3 ms·
As far as I am aware, we do not ration health care in Canada A waiting list is rationing; a limited list of approved drugs/procedures is rationing; a ban on pr
by gojomo 17y ago
As far as I am aware, we do not ration health care in Canada
A waiting list is rationing; a limited list of approved drugs/procedures is rationing; a ban on private insurance is rationing.
There are many accounts of Canadians seeking denied or long-waitlisted procedures elsewhere, usually the USA. Some examples are listed here with regard to court cases about provincial bans on private programs:
http://www.canadianmedicinenews.com/2008/01/is-universal-healthcare-illegal.html http://www.canadianmedicinenews.com/2008/01/is-universal-hea...
If the USA adopts the same national controls, an important safety valve for Canadians will disappear (and US citizens may find themselves medical tourists elsewhere).
Results for some diseases are worse in Canada, perhaps due to limited therapies and longer waits. Here's Dick Morris plugging his new book with some figures:
http://www.dickmorris.com/blog/2009/07/09/obama-will-repeal-medicare/ http://www.dickmorris.com/blog/2009/07/09/obama-will-repeal-...
In our new book, Catastrophe, we explain - in detail and in depth - the consequences the elderly of Canada are feeling from just this kind of program. Limited colonoscopies have led to a 25% higher rate of colon cancer and a ban on the use of the two best chemotherapies are part of the reason why 42% of Canadians with colon cancer die while 31% of Americans, who have access to these two medications, survive the disease.
Overall, the death rate from cancer in Canada is 16% higher than in the United States and the heart disease mortality rate is 6% above ours’.
It's Dick Morris, so I'm sure he's spinning and shilling, but there are tradeoffs inherent to single-payer cost-controls -- some people get worse care.
- anigbrowl 17y ago* "...42% of Canadians with colon cancer die while 31% of Americans, (..), survive the disease* Wait, what? 42% of Canadians die, ok that kinda sucks if you have colon cancer. 31% of Americans survive implies to me that 69% ...don't. 69% chance of death vs 42% change of death...I'll take the 42% please. I presume this is a case of sloppy blogging rather than deliberate manipulation, but this kind of nonsense does a disservice to the complexities of the healthcare and ageing debates. I would refer people to the Economist's extensive and sober-minded coverage of these complex issues - which has also been the subject of controversy and in fact makes profoundly depressing reading, but is a deal more informative. BTW, as a European who has benefited extensively from the Euro model of healthcare growing up, it is more impersonal and less reassuring than my experience of American healthcare. But it's there for you most of the time, and you won't be forced into bankrupcty.
- gojomo 17y agoYou're right; that's sloppy writing in Morris's column. The wording is clearer in the book, which I just looked up via Amazon's search-inside-the-book. From p. 109: When government bureaucrats ration health care, the results can be a disaster. Take the grim story of colon cancer in Canada. Colorectal cancer rates are much higher in Canada (6.7 per 100,000). than in the United States (4.8 per 100,000.) And although 41 percent of cases in Canada prove fatal, only 34 percent in the United States lead to death. Even though colorectal cancer is the second leading cause of death in Canada, the drug Avastin -- the standard treatment in the United States -- is not available to patients in Canada through the government health system. "What is going on in Canada is shameful," says Barry D. Stein, president of the Colorectal Cancer Association of Canada. "This treatment, which was finally approved last year in Canada and which was long overdue, is not reaching patients who are desperately in need of... a treatment which is the standard of care in the treatment of the disease." My point is mainly there are lots of ways to ration -- dragging out both approval and access save money, at the margin, but also result in earlier deaths, at the margin. There are tradeoffs in any system. Some USians would like the Canadian system; some Canadians have to come to the US for treatments. And especially with regard to the US system, there are big externalities and innovation effects. Canada and the rest of the world get giant positive externalities from the drugs and treatments developed first in the USA's expensive, competitive market. It may be economically rational to dilly-dally on advanced techniques when some other market is leading the way; or to drive a national hard-bargain to get drugs near the cost of production when the drug is already developed. But if every country lags, and every country squeezes all the profit out of medicine, the whole world will suffer from resulting the dearth of innovation.