4 ms·
This here is the crux of the issue. Young, impressionable people believing what the school is selling. And you can argue till the end of the Earth about who's f
by secstate 13y ago
This here is the crux of the issue. Young, impressionable people believing what the school is selling. And you can argue till the end of the Earth about who's fault it is, but the reality is that the world is full of people who are in turns impressionable and opportunistic.
I loved my alma mater, but I also never for one second believed that anyone outside of the few professors I was close to and still keep in touch with, actually cared about me as a person.
The author's experience with mental health issues was a perfect shit storm of being cut down after taking their warm-fuzzy message hook-line-and-sinker, AND a broken health care system in general.
I would also argue there are no easy answers. It's not my place to suggest reforms, but if you're admitting someone to a psych ward and you know that at least one time they slashed their thigh open with a pocket knife, how can you possibly take their word for it that they aren't going to use the drawstring on their pants, or the plastic cover of a notebook to try self harm again? It's a no-win situation, and those are the worst.
The best case would probably be to abolish psych wards and give everyone one-on-one access to a counselor 24-7 so they can hang out and be 100% sure they're not in danger. But I'd also note the world has moved "forward" a lot in terms of stigmas and treatment of the mentally ill. Is their room to improve, hell yes. But to ignore the almost death-camp like environments of the homes for the feeble minded just a century ago, we're doing okay.
- DanBC 13y agoRemoving ligatures is fine. Removing actual sharps is fine. I don't know the plastic binder, so maybe removing that is fine too. Making someone strip naked for a search is not fine. Giving an intimate search is also not fine. Threatening to restrain them to a bed is not fine. Keeping them in their room is not fine. Keeping them on a locked ward is not fine. Etc etc. If her account is accurate I am shocked by how bad her treatment was. I've attended many a&e units with someone with severe deliberate self harm (much worse than described in the article) and that person got much better treatment. Not just medical clinical treatment, but the humane stuff too.