8 ms·
The rise of dogecoin interests me because I think it demonstrates a problem with cryptocurrencies - mining becomes too prohibitive for the end user to do before
by untog 13y ago
The rise of dogecoin interests me because I think it demonstrates a problem with cryptocurrencies - mining becomes too prohibitive for the end user to do before the currency becomes mainstream.
Early on, the opportunity of bitcoin was huge. You mine a little, the value of your coins just keeps on rising. Now you can't mine any meaningful level of currency yourself, so the entry level has raised dramatically.
So why not move onto a different currency? Get in early. Get a stack of currency. Then that'll become too difficult to mine and newcomers will move onto the next. And the next.
- driverdan 13y agoWhat are you talking about? The average person may not be able to solo mine a block but you can still earn meaningful quantities through pools.
- untog 13y agoWell, perhaps I should have rephrased - I know you can still earn bitcoin, but you can earn more <newcryptocurrency>. So why not switch? The answer would be "because bitcoin is legitimate and dogecoin isn't" - but I'd argue that bitcoin hasn't gotten there yet. So it's a race, and one that any cryptocurrency is likely to lose.
- _wdh 13y agoBut you'll never be able to earn as much as the average person who happened to start mining a month before you. The people who started first will always have an advantage over you. It all looks a bit like a pyramid scheme.
- TDL 13y agoPlease look up the meaning of pyramid scheme. Whatever crypto-currencies end up being, they are not pyramid schemes.
- bushido 13y agoHow do you define meaningful? For a single novice user this would be the cost of hardware (substantial), opportunity cost from delays in delivery of hardware, decaying returns with exponential increase in difficulty, cost of electricity and opportunity cost. Then it needs to be ascertained if they are mining a commodity or an investment. That is mining to sell (similar to farming and mining minerals, metals etc.) or are they looking to hold it for long periods expecting an appreciation. The later has other practical implications. For the majority of prospective miners, these costs are huge and have little to no chance of breaking even. Arguments could be made for or against the profitability from speculation/long term holding, but that is beyond the scope of most people's definition of meaningful.
- driverdan 13y agoYes, please dissuade others from mining. It makes it more profitable for those of us who are already doing it ;)
- flatline 13y agoNot for bitcoin you can't. Not really, anymore. The rise of ASICs has marginalized everyone but the ASIC producers. They will always have the edge going forward. Even if they rent you the equipment, you are sharecropping and paying them enough that your sole profit will be from an increase in the value of the currency, not in acquiring coins at the current rate. You may as well just buy the bitcoins. I'm still not sure if this is to the net benefit of the currency or not; I don't think anyone is, people argue both sides, but I tend to think it's a bit premature since productive mining will proceed for years to come at the hands of only a few. One of the potential benefits of the scrypt algorithm used by Litecoin and Dogecoin (and others) is that even with scrypt ASICs being developed, the memory-intensive nature of the algorithm has so far prohibited a massive disparity in hashing ability. You can still buy a sub-$2000 mining rig that will basically pay for itself in a couple months.
- aestra 13y ago>You can still buy a sub-$2000 mining rig that will basically pay for itself in a couple month No you absolutely can't. About 6 or 8 or so weeks ago I was making about $4 a day mining scrypt coins. Now I'm making $1.50. I don't think it is going to be profitable 6 weeks from now. When Dogecoin first exploded I had several $15-$24 days. Right after I first started there was actually a graphics card shortage(!) because of the interest in mining. My graphics cards haven't been paid off yet with just mining, and I don't think they will be. That's not a problem for me, because I can sell one of them, and keep the other, which will pay them off. If you don't already have the PSU, CPU, MOBO, etc, you are wasting your money building a mining rig, especially now the profits are so low. Only buy a graphics card if you want the card for other reasons. Those mining profit calculators way way way overestimate. EDIT: My system has 600 kH/s hashrate. EDIT EDIT: Even 6 or 8 or so some people on the litecoin mining subreddit were very confused about people who were building expensive mining rigs and pointing out how those rigs will never pay for themselves.
- driverdan 13y agoYou need to change what you mine to whatever is most profitable. If you only target a single, popular one then yes, difficulty will increase and profitability will probably decrease. See http://www.coinwarz.com/cryptocurrency/ http://www.coinwarz.com/cryptocurrency/
- davidw 13y agoRelated to this concept of moving to some other currency: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/12/how-and-why-bitcoin-will-plummet-in-price.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/12/how...
