Not being correct is not a sin. Beyond that, the paper isn't pants-on-head crazy. The objections most people have to it can be solved by adding a single term t

Not being correct is not a sin. Beyond that, the paper isn't pants-on-head crazy. The objections most people have to it can be solved by adding a single term to one of the equations, and some very straightforward sensitivity analysis. Which is, you know, exactly the kind of thing pointed out in peer review.