4 ms·
Ok let's say they have some evidence that is sufficient to create reasonable suspicion, but probably insufficient to secure a conviction. Why would it be wrong
by snowwrestler 13y ago
Ok let's say they have some evidence that is sufficient to create reasonable suspicion, but probably insufficient to secure a conviction.
Why would it be wrong for the FBI, under the supervision of a court order, to tap this person's phone to see if he is the killer?
Keep in mind this is not a broad NSA dragnet here. This would be a targeted wiretap driven by probable cause and governed by the federal rules of evidence. The GP said "It would be wonderful if all wiretaps were ruled illegal," and we're exploring that idea.
- malandrew 13y agoNo, it would not be as long as there was a court order and our judges have the time and sense of gravity to give each and every court order sufficient scrutiny to determine whether it has merit or is merely a fishing expedition. Wiretaps should also only begin once a warrant has been approved by a judge, any wiretap in bulk so you can retroactively get phone records and conversations from the date before the warrant was issued is unconstitutional. If the person in question kept their own records, the warrant can apply to those records, but to keep a tab on every American, innocent or otherwise, is disturbing. Personally, I would love to see a two-factor commit with all warrants. All warrants should require two judges to sign off on them, one federal judge and one state judge where the wiretap will be carried out. The other thing I would like to see is some sort of "cost" that the agencies must bear to be able to request warrants. It should cost each agency money to apply for warrants and they should have a limited budget each year to spend on warrant applications. At the end of each year, to apply for increases in this budget, they should present an equal number of both cases which they would have liked to pursue warrants on someone, but it was deemed outside the budget and cases where they pursued a warrant and got one, but the person turned out to be innocent. Such a policy applies market forces to limit rampant wiretapping and phishing expeditions. Instead they will adjust to only use their warrants on those people who actually should be wiretapped. This would also help prevent unilateral action by a single agent or team, without appealing to another independent group with power of the purse over warrant applications. Individual agents and teams would try to get warrants for all their suspects, but the group with power of the purse has the responsibility to dole out warrant applications according to merit so that the agency doesn't run out of them before year's end.
- arca_vorago 13y ago"under the supervision of a court order" A court order is not a warrant. This is the heart of the discussion you are trying to get into. The 4th amendment is very clear: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." If we allow a court order or a subpoena to continue to be all that LEO/LEA's to need to get whatever information they want, they will stop going to the courts for warrants, and worse, they will end up doing FISA style bulk orders/subpoena's. Bottom line, if you have probable cause, get a fucking warrant, else, fuck off. (and companies should be requiring warrants for access to customer information too, not just setting up a pay portal for LEA's to peruse at leisure.)
- jasomill 13y agoA search warrant is a particular type of court order; a subpoena is another. As far as I know, there isn't really any overlap: search warrants authorize law enforcement to conduct searches, subject to fourth amendment restrictions; subpoenas compel parties to deliver documents or testimony, subject to fifth amendment restrictions.
- snowwrestler 13y agoJust replace the term "court order" with "warrant" above if it makes my point clearer. The opinion that kicked off this sub-thread is that all wiretaps should be illegal. "All." That would also eliminate wiretaps that would be authorized under a warrant.