the graph again, work growth seem to be approaching a maximum, with it slowing heavily in the last few decades while corporate profits seem to be following an exponential type growth with a temporary drop in the recent recession. Intentionally or not, your graph is incredibly manipulative, including not choosing a base-line zero on the y-axis for corporate profits which hides that exponential type growth.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWhat I see is corporate profits are volatile, whereas comp increases steadily. And they don't seem to move together - i.e., a spike in corporate profits doesn't correspond to a drop in wages, or vice versa. The axes are just whatever the federal reserve site does by default. The baseline is also irrelevant to the main point - compensation and corporate profits don't seem to move together. (This fact should not be surprising at all, since sticky nominal wages are the cornerstone of most modern macroeconomic theories.)
- eloisant 13y agoYou should use nominal dollars. That would probably make it clearer that from around 2001 the profit started to skyrocket while compensation started to plateau. I wouldn't be surprised if the compensation in real dollar when down. Also, your graph doesn't show people who lost their job. If you layoff people who make the less in the company, the average compensation goes up even if nobody got a wage increase.