4 ms·
You should expect it and plan for it, but when you know it your actions have to change. If I know you're about to kick down my door, I have far more options tha
by Jtsummers 13y ago
You should expect it and plan for it, but when you know it your actions have to change. If I know you're about to kick down my door, I have far more options than if I know "in the next hour they'll probably kick down my door". The information completely alters the dynamic. Even in games with no hidden information (such as chess or go), you don't know what my next action will be (except in few cases where my options are severely limited), you only know the probabilities. What if we're raiding a house for some reason (like in Munich), and there are 4 doors and a dozen windows. 5 gunmen inside, if they know which doors we're about to go through and which windows we're ignoring, they can either effect an escape or a more effective defense. Our raid is going to be fair less effective if we announce our plan to the opponent instead of making them guess at it.
- jimktrains2 13y agoI guess I'm thinking about things in terms of Kerckhoff's principle. If your success is related to secrecy of your plan, then it seems very fragile.
- Jtsummers 13y agoAh, but that's about cryptosystems. And its application is really about the continued use of a thing. Kerckhoff's principle doesn't apply so much to a one-off situation. Sticking with a house raid: We have a plan to raid this house using these entrances, covering those exits with these 10 people. The adversary knowing our plan screws us, but learning it after the fact doesn't help our adversary. But what if we use the same tactic every time? What if we always cut power immediately before breaching. That's a signal to the adversary. What if we always use the same sniper and he has a known handicap? If the adversary learns these things then they can break our efforts (or reduce the effectiveness) to conduct the raid. And this is where Kerckhoff's principle could be applied. EDIT: It's not secrets that are the problem, it's keeping the wrong secrets. You can't have my passphrase or my PGP private key(s), but, sure, you can have the AES and RSA algorithms and my public key(s).
- mikeash 13y agoSometimes a fragile plan is still the best one you can have. Life doesn't always give you good choices. Sometimes you're stuck with either a fragile plan where things can go horribly wrong if secrecy is breached, and one that's even worse.