3 ms·
"It makes people lazy and less productive. This may seem ironic, but when someone puts in heroic levels of effort, they start to place less value on each minute
by greenyoda 13y ago
"It makes people lazy and less productive. This may seem ironic, but when someone puts in heroic levels of effort, they start to place less value on each minute. I know that if I work all night, then an hour brain-break mid-day sounds very reasonable. The problem is that these breaks become a habit that can persist between Crunch times."
While I found the rest of the article to be thoughtful and useful, this part sounds like it was written by a pointy-haired boss who doesn't believe his employees can possibly be productive unless their butts are firmly planted in their chairs.
A one hour mid-day brain-break might make many people more productive. In fact, taking an hour for lunch and getting out of the office is a good way to clear you head, and by the time you get back, your brain might have figured out the answers to the problems you had when you left (which might have taken you the rest of the afternoon to figure out otherwise).
If you can't trust your employees to take mental breaks when they need them, then you should be managing assembly line workers, not knowledge workers.
- GhotiFish 13y agoUnfortunately, I had first hand experience on this one, at least for me he isn't wrong. There was a family incident which required a substantial amount of my attention, I'd lost two weeks, and my boss required I make that up. I went to working from 40 a week to 60. The thing is, I already had trouble pacing myself. I tend to work fast and burn out fast, so 40 hours a week was already a little more work than I am capable of, but those extra 20... The only way I could even perform those extra hours was by extending my breaks and doing less work. Now that I've paid the debt, the way I perceive my workplace has altered. I'm having serious serious serious problems doing any work at all now. I can't get it out of my head, I know I've got an insanely huge block of time ahead of me that I just can't cope with, even if there's some rushed context.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoYou're right, he used a poor example: 1 hour brain break is not necessarily unreasonable at times. However, his basic point is very true. Right now I work at a company (clara.io) that has an incredible 8 hours a day culture. Heads down, solid work for a solid 8, and then out the door as if there was a clock to punch. This is an incredible contrast to every other place I've worked at, where 10 hours was a short day, yet in reality we probably spent less time working than we do at clara.io. We'd spend time chatting about politics or local issues, take long breaks, waste time on Hacker News and the like, et cetera. It's really hard to cut that out once you're used to it.
- tieTYT 13y agoMaybe I misinterpreted what you meant by "solid 8", especially in the context of your reply. Does that mean you don't take lunch?
- mattmanser 13y agoYou're totally misunderstanding what he's saying. It's that these people are kidding themselves and effectively completely wasting their own time. Instead of working 9-5 being productive 90% of the time, they're working 9-11, but during 9-5 they're 30% productive then make up for it by doing a heroic effort in the evening. If they'd have just focused earlier, they'd be at the cinema with their friends. I've been in that scenario, getting nothing done during the day then working hard at home at night. It creeps up on you, to begin with you're working all 10 or 12 hours. By the end of it, you're not.
- jacalata 13y agoI think you missed his point (which could certainly have been made better). How I read it was more like this: If you are told/know that you will be working 14 hours today because everybody is in crunch mode, then taking ten minutes every hour to get coffee and relax isn't a big deal, and another ten minutes on HN every hour isn't a big deal, and another ten minutes on email every hour also isn't a bid deal, and now you've spent only 7 hours actually working for 14 hours at the office. On the other hand, if you are told you can only work 9-5, then you will save all the HN time for later, and you will probably ignore some of the less important emails, so that's an extra 15 minutes per hour of actual work, so you worked 6 hours in your 8 hours at the office. Source: I interned on a military base that had exactly this rule. It really focuses you to know you have x hours, no more, each day.