4 ms·
From a student's point of view: I hated professors who made their own webpage just about as much as I hated Blackboard. A big downside to Blackboard was that ev
by freehunter 13y ago
From a student's point of view: I hated professors who made their own webpage just about as much as I hated Blackboard. A big downside to Blackboard was that every professor had their own way of using the tool, but it was worse with professors who made their own sites. At least on Blackboard some things were standard, and everything could be standard if the professor wasn't an ass. On their own websites, nothing was the same across classes. I'd have to learn how to use the site again every time I took a new class. Doubly true on both accounts for online classes.
Blackboard sucks, but at least it takes some work out of being a professor. Making your own site takes extra work, and extra work on top of that to make it friendly for students. They both still win out over the atrocity that is the Respondus LockDown browser, which my school required for some tests. Google it. It's bad.
- Smegger 13y agoIn my college experience it depends on the teacher that wrote the page. I had several professors that had formerly been developers, their course pages were lightyears ahead of the blackboard pages used by the rest of the faculty.
- gedrap 13y agoIn my school, probably 90% of professors create their own course web sites (I came across only 2 who use blackboard in 2.5 years). We don't have any problems you mentioned, really, most the web sites are very minimal (even without CSS, usually). It does it's job, everyone's happy. Problem solved :) for example: http://studentnet.cs.manchester.ac.uk/ugt/2013/COMP36111/ http://studentnet.cs.manchester.ac.uk/ugt/2013/COMP36111/
- M2Ys4U 13y agoThere were a few CS courses at UoM that required Blackboard... and I hated it. It became a running joke between my tutorial group and my tutor (who was, at the time, the director of undergraduate studies in the school) and sometimes they mentioned Blackboard just to make me rant. That said, you're absolutely right. The system works perfectly well, but we are talking about a computer science department here and not a humanities department. PS is Dr Latham still teaching and, more importantly, wearing those hideous shirts?
- gedrap 13y ago>>> PS is Dr Latham still teaching and, more importantly, wearing those hideous shirts? Oh yeah he is and, yes, still wearing Hawaiian shirts.
- peterstjohn 13y agoGod bless that man.
- kd0amg 13y agoOn their own websites, nothing was the same across classes. I'd have to learn how to use the site again every time I took a new class. I guess I had the advantage of less "creative" professors. Most of them did pretty much the same thing with the course web site. Click the "Syllabus" link to see the syllabus, click the "Homework Assignments" link to see the list of problem sets, etc.
- tomrod 13y ago> . A big downside to Blackboard was that every professor had their own way of using the tool, but it was worse with professors who made their own sites. In my view, this is the differentiating factor between MySpace and Facebook. On MySpace you have a lot of control over the webspace -- and it's horrible and atrocious for the visitor to the page 99% of the time. Facebook makes the layout standard, and this benefits visitors to pages because people can find the information they're looking for. (I am not a UI/UX guy, take my thoughts with a grain of salt).
- saraid216 13y agoThis is true if you're only looking at MySpace and Facebook. If you go back a decade, MySpace won the social network space because you had a lot of control over the webspace. Because setting up shop was more about expressing your personality online than about showing off your vacation pictures. > (I am not a UI/UX guy, take my thoughts with a grain of salt). Your thoughts are actually absolutely correct as long as you're not talking about social network sites. This is common wisdom in Information Architecture / User Experience. Which isn't surprising, since they wouldn't have a job otherwise.
- impendia 13y agoAn interesting point. I don't really understand it, so please allow me a question. Is there anything you would find disagreeable or unfriendly about, e.g., the following? http://www.math.sc.edu/~thornef/math142/ http://www.math.sc.edu/~thornef/math142/ To my way of thinking, this is obviously the way to present my course materials. Any friction points I'm not thinking of?
- jkimmel 13y agoAnother student here with my two cents. Your course website looks very clear, easy to use, etc. (also, I like the approach you seem to be taking with the material, I learned from the same book and always thought the convergence test guesswork was silly) Part of my personal frustration with custom Professor sites, and that of other students I know, is simply that it's yet another site to keep track of. For all the failings of large LMS's, they are effective at centralizing coursework into a location a student can check daily. When a few professors have custom sites, it's easy to forget to check one Prof's site for updates, announcements, etc. Even just for syllabus info, I have more than once gone to my LMS and groaned when I realized that I had to look up the address for a custom site or dig through bookmarks. I once had a semester where every Prof used their own site, and I had to cycle through 5 bookmarks daily to keep track of everything. TL,DR: it's simply one more thing to keep track of, increasing the friction of information acquisition from a student's perspective.
- saraid216 13y ago> Part of my personal frustration with custom Professor sites, and that of other students I know, is simply that it's yet another site to keep track of. It's worth noticing that this is a symptom of a much larger trend in academia: professors tend to be naturally siloed and need to put in effort for presenting themselves and discovering others' work. Journals seem to have some positive effect, but Elsevier seems to negate a lot of that effect. Contrast this with something like the open source community, with its registries of projects and package managers and the current (long-lasting) trend towards platforms and APIs. I think what I'm describing is what SCORM is supposed to be, but I've never actually used it, and I suspect SCORM is the XML of it. The "Yes, it does the job, but ohgodclunkymassivehugepain, save us Douglas Crockford, you're our only hope."