2 ms·
There's an easier reformulation, at least for Denmark. Denmark doesn't have a minimum wage. Instead, many wages are set via collective bargaining. (The unions a
by dalke 13y ago
There's an easier reformulation, at least for Denmark. Denmark doesn't have a minimum wage. Instead, many wages are set via collective bargaining. (The unions argue that this is more effective than a national minimum wage.)
So for Denmark let's not talk about "poverty" but "below the minimum wage for all private and public sector collective bargaining agreements", which Wikipedia tells us is 109 kroner ($19) per hour.
"There's no infinite money fountain" ... how come with all of the advances in efficiency over the century, we're still working roughly the 8 hour days from factories 100 years ago? While not infinite, surely we should be better at using that fountain by now.
I read "forced to do by the men-with-guns" often, though of course not always, from libertarians. I've always had a problem with that. There's coercion by force, certainly, but there are other ways to coerce. The government can also deny you access to things. For example, to a working water supply and sewage system, to the banking system, to telephones, to health care, to parental leave, to the judicial system, to weather reports, and so on.
Some of that can be worked around, like by going off the grid, but not all. It's very hard to travel internationally if the US refuses to issue a passport. If you don't have access to the court system, then what do you do when your neighbor decides to move the fence 3 meters closer to your house?
Indeed, I can easily consider a government based completely on the threat of the withdrawal of services rather than force. Some very rich people, and certain groups like the Amish, may be able to go it alone. Otherwise, the switching cost of leaving government services will be too high.
So no, I don't think that it's reasonable to think of government as synonymous, even poetically speaking, with coercion by force. You need only look at, say, the Viking sagas of Iceland to see how governments can exist to help reduce the overall need for coercion by force.
- judk 13y agoAn unskilled unemployed person in say NYC today has a faaaaar better life than such a person in NYC in 1914.
- dalke 13y agoYou aren't helping. This sort of statement is why debates about poverty end up all over the place. Yes, computers were once so expensive that, quoting Professor Frink, "only the five richest kings of Europe would own them". Now they just about come free in a box of cereal. The usual solutions are either 1) use something like the OECD approach, where poverty is the number of people making under 1/2 the median income, or 2) use a "relatively absolute" basket of goods concept, which includes housing and food. Instead, you hand-wave "faaaaar better", without explaining what you mean. For example, it is not "faaaaar" easier for said unskilled person in NYC to find affordable housing now than 1914. For one, zoning laws and regulations have reduced the number of boarding houses, cage hotels, and flop houses over the last century. You can have all the bandwidth you want, in your proverbial shelter under the bridge, but it won't keep you warm.
- jerf 13y ago"While not infinite, surely we should be better at using that fountain by now." Simple: We are. Or at least, there's a lot more to go around for everybody, even if overall efficiency may or may not have dropped. However, as long as resources remain finite, there are still tradeoffs; we can not escape that. I think the reason we believe we are so much poorer than we were a hundred years ago is that we got ten times richer, but our desires grew twenty times larger. We are still ten times richer even so. (Numbers made up. Especially the desires one.) "The government can also deny you access to things." Which they will be doing with force, unless you have this mental model in which the government announces "Oh, BTW, we're not letting you have any water" and your mental model's citizens just say "Oh, OK then, we'll just peacefully crawl over here and die then. Would you like us to bury ourselves for your convenience?" Indeed many people do seem to operate with this model, but I find it models reality poorly and makes bad predictions. I suppose it comes from a multigenerational civilization where government and citizens have mostly managed to live in peace, and it seems to me that seems to produce a dangerous situation in which both sides eventually forget what that peace is built on.
- dalke 13y ago"there's a lot more to go around for everybody" I think you've made an unstated assumption that it will go around to everybody. If wealth concentrates to the top over time, then most people could be worse off, and a few be spectacularly rich, even if desires remain unchanged. "Oh, OK then, we'll just peacefully crawl over here and die then." If the government utilities stop providing water and power to your house, what do you do? (I assume you want those things.) Yes, you could switch to solar, or a generator. And you could drill a well and harvest rainwater. These are high costs. Can most people afford doing that? And afford the higher maintenance? Or you might get a non-government utility to come in. Which means they need a line from the power plant and a pipe from the water works, both to your house. There's a lot of people in between who might say "no" to the request to string a power line or dig a trench across their property. (The concept of "right-of-way" requires some sort of coercion.) Yes, it's doable. There are entire communities which are off the grid. But costs time and money, which most people aren't interested in doing. Or you could sneak in and hook up to the government utilities, so each time they'll disconnect and make it harder. Or you could connect to your neighbors. Then the government disconnects them. This is inconvenience, not violence. Where's the government force in my example? But yet it is coercive, yes? When I graduated from college, I had to pay off a small library fine before I could get my diploma. The college didn't force me to pay the fee. But the threat that I wouldn't get my diploma unless I paid was a very big incentive. So I know at least one case where this model of mine makes a good prediction. "what that peace is built on". The "men-with-guns" models simplifies that to the point of farce. There are incentives to having and being part of a good government. There are means of coercion other than force. And there are men-with-guns in places without government.