3 ms·
JRR Tolkien Its interesting to compare the Venn diagram of this list of influential books vs "old books you should actually read as opposed to know about to co
by VLM 13y ago
JRR Tolkien
Its interesting to compare the Venn diagram of this list of influential books vs "old books you should actually read as opposed to know about to consider yourself educated". I've read Gibbon and Plutarch and Kafka and Orwell and Thucydides and Thoreau and quite a few of the others and enjoyed them immensely. I've read some of the others on the list and not enjoyed them so much. I've glanced at Principia and a couple others and Nope'd. Maxwell, no, not going to happen.
I self educated on what amounts to a great books curricula when I was a kid. Any teenage boy who claims not to like Anabasis or maybe Plutarch either has something wrong with him or is lying about having read it (or maybe got stuck with an awful translation). Some of it was tiresome, having to haul books from old fashioned public library or pay serious money in some cases. The modern tech world should be better but it isn't.
Anyway bringing it on topic for YC / HN we now have the technology to give everyone in the world a handheld device with not only "the" great books curriculum but any collection of great books curricula, although the whole "product" is not quite there... maybe only 99% of the way and terribly expensive. And that last 1% is going to be hard. I have no idea how a startup would fix that last little bit, but I'd love to see one try. Maybe a really good (free, or close to) ereader and study app containing various collections of curricula, some of which like the gutenberg editions require a bit of massaging and tidying up. Also needs some kind of markup language / links to wikipedia / merged with academic notes.
A little more education wouldn't be the end of the world.
- minopret 13y agoMany of these are surprisingly very readable, particularly if you're willing to wade into their world. For example, I find it hilarious that, in The Republic, Glaucon (if I recall correctly) complains directly about Socrates using his method that has sometimes impressed all of us or been impressed upon us as the irrefutable voice of authority. He says, practically in so many words, "You're just being a smart aleck! You ask a bunch of leading questions and get smug when we don't have immediate criticisms for your supposedly inevitable answers! But all it really means is that they're different from suggestions that we've heard before!" On the other hand, I had little success trudging through An Essay Concerning Human Understanding by John Locke. So, I'd suggest that a reader who makes a patient attempt will find that many of them open up and become old friends. If not, I wouldn't bother to suffer through. There are plenty of books to try. You can always try one again in another decade or perhaps another lifetime.