3 ms·
I don't think people are really criticizing Microsoft for image-mongering as such. I think they're getting nailed for the clumsiness of their recent attempts (l
by gruseom 17y ago
I don't think people are really criticizing Microsoft for image-mongering as such. I think they're getting nailed for the clumsiness of their recent attempts (like the puke ad) to outsource the development of a happening-new-image that has no connection to who or what they really are, and just sort of plaster it on and hope that anyone will be fooled by it.
Sure, corporate images are idealized and sanitized and in that sense false, but the better ones still stem from the underlying reality. Is Google purely benign? Hardly, yet "don't be evil" does express something real in their culture. Are Apple and their users members of a superior race? Hardly, yet they have produced superior designs.
Microsoft's problem is that their truly distinctive quality over the years -- their competitive ruthlessness -- doesn't lend itself to positive marketing. A campaign based on something like "We screw people. Hey, it's just business." isn't likely to win favor. Maybe it says something about Microsoft that they have trouble finding a positive image that isn't an obvious marketing concoction.
- endtime 17y ago>a happening-new-image that has no connection to who or what they really are Oh? And what is your justification for that statement? Have you worked there? I have, and I am actually surprised at how cool and fresh some of the stuff MSFT is doing is.
- gruseom 17y agowhat is your justification for that statement Longstanding observation of their products, behavior, and culture. But really, all you need to look at is the painful artificiality of the ads themselves, including the OP.