4 ms·
This population consists of 50 people who can afford to pay $1 for your product, and 1 person who can afford to pay $100...You can sell it to 50 people and make
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
This population consists of 50 people who can afford to pay $1 for your product, and 1 person who can afford to pay $100...You can sell it to 50 people and make $50 profit, or one person and make $100 profit.
This is true for a single monopolistic market incumbent. On the other hand, if I (the upstart) want to make money, I'll charge $1. I don't care if I just cost you $100 and I only gained $50 in profit - my choices were either getting $50 (by selling at $1) or $0 (by selling at $100).
The real estate market is pretty competitive - it's not as if a small oligopoly owns all the land. So if rent is going up, you should be asking what what prevents upstarts from buying up a city block and building a gigantic low cost tower block to house everyone. (Hint: insane SF zoning regulations.)
- brudgers 13y agoIt's more than zoning regulations. It's the difficulty of aggregating a large enough parcel. There are two ways to own an urban block: acquire it parcel by parcel over time or purchase it from someone who has acquired it parcel by parcel over time. [1] Obviously basic market place principles play a role. Remaining parcels go up in value as the block becomes increasingly under single ownership and because other people are trying to do the same thing [2]- identifying prime parcels for redevelopment is easy for obvious parcels and there are lots of eyes looking for less obvious parcels. [1] ok, sometimes you can get the government to condemn the block and turn it over to you in one fell swoop and that's probably the most cost effective in many places. [2] The third to last parcel on a block remaining to be aggregated has often improved its location because of the aggregation process and hence commands a much higher price than paid for parcels already part of the aggregate.
- nitrogen 13y agoI seem to recall a story that Disney used a network of shell companies to conceal its aggregation of the property on which Disney World was built to avoid the effects you mention.
- brudgers 13y agoYes. It's standard practice in an industry that has long lead times, often requires keeping the locals in the dark and whose primary raw materials are non-fungible. Disney also used the political route to establish a private governmen, The Reedy Creek Improvement District.
- nkoren 13y agoI'd love to see San Francisco have much more open zoning regulations. They're clearly a contributor to the high real estate costs. However even if I built a low-cost arcology in the middle of SF, I can guarantee that it would find a ready market of rich people willing to pay premium for it. Until the supply of real estate exceeds the demand of rich people willing to pay for it, the market will cater primarily to the wealthy and prices will remain high. A vasty liberalised zoning regime would probably help -- but not until it had saturated the market to the point where the wealthy were no longer crowding out the rest. Unfortunately the financialisation of the real estate industry makes this very difficult to achieve, as the wealthy will keep acquiring real estate as an investment long after their need for it as an actual place to live has been sated. Solutions to this will almost certainly need to include all of the following: 1.) Liberalisation of zoning & development, as you suggest (see Germany for a good example of this). 2.) Ending tax breaks which reward the accumulation of real estate. Probably other measures to de-financialise the real estate sector somewhat, such as requiring significantly higher reserves for banks. 3.) A Universal Basic Income to provide automation-proof social support / monetary redistribution in the face of the end of wage labour.
- yummyfajitas 13y ago...the wealthy will keep acquiring real estate as an investment long after their need for it as an actual place to live has been sated. Negligible problem. SF has a very low vacancy rate. Worry about it if it happens. http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/san-francisco-vacancy-remains-low-despite-building-boom/Content?oid=2622906 http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/san-francisco-vacancy... As for (3), we are nowhere near the point where that is necessary. No developer should ever clean their own house unless labor is scarce. Yet strangely, we have people claiming they can't find work, and we also have high costs for domestic labor. The real problem is that taxes and transfers drastically reduce the incentive for people to do low skill work: http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/taxes-and-cliffs.html http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/taxes-and-cliffs...
- erichocean 13y agoOT: I've got an iOS app that collects an incredible amount of actionable metrics, and I'm looking for some help with exactly the problem you're solving at BayesianWitch for websites. Is there a way I can use your product to help what I'm doing? Email me at erich@rollrandom.com if you'd prefer to answer privately.
- erichocean 13y agoit's not as if a small oligopoly owns all the land Not owns, but controls: the city (and residents) of San Francisco are the ones making the critical decisions here, not the property owners. The property owners are playing rationally within the rules the city has set up. If they want a different outcome, they can change these entirely man-made rules at any time with the stroke of a pen.
- mrow84 13y agoWouldn't you start by charging $99? (And then start a bidding war, and then...) I don't think it was nkoren's intention to provide a complete model of the economy, but simply to illustrate how markets can underserve segments of the population. Examples like this can often be "disproved", sometimes with ease, but that rather misses their purpose. A similar point was the topic of a recent xkcd: http://xkcd.com/1318 http://xkcd.com/1318