3 ms·
I find this objection lame. Satire isn't supposed to be civil. It isn't supposed to be non-misogynist or non-homophobic either. It's supposed to be fucking ruth
by gruseom 17y ago
I find this objection lame. Satire isn't supposed to be civil. It isn't supposed to be non-misogynist or non-homophobic either. It's supposed to be fucking ruthless. It's supposed to speak the unspoken truth about something, irrespective of decorum.
Obviously not every shot is going to hit the mark, and the ones that miss often seem rude, crude, or both. But when satire hits the bullseye it transcends all of those categories because of the power of truth-telling. It has been a valuable part of civil discourse, in the larger sense, for as long as civil discourse has existed.
As for this particular attempt at satire, I think it hit the target in a few places (in terms of nailing what's going on behind the original propaganda), and the rest of it reads like pretty much every other Zed Shaw blog post. So, not completely successful, but not too bad for an instant knockoff. And the original piece was so asking for it (did you read her t-shirt?) It would be interesting if other parodies pop up.
- prodigal_erik 17y agoWhich unspoken truths are those? That the author has a problem with the idea of anal sex? That he (for reference: http://farm1.static.flickr.com/147/423037071_85d564748a.jpg http://farm1.static.flickr.com/147/423037071_85d564748a.jpg) thinks the interviewee has stereotypical facial hair?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rdouble 17y agoAs for this particular attempt at satire, I think it hit the target in a few places (in terms of nailing what's going on behind the original propaganda), and the rest of it reads like pretty much every other Zed Shaw blog post Zed's no Mark Twain. He took something that was almost a perfect self-parody and then made it less funny. When I read his version I get the same uneasy feeling I get when I worked with some guys from Long Island that would download Howard Stern episodes and listen to them on repeat all day. I wonder why he bothered to expend any energy on this. It's like making fun of retarded people.
- scott_s 17y agoGoing for the shock is cheap. It's possible to do satire without going for the shock.
- ptomato 17y agoAnd yet, great satire frequently seems to go for shock. See: A Modest Proposal, 1984, quite a few of Mark Twain's short stories, Chaucer, etc.
- Scriptor 17y agoThis write-up is nowhere near comparable to those works. A Modest Proposal discussed in a frank tone the idea of selling babies as food for money. 1984 showed an ultra-totalitarian state through the eyes of someone used to it. Sure the torture scenes were ruthless, but not "shock" satire. This is something that could've been written up by an angry fourteen year old and simply calls everyone either a dick or a whore. No eloquence, nothing subtle, nothing new.
- ptomato 17y ago1984 was certainly "shock" at the time it was written. Since then many of the concepts have simply become so commonplace as to be unremarkable. And I'm certainly not claiming that this is great literature, merely providing counterexamples to the idea that "shock is cheap".
- scott_s 17y agoThere's a distinction between the meaning behind what you say, and how you say it. Trying to shock people through your "how" is cheap.
- three14 17y agoThat's a different meaning of shock. The shock in A Modest Proposal doesn't read like "I have no self control" or "Look! A drunk in the gutter."
- 17y ago