4 ms·
That's like saying that Amazon doesn't actually embrace the US dollar, they just embrace payment services like Visa and Mastercard.
by baddox 13y ago
That's like saying that Amazon doesn't actually embrace the US dollar, they just embrace payment services like Visa and Mastercard.
- slg 13y agoNo, it isn't the same. Visa and Mastercard pay Amazon with USD. BitPay and Coinbase do not pay TigerDirect in Bitcoin. Amazon is fine holding reserves of USD. Retailers like TigerDirect and Overstock are not yet willing to hold reserves of Bitcoin.
- CodeCube 13y agostrictly speaking, you don't know this. I believe these services let you choose what percentage you want to be paid in USD, and what percentage you want to keep in bitcoin. So although they may choose to be paid entirely in USD, they could also choose to keep some amount of bitcoin ... that's an internal matter that they may or may not make public
- danudey 13y agoFrom an accounting perspective, it makes little sense to keep BTC, since it's so volatile. It's easier to account for your sales in USD and have a fixed value than account for them in BTC, which fluctuates wildly.
- vijayboyapati 13y agoMerchants have the choice whether or not to hold bitcoin. It's probably fair to say many or most merchants will choose to receive dollars because their costs are in dollars, and the price of bitcoin is still volatile. But the price is volatile only because bitcoin is still nascent and not widely held. As it becomes more widely held and more liquid, the volatility will go down, and the willingness to accept and hold bitcoin will increase (i.e., there will be an increase in reservation demand). Merchants who are willing to accept and hold bitcoins will also benefit from lower transaction costs - those who have the conversion done for them are implicitly paying the transaction cost related to the volatility and bid/ask spread in the market (or perhaps more likely it is the consumer paying this implicit transaction fee). It's also important to realize we're in the very very early days of bitcoin. This is really like 1994 for the Internet.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- seliopou 13y agoThat's not the case. Bitcoin payment processors deposit USD directly into the merchant's bank account. The merchant doesn't have to deal with Bitcoin at all if they choose not to. If the payment processor submitted orders on behalf of the customer, then the merchant would in fact not even have to know of Bitcoin's existence, even though Bitcoin is facilitating the transaction at some level.
- mikeash 13y agoIf Amazon instantaneously converted all USD they received into another currency, and transacted all of their business in that other currency, I think we'd be entirely reasonable to say that they didn't embrace USD.
- baddox 13y agoHow would that make a difference to the consumer? Imagine that, for all we know, Amazon currently converts all of its USD revenue into another currency. That makes absolutely no difference to the consumer, who still uses USD.
- mikeash 13y agoIt wouldn't, but I don't think we're talking about making a difference to the consumer here.
- baddox 13y agoThen the definition of "embracing Bitcoin" makes little sense to me.
- mikeash 13y agoI imagine that's because these conversations tend to be about validating Bitcoin as a "real currency" that's going to change the world and replace fiat currencies and such, not at all about consumers (even though they would tend to matter a lot in that at some point).
- XorNot 13y agoCoinbase could become a regular US cash service tomorrow and it wouldn't make a difference to their client interactions with retailers. What's going on here is the retailers are forking the "risk" of Bitcoin off to Coinbase - they bill Coinbase in USD, Coinbase bills the customer in BTC and hopefully the BTC market doesn't turn against them in the interim and that Coinbase manage to keep enough USD on hand to keep cashing out Bitcoin. Which is where the problem lies: for Coinbase to operate, the have to be selling huge quantities of Bitcoin for USD to people who want to buy Bitcoin. And they need to hope the price keeps going up to cover their position.