5 ms·
From a European perspective, it seems utterly strange that Americans don't simply use wire transfers for something like this. If someone wants to send me money
by pavlov 13y ago
From a European perspective, it seems utterly strange that Americans don't simply use wire transfers for something like this.
If someone wants to send me money, I just give them my bank account number (IBAN). Transfers are free within EU and the handful of outsider European countries.
Why are Americans afraid of giving out their bank account numbers? The only thing you can do with an IBAN is send money to it, and that's hardly malicious.
- steveklabnik 13y agoWire transfers are expensive here, $15~$30. You can also withdraw money if you have the bank account information. A famous example is Don Knuth, who had to stop offering rewards checks: http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/news08.html http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/news08.html
- lettergram 13y agoI know it isn't bad if you know the person is at the same bank, for example most of my friends bank at Chase so we can transfer money via wire for free.
- steveklabnik 13y agoRight, I personally use Chase's "QuickPay" feature a lot. I would imagine that most people don't think of that as a 'wire transfer' though.
- pavlov 13y agoWow. At that cost, I assume American banks must be using a combination of telegraphs and the Pony Express to settle their wire transfers. "You see, sending money across state lines is not easy. There needs to be insurance in case wild natives attack and steal the leather bag containing those money orders... It's only fair that we pass that cost on to the customer."
- wmf 13y agoYou're joking, but when I did a wire transfer it failed the first time and I had to call my bank and give them extra information over the phone, including the street address of the branch where the destination account lives. Considering how much labor went into it, I understand why they charged me $30.
- pjg 13y agoNothing is completely secure. Giving out Credit/Debit card numbers on a website can lead to theft too. Giving out bank account numbers can to. In both cases consumer is indemnified as along as they flag the transaction within 60 days. The problem is the hassle of dealing with the banks etc.
- lettergram 13y agoWire transfers cost money in the U.S. essentially it seems like a way for a bank to make extra money to me (since it really takes little effort to transfer money). That's part of the reason paypal and bitcoins have been fairly popular in the U.S.
- ryanhuff 13y agoAutomated Clearing House (ACH) transfers are usually much cheaper than wire transfers (often free at credit unions). http://www.mybanktracker.com/news/2013/03/20/ways-send-money-someone-else/ http://www.mybanktracker.com/news/2013/03/20/ways-send-money...
- sim0n 13y agoWire transfers are generally free within the UK/EU and very fast (bank-to-bank in the UK usually only takes a few hours at most).
- qzervaas 13y agoI love how we've been trained to think that a few hours is fast. Only takes 30 days for me to clear an international cheque!
- martinald 13y agoIn the UK they're pretty much instant. In my experience if it doesn't hit the account by the time you login to your online banking, something's gone wrong.
- dylanbathurst 13y agoLike everyone else on this thread said, wire transfers cost money here in the US. I think what the EU considers a wire transfer is different than what we do here in the US. Wire transfers here require a bunch of information and are painful. We do have something closer to what you're talking about though. Most large US banks offer the ability to transfer money to other members of the same bank with simply an account number. Such as Bank of America to Bank of America, or Wells Fargo to Wells Fargo. There are fees associated with going Wells Fargo to Bank of America though which is a turn-off. The other problem with these kinds of transfers is that there is no API for integrating that technology into a 3rd party service. I would have to go onto Wells Fargo's site to transfer money to another Wells Fargo customer. If those banks had any sense at all they would innovate and release APIs to enable that kind of transaction.
- mbesto 13y agoAs someone who spent a lot of time in the UK/EU and is now back in the states, I'd love for someone with insight/experience in the EU/UK to explain how the economics make it possible for a system of banks to talk to each other without charging the users. The US economics are pretty simple - banks know they can charge for it.
- steveklabnik 13y agoI am from the US as well, and am not a lawyer, but my understanding is basically TL;DR: regulation * http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Bank_Account_Number#Single_Euro_Payments_Area_.28SEPA.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Bank_Account_Numb... * http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area
- psutor 13y agoWhy are Americans afraid of giving out their bank account numbers? The only thing you can do with an IBAN is send money to it, and that's hardly malicious. In the US you only need a name and bank account number (and to know which bank it belongs to to find the routing number) to make ACH withdrawals. That's why. I'm not aware of any reforms in the banking system to change this awful system, so these online services are the next best thing. I am still waiting to find a good opportunity to use Square Cash.
- pjