5 ms·
Stallmans rhetoric and ridiculous hate for apple specifically is nothing new and still makes no sense. His argument about not being able to install modified ve
by stephenr 13y ago
Stallmans rhetoric and ridiculous hate for apple specifically is nothing new and still makes no sense.
His argument about not being able to install modified versions of open source apps on ios is either a blatant lie or sheer ignorance.
But that doesn't matter - his opinion is quite obvious as soon as he uses the word "win".
It's apparently too horrendous for stallman to imagine a world where some people support and use commercial software and some support and use open source software and some support and use "free" software, without constantly getting into a pissing match.
Stallman is frankly no better than a religious fundamentalist claiming abortion and condoms are the work of the devil, and not only will they avoid them, they will lobby governments to enact laws banning such items.
- saurik 13y ago> His argument about not being able to install modified versions of open source apps on ios is either a blatant lie or sheer ignorance. This is only true if you are willing and able to pay (and are allowed to pay) Apple $99 to get into their developer program, for a limited number of devices, to get access to a now closed-source fork of LLVM (the AArch64 support is still not merged, and no code from Xcode 5 has seen the light of day now over four months later) that would let you swap in replacement code; and then, even after compiling it, you wouldn't be able to freely redistribute it to others without submitting it to Apple's store review process (which might very well reject it for any number of reasons, including "similar to existing apps", which is actually a documented rejection criteria).
- stephenr 13y agoMembership is required to distribute via the App Store, not to build and install to a device via USB. There is also nothing stopping you installing the app onto others devices the same way.
- saurik 13y agoNo: the $99 registration is required to get a provisioning profile that will let you install code onto a limited number of devices. (Have you ever done this before?...)
- orbitur 13y ago> Membership is required to distribute via the App Store, not to build and install to a device via USB. Nope, you can't install to a personal iOS device without the dev cert either. Unless you've jailbroken the device.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoNice rhetoric you have there - if only there were any arguments in it! It may be surprising to you, but fighting for a cause is not bad because you are fighting for a cause, but because you are fighting for an idiotic cause. Religious fundamentalists aren't idiots because they are fighting for something, but they are idiots because they are fighting for something that would be detrimental to society (including themselves). You may remember there were people who fought against slavery, they even lobbied government to enact laws banning slavery. If only someone had stopped those fundamentalists! Also, you might want to familiarize yourself with RMS's position sufficiently to not fall for "commercial vs. free software". RMS never opposed commercial software, in fact he is very much for commercial software. Chances are you don't have a clue what you are actually arguing against. Go, read the FSF's FAQ, so you can at least argue without using any strawmans.
- mwfunk 13y ago...and if there was even the slightest, remotest equivalence between human slavery and proprietary software, this argument might hold water. Anyway, fundamentalists are bad because fundamentalists are bad, period. Even if they're fighting for the right thing, they're still doing it for the wrong reasons, and people need to at least acknowledge that before lionizing them too much. I'd much rather get behind someone doing the right thing for the right reasons, or at least maintain a modicum of skepticism about everyone if no such leader exists.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoI would very much contest that there is no similarity between slavery and proprietary software. But that wasn't the point anyhow (you see, the fact that fighting for a cause being bad depends on the cause being bad does not in any way depend on whether your cause is similar to some super-awesome cause someone has fought for - fighting for better street lights in your neighbourhood is not bad because someone some time fought against slavery), so let's forget about that. "fundamentalists are bad because fundamentalists are bad, period" - are you serious? That is supposed to be a rational argument? Arguments of the form "x is bad because x is bad, period" are quite typical of ... fundamentalists! And you know why those are bad? Because they don't demonstrate any rational connection to the real effects the promoted values or actions would have on humanity. And now, would you mind explaining how all of that contradicts what I've been saying? Or does it?