3 ms·
Do you want to know what marxism is like in america? Try academic research science. Pay lines for postdocs are effectively set by a centalized agency - NIH gu
by dnautics 13y ago
Do you want to know what marxism is like in america? Try academic research science. Pay lines for postdocs are effectively set by a centalized agency - NIH guidelines. There's limited market and a captive, oversupplied labor pool, zero ownership of the means of production ("it all goes for the collective effort"). Advancement is not meritocratic, but rather a combination of being in the right place when a position opens up, and who you know ("political connections"). As a result you have absurdities like me: a PhD four years out of grad school (10 years off my bachelor's) that can run circles around bosses both intellectually and technically, experience in multidisciplinary research up the wazoo - making $40k/year. Meanwhile, the head of the institute built a $37 million vanity building, excuse me, lab facility, and does media gigs showing off his tesla roadster to David Frost - largely extracted off of state funds by skimming off of grants ("overhead") and also state-provided "R&D and investment vehicles" - SBIRs, etc.
Well, at least I'm not an H-1B. I remember a postdoc on an H-1B who lived in a one bedroom underneath me and my roommate's from grad school, who was paying twice I was in rent and also trying to support a wife and two kids on an equivalent salary in this relatively expensive city (San Diego).
Enjoy your marxism.
I have left the system - I'm starting up my own biomedical/science research institute run off of actually humane principles - and so I'm, in the interim, unemployed. Luckily, I seem have some skill in the "free market" and so I'm financing this short break in employment off of investments I made (bitcoin, a handful of stocks) and am entering in 'hustle' mode - picking up whatever jobs I can to tide me over (you don't get unemployment benefits if you quit, even though you've paid into it). I'm much happier. When I do work, I know that what I'm doing is making a difference -if minor- in people's lives, not working to advance the agenda of a faceless bureaucracy doling out grants mostly administered by scientists who couldn't hack it in research and so went to work for the bureaucracy (dunning-kruger effect).
- tsax 13y agoBravo. The absurdity of some of the highest paid people in the world calling for a revolution is really comical to an immigrant like me. Not to say that the collusion was not despicable.
- dfraser992 13y agoI was hardly very well paid - I was constantly paid late and should have been charging the assholes I was working for double my rate. Perhaps a good way to explain the problem is a) let's say I got paid $50/hr. Task A takes me 1 hour and I go and generate some work product that fulfills a customer's request. B) this customer is paying $2000 a month for their problem to be solved. You have to take into account as well the cost of the system that I built that task A is built upon, so let's say that cost $5000. So in 3 months, the cost as paid by the capitalist pig has been fully paid for, and from then on, in perpetuity, there is nothing but $2000/month in profit that goes strictly into the piggy bank of the greedy capitalist pig. Meanwhile, I don't even get paid the $50 he owes me on time. As a white collar professional who is doing _all_ the work, while capitalist pig goes on skiing vacations, this is really galling. Ok, I can quit or go work for someone else, or build my competing system (then get sued by the sociopath)... I think this shows how the pay of CEOs etc over the past 20 years has risen to astronomically insulting levels while everyone else who literally enables that is getting shafted. If the CEO does a whole lot of work, then I won't begrudge them some difference in pay. But such a difference compared to what they actually do in terms of effort? No, not when CEOs etc in general seem to be able to avoid responsibility for their screwups so easily. The system is out of balance. It really has nothing to do with the amount of money involved.
- Iftheshoefits 13y agoAll I gathered from your comment is that you are a PhD holder who doesn't know what "marxism" is.
- dnautics 13y agoPresumptively the 'most important' things that Marx believed is the idea that the workers should "control the means of production"[1] via a centrally organized apparatus, preferably the state, plus theoretically orthogonal (except to the keepers of the faith) stuff like labor theory of value, distinction between productive and unproductive labor, and dialectic model for social progression, plus a little bit of pining for the simplicity of the feudalistic era. But, you're right, I don't know what "Marxism" is. But, I suspect many self-proclaimed marxists haven't even read Das Kapital or the Manifesto, so at least I'm a little bit ahead. [1] I will cop to not fully understanding what it generally means to 'control the means of production' but I blame Marx. It's kind of not a really well-defined idea, and he had a penchant for florid language, in places where he was compensating for not being precise.
- dfraser992 13y agoMy post was a bit of a rant, admittedly. I am reading Das Kapital now and have found it useful - I am an engineer, so yes, "central planning" is a unrealistic ideal (how does the behavior or organization of the Federal Reserve not fall under "central planning"?) But as a work of philosophy, the ideas in Das Kapital are useful - labor theory of value, productive / unproductive labor, etc. My first draft got long, so I'll try to keep this short. As for your situation, it to me seems more like the corrupt quasi-totalitarian system involving oligarchs and Ayn Rand's "moochers" and etc - crony capitalism? It doesn't sound anything marxist to me - the Soviet Union was not communism, despite whatever they claimed. And America is hardly a democracy... People are fundamentally corrupt, especially when there is money and power involved. Re: "control of the means of production" - let me explain it this way. In London, I got hired to build a website and somehow it turned into me being employee-ish #1 (and the only one) for a B2B startup. In my contract (one for contractors) was a clause about my ability to stop work and demand payment for late invoices at any time. But IT startup culture is not really like that - you get the job done, right? It is hard, and professionalism counts for everything. So in my mind, it was the nuclear option - I need to use that, then the relationship with my client has irrevocably broken down because step 2 is calling in the lawyers. But the CEO of this startup, who is a lazy, shiftless, and sociopathic bastard, leveraged that work ethic to the point where he was refusing to pay everyone's invoices (me and the salesguys) - "cash flow problems". But we still kept working, to keep the company running. While this bastard took skiing vacations - he and the other founder did very little work, really. All they did was put up a bunch of cash and had an idea and no skill what so ever relevant for the task, except how to exploit the workers and scam the customers with badly written contracts. It all came to a head when one customer threatened to sue - he'd been flat out lied to about the nature of the data he was being sold. I fixed the situation - I was the engineer - and then demanded payment. They point blank told me to go fuck myself, deliberately breaching the contract. This is when I realized I 'control the means of production' - I was the -only- person in this 5person company who could do anything useful of value. I was the one generating all the value (the code, the systems). I was labor and had been fucked over by capital, who brought nothing to the table except money. They didn't even bring a work ethic. Well, the salesguys, but their function was to take my output and get customers interested in it. All capital did was think up ways to exploit both customers and workers. So I controlled the means (because everything I did was the foundation of the company) and I did not use that power to my benefit to counteract the predations of the evil capitalist pig I was dealing with. I should have gone on strike; that's what that clause in the contract was for. But middle class white collar Americans don't have that mentality, and especially IT people. My introduction to the real world utility of Marxist philosophy was a harsh one... Fundamentally, my mistake was not realizing I was my own corporation, and not an employee, and so had the responsibility of acting as sociopathic as need be in order to deal with 'corporations' or people who are doing the same. I hate doing that - it is not in my nature or mentality. I guess mentally, I am more working class. I prefer to cooperate with people than exploit them and I would guess this goes for most people in IT. So what are you producing that other people higher up in the hierarchy are appropriating for their own and exclusive benefit? It sounds like you have decided to become capital yourself, which I encourage - today's ethos of engineers starting their own companies is a good thing, one that really wasn't happening when I started in IT. So hopefully the lazy capitalist pigs who do nothing but exploit labor can be cut out of the equation eventually... But don't exploit the people who work for you!