4 ms·
I'm not an American and I'm what most people would call a "libertarian", but if you really do believe in "protection tariffs" then ask yourself if you're prepar
by paganel 13y ago
I'm not an American and I'm what most people would call a "libertarian", but if you really do believe in "protection tariffs" then ask yourself if you're prepared to pay ~$1,800 for a PS4, for example. (http://www.destructoid.com/playstation-4-will-cost-1-850-in-brazil-263741.phtml http://www.destructoid.com/playstation-4-will-cost-1-850-in-...)
- rayiner 13y agoIf it would bring jobs back to the Delaware valley, then in a heartbeat.
- fiatmoney 13y agoThe entire point is that the high cost makes domestic production more attractive, because you can offer a lower price than the foreign-produced, tariffed variety.
- ihsw 13y agoAnd when domestic production just doesn't happen, what then? Will you allow your population to languish in poverty while prices are high due to an artificial floor? PS4s are a luxury, but when we apply the same logic to necessities then that argument falls on its face fairly quickly. Tariffs are also susceptible to political wrangling, where taxes are levied selectively.
- dandelany 13y agoWe have the resources and labor force for domestic production, and there is plenty of money to be made. Nature abhors a vacuum. It would happen. > PS4s are a luxury, but when we apply the same logic to necessities then that argument falls on its face fairly quickly. So let's only apply it to non-necessities. We already have higher taxes on some luxuries, what would happen if we implemented them as import tariffs rather than sales tax?
- fiatmoney 13y ago"Necessities" are irrelevant. If you are worried about, eg, the ability of the poor to afford food, and have a simultaneous goal of promoting domestic industry, the optimal policy is income subsidies + the tariff you would have imposed anyway. In fact, you can use the tariff to finance the income subsidies, and it will work at some tariff level as long as the right proportion of the market for that good is not receiving the subsidies. Further, the industry growth prompted by the tariff is likely to disproportionately help those the income subsidy would be targeting. You'll notice the market for unskilled labor in the US is not exactly thriving. The political economy argument is more compelling, but in practice "free trade" ends up being anything but. International trade agreements usually take the form of market access conditioned on the kinds of regulation friendliest to the most politically influential (~largest) actors. This is how you get, eg, "free trade" agreements that massively strengthen copyright regimes, to the benefit of "original" content producers and the detriment of content remixers and consumers.
- felipe 13y agoBrazilian here: A local tax expert pointed out that Sony is adding a huge profit margin on top of the taxes [1]. Sony has disclosed the tax figures to the media but not their profit margin, and trying to blame it only on taxes because they know the Brazilian consumer will believe. Some suspect that Sony is importing at an even higher price than the retail US price. No one knows for sure, but clever US sellers were buying PS4 at full retail price, shipping to Brazil, paying all taxes, and still they were able to sell cheaper than the retail price of the Brazilian PS4. If Sony produced PS4 in Brazil they would pay 6% taxes instead of the 40% protection tariff. Microsoft (actually Foxconn) is doing exactly that in Brazil and that's why the XBox One is actually cheaper than a PS4. Sony simply did not want to incur the labor costs and risks associated with investing in the local tech industry. Nothing wrong with that (it's their decision), but they are not being truthful to the local consumer. [1] (in portuguese) http://info.abril.com.br/games/noticias/2013/10/sony-divulga-infografico-com-taxas-e-impostos-cobrados-em-cima-do-ps4-brasileiro.shtml http://info.abril.com.br/games/noticias/2013/10/sony-divulga...
- easytiger 13y ago> Sony simply did not want to incur the labor costs and risks associated with investing in the local tech industry. Nothing wrong with that (it's their decision), but they are not being truthful to the local consumer. You can't expect them to set up a factory in every single geopolitical location that imposes these rules.