2 ms·
The simplest counterargument to the Luddite Fallacy I have heard is: Animals (e.g. horses), the lowest-skilled "workers", have been completely replaced by machi
by tomp 13y ago
The simplest counterargument to the Luddite Fallacy I have heard is: Animals (e.g. horses), the lowest-skilled "workers", have been completely replaced by machines.
- beat 13y agoInterestingly, skilled animal workers haven't been replaced by machines. Example: service dogs (also, hunting and herding dogs). When the animal's advantage over humans is sheer strength and endurance, machines usually work better. But when their advantages are senses and intelligence, they still outperform machines.
- stonemetal 13y agoI rather see that as a point in favor of the Luddite Fallacy not a counterargument. The US horse population has crashed from 21 million in 1900 to 3 million in 1960.(PDF warning) (http://www.americanequestrian.com/pdf/US-Equine-Demographics.pdf http://www.americanequestrian.com/pdf/US-Equine-Demographics...) If the human population fell to 15% of its current level because of unemployment, it would probably be pretty unpleasnt for a while.