- lordCarbonFiber 13y agoThat is the fundamental misconception in regards to the crypto-currrency and (in my opinion) indicative of why they will probably never catch on in any mainstream fashion. If the currency was successful, the end user was never intended to be able to mine a meaningful level of currency themselves. The act of mining is required to facilitate transactions and miners get a small part of those transactions for participating. The initial payouts are there solely (in theory) as incentive for the early adopters to mine when the transaction volume is small and to allow them to give the currency an early liquidity. In practice, because of the deflationary nature of the coin and the domination of speculation over transactions involving some tangible goods or services, people are hoarding them expecting increases in value. This is not a good hallmark of a currency and is a flaw that all the derivative coins fail to address.
- BrainInAJar 13y ago> people are hoarding them expecting increases in value. This is not a good hallmark of a currency and is a flaw that all the derivative coins fail to address. This is the fundamental problem with all non-fiat currencies and is why the world moved off the gold standard
- secabeen 13y agoThis. Currencies function well when they grow in-line with the growth in the economies they serve. When they fail to do so, people become reticent to actually use them in commerce, which increases hoarding, increasing theoretical value, but reducing actual utility.
- broolstoryco 13y agocould you please point me to any theories or papers that discuss this? (genuinely curious)
- secabeen 13y agoThere are some citations in the Disadvantages Section of the Gold Standard article on Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#Disadvantages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#Disadvantages
- rmc 13y agoA cynic like me thinks that's part of the point of bitcoin. Make it easy at the start to encourage adopters ("mine now and you'll have a big piece of the pie"), and later adopters will pay you back when it gets popular.
- brador 13y agoMLM 101. The top of the pyramid make the big money, everyone else gets played.
- broolstoryco 13y agoThen every successful startup out there is an MLM scheme.
- untog 13y agoThe problem is that you also need to ensure that it isn't easily replaceable. Which bitcoin is.
- dllthomas 13y agoMake access to the chain important for other reasons, and it stops being replaceable.
- timdiggerm 13y agoRight, but that only encourages hoarding.
- steveklabnik 13y agoSatoshi controls about 14% of all BTC, and 7% of all BTC that will ever exist.
- Smegger 13y agoyou assume that his did not end up in the bit bucket. The problem is if Satoshi ever makes a transaction people will freak over what it mean and think he is cashing out or some bull it will be years before he can use them without it inducing a panic.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoAt the risk of oversimplifying the issue: perhaps people should focus less on making enormous amounts of money mining and more on, you know, using the fucking currency.
- Smegger 13y agoIts the internets version of a gold rush, The people that ended up with gold were no the miners it was the people selling stuff to miners
- ojr 13y agoRichest Dogecoin Owners http://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-dogecoin-addresses.html http://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-dogecoin-addresses....
- crimsonalucard 13y agoCurrencies typically aren't mined. If a currency can be generated out of thin air indefinitely that is usually a problem. You can actually "mine" paper dollars as well: it's called counterfeiting. In all countries the act of counterfeiting is unfair, leads to inflation and is almost always illegal. The fact that the mining is tapering off for bitcoin isn't a problem. It's actually a feature that is designed to mitigate uncontrolled inflation. The TRUE problem with bitcoin is that the nature of the coins themselves are changed by the way people perceive the coins. If people treat the coins as currency then thats what it becomes, but if people treat it as a speculative investment asset similar to a stock share then that's what bitcoin will become as well. Right now nobody buys bitcoins to use as a currency. I can assure you 99% of bitcoin transactions occur because people are gambling on the fact that the price will go up and not because you want to use the coins as you use a dollar bill. Currently, bitcoin is much more a speculative investment asset then it is a currency. It is exactly like the stock market: A market where people bid on worthless paper for the sole purpose of selling the paper for profit. In short the main problem with bitcoin is YOU and ME. As users of bitcoin the way we perceive and use the currency will change what it will become.
- addandsubtract 13y ago>You can actually "mine" paper dollars as well: it's called counterfeiting. The counterpart to mining coins would be to invest dollars and "mine" interests.
- crimsonalucard 13y agocounterfeiting is a closer counterpart in my opinion as interest is capped by the amount of money you have while mining is only capped by time and porcessing power. Anyway, all the money generated from the Fed, loans and interest is complicated to think about. I thought it was simpler to illustrate the whole thing with "printing money." Most people can perceive the bad part of counterfeiting and relate that to excessive mining, which is basically the point I was trying to convey.
- judk 13y agoThat is not mining. Mining dollars happens when when banks engage in fractional reserve banking, lending out money that is simultaneously "in" a depositor's account. But that doesn't create money, so much as temporarily creates an illusion of more money existing, hoping that there will not be a bank run to withdraw all of it. With non-reserve banking, when gold is passed around as money (possibly with seignorage), it is mined by digging in dirt.