2 ms·
Interesting, but I don't know if it's so valid. Precedence in the US is if someone sold something in violation of copyright, the purchasers don't have to retur
by ars 17y ago
Interesting, but I don't know if it's so valid.
Precedence in the US is if someone sold something in violation of copyright, the purchasers don't have to return it, instead the publisher is fined, with the money going to the copyright holder.
Just because Amazon could delete it, doesn't mean it should. At least not until ordered to do so by a judge.
- BearOfNH 17y agoThe analogy with a car is specious. There is just one car, as opposed to unlimited copies of a file. Plus the State has vested interests in automobile ownership and licensing. If on the other hand you had a stolen copy of _1984_ on your coffee table I very seriously doubt the police would bother to repo it, believing it to be a civil matter. My wife (who actually IS a lawyer) goes even further. If you bought your hard-copy of _1984_ in good faith (say, from a bookbinder who sold it to you instead of rebinding it for a customer), then in fact you ARE the legal owner of the book, and the customer who got screwed has to seek restitution from the bookbinder -- who might also wind up in jail guilty of fraud. I'm not sure that's justice but according to my wife, that's the law in our state.