> The gal has obviously sick. Yes, Yale sent her away, but is there any actual psychiatrist here who would recommend keeping a suicidal/self-harming patient in

> The gal has obviously sick. Yes, Yale sent her away, but is there any actual psychiatrist here who would recommend keeping a suicidal/self-harming patient in any school/job situation? I would be reasonable surprised if the first round of advise from a psychiatrist to recommend quitting a job or stopping school. In the cases where it would be recommended I would bet it only happens after there is a strong alternative support network in place. So yes Yale sent her away, but it is not obvious a psychiatrist would have made the same choice. > If anything, Yale should get some credit for not black balling her; Do you think they deserve credit for making a reasonable decision? Or that Yale did a better job relative to what is standard for other Universities?