3 ms·
How good is the system at ensuring this happens? I'd be impressed if they manage to stop prosecutors from cheating.
by kevingadd 13y ago
How good is the system at ensuring this happens? I'd be impressed if they manage to stop prosecutors from cheating.
- mschuster91 13y agoPretty good at it, I can't recall any major scandal in the last few years. Suppression of evidence (regardless who the actor is, be it prosecutor or a 3rd party) is punishable by law (http://dejure.org/gesetze/StGB/274.html http://dejure.org/gesetze/StGB/274.html). However I was not able to find the possible sentences (though, I think, it includes jail time).
- SwellJoe 13y agoThere's no major scandal because it is expected, it is practiced with regularity, and it is not punished when it happens. Some friends of mine were setup by Austin Police Department undercover officers...the protest they intended to participate in would have led to misdemeanor charges. The undercover officers encouraged use of, and provided, dragon sleeves (a type of lockbox to make it harder to separate protestors who are in a sit-in or lockdown of some sort), which led to felony charges for seven of the protestors. It was entirely a lucky break that one of the undercover officers was outed (a friend of a friend recognized him from school and knew he was a cop), and with that information the lawyer was able to request all the records that showed how things went down. Had that lucky break not happened, those kids would still be in jail today and saddled with felonies. The prosecuting attorney tried to make the case that his Houston officers didn't know about it, and that it wasn't relevant to the case and that evidence shouldn't be brought up. The judge, thankfully, disagreed. In my experience, cops lie, prosecuting attorneys lie, and when they lie they face no consequences. The officers overseeing this case, and the district attorney prosecuting this, should be out of a job or, better, in jail for trying to destroy a man's life. But, to them it's just another day. They got caught this time, but dozens of others weren't lucky enough to have surveillance footage proving their innocence. I don't have a very high opinion of police or the justice system, as you may have guessed by now. But, I think it's important to stop living under the illusion that this is an isolated incident and that "most cops are good people".
- stdbrouw 13y agoI think most cops and prosecutors are good people. "Those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience."
- pgeorgi 13y agoWhat about Lothar König (http://www.dnn-online.de/dresden/web/dresden-nachrichten/detail/-/specific/Prozesspause-in-Dresden-dauert-an-Pfarrer-Koenig-sucht-die-verlorene-Leichtigkeit-1703559932 http://www.dnn-online.de/dresden/web/dresden-nachrichten/det... - sorry, I found no english article), or the NSU files (http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/intelligence-agency-slammed-for-shredding-files-linked-to-zwickau-cell-a-841759.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/intelligence-age...) that were destroyed just in time (though that wasn't the police, but the federal domestic intelligence agency)?
- mschuster91 13y agoIndeed, the Lothar König affair is something I had forgotten. And the NSU is an entirely different beast of a story - personally I think it is one or more blacker-than-black ops gone wrong and the intelligence service fucked up to properly cover their traces.
- rmc 13y agoI can't recall any major scandal in the last few years Lack of no major scandal means either: (a) The system is fair and basically works as advertised or (b) The system is so massively corrupt that it happens often enough, but that information is hidden from public view.