3 ms·
If you believe in software freedom for all users, then it is immoral to distribute proprietary software or enable others to do so. In that case it's not a kludg
by dalke 13y ago
If you believe in software freedom for all users, then it is immoral to distribute proprietary software or enable others to do so. In that case it's not a kludge, it's a design feature to make it harder for others (eg, "software hoarders") to be immoral, and your points are incorrect.
If you believe in software freedom for all developers, so they can do whatever they want to do with your code, then yes the gcc design is horrible and your points are correct.
The choice of viewpoint is based on one's politics and ethics, even if isn't explicitly stated. You apparently don't believe in software freedom for all users, so you interpret RMS's objections as being "politically motivated."
But by the same token, clang has made a deliberate choice to not protect user freedom, which can just as easily be interpreted as a politically motivated decision.
- jejones3141 13y agoHmmm... then what distinguishes that design feature from DRM?
- dalke 13y agoUmmm, lots of things? To start with, access to the source code, the legal ability to modify and redistribute said code, and no requirement for permission renewals from someone else. What gives you the idea that this is anything like DRM? Given the long history of spin-offs like gcc-xml (which started in 2000), there's nothing which prevents you from adding this design yourself. This is a social contract issue, not a legal one.