5 ms·
I realize there is a bit of snark in that comment but the interesting bit is known as COGS. Part of the "value" of a business is the rate at which it can make m
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I realize there is a bit of snark in that comment but the interesting bit is known as COGS. Part of the "value" of a business is the rate at which it can make money, and the server business is limited in its rate by how many machines you can build and the price you can sell them for. Most internet businesses (like Snapchat) are limited only by the amount of money you can extract from users and the number of users you can sign up. While the sunk costs of hosting servers and infrastructure is non-zero, the marginal cost of an additional customer is tiny compared to the marginal revenue they could generate.
This is the fundamental way in which the information economy is different than the goods economy. And that makes comparing a business in one, with a business in the other, invalid.
- nacs 13y agoAnd just how much money is Snapchat extracting from its users to justify 3 billion?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoWell this estimate http://techcrunch.com/2013/11/19/how-many-users-does-snapchat-have/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/11/19/how-many-users-does-snapcha... is that snapchat probably has at least 10M users. So let's say you wanted a 10% return on your $3B value, you would have to generate $30 in net income per user per year ($300M). If you charge a 'membership' fee of $3/month [1] that gives you $360M a year, leaving $60M/year (or $5M / month "burn" rate). So would people pay that? I don't know. But it would be the sort of math you would go through evaluating that deal. To evaluate the server deal you have to look at how many units you think you are going to ship, what your COGS are on them, and your gross margin. You can't really give someone 'free server' for a year because you have money sunk into building it and shipping it. Further your revenue probably doesn't change if 100 people use a server or 1000 people do. My point remains that it is not possible to compare 'goods' economy companies with 'info' economy companies. [1] [Edit: added the RPM rates] Conversely, in advertising terms with 400M snaps per day you would need a RPM of $2.50 to generate $360M/year in revenues.
- nacs 13y agoI highly doubt SnapChat's audience of majority less than 18-year-old population (with most in their early teens) are going to pay $30 a year for a way to send auto-deleting pictures to each other. Especially when there are numerous other free multimedia messaging apps. Getting even 1% of that audience to pay would be impressive. An RPM of $2.50 is also equally unrealistic for an audience of the mostly non-credit-card holding teen demographic, even more so when they're looking at the autoexpiring content for mere seconds before moving onto reply. Not only that but I'd bet a lot of those snaps per day come from a small subset of the 10M users.
- baddox 13y ago> So would people pay that? I don't know. I know. People would not pay that.
- cwp 13y agoNot only that, but nobody forked over billions for Snapchat. The company took investment at a price that suggests we can extrapolate a total valuation in the billions, but nothing like that amount of money has actually changed hands. Lenovo is putting up $2 billion in cash for this deal.
- nl 13y agoSnapchat turned down a $3 billion offer from Facebook. That's what the snarky comments are about.
- cwp 13y agoAgain, that's not cash on the barrel head. That's a rumor. Was it $3 billion in Facebook stock? Was it $1 billion plus a performance bonus? Would Snapchat continue to operate independently, or was it a huge acquihire? We know what IBM's server business is worth. Snapchat's valuation is just speculation.