3 ms·
Well, from the various followups on the original story, it looks like the reality was much more complicated than this article (and your comment) make it out to
by ubernostrum 17y ago
Well, from the various followups on the original story, it looks like the reality was much more complicated than this article (and your comment) make it out to be.
Specifically, it looks as if the publisher of the Kindle edition was an outfit that distributes digitized public-domain books. The specific books in question are in the public domain in Canada, but not elsewhere. Therefore:
1. Neither that publisher nor Amazon had the right to offer these books for sale outside of Canada, and
2. The publisher receiving the payments for these books was not the entity which owned the rights to them in countries where the books are still under copyright.
The exact means by which the screwup happened, I don't know; maybe the public-domain publisher mistakenly thought the books were PD everywhere, maybe they forgot to check a box for "only sell to Canadians", maybe Amazon mistakenly listed the books where it wasn't supposed to.
But regardless of how the situation came about, this is not the publisher of a book trying to "unpublish" it, or changing their mind about whether to offer an electronic edition. This was copyright infringement which was discovered and remedied.
Did Amazon do it in a way that sucks? Yeah. Should anybody be surprised that this functionality exists in the Kindle? Absolutely not. Hell, even Google -- striving for openness and fairness and not-being-Apple -- built a remote kill switch into their app store for Android.
- andreyf 17y agoHell, even Google -- striving for openness and fairness and not-being-Apple -- built a remote kill switch into their app store for Android You know, I'm really glad they did. They'll know first if an application has a virus or remote exploit, I want them to take it off my device. I trust that they won't do anything shady (and I trust Amazon won't do anything shady) because (1) they're bound by laws that keep them in check and (2) they want my business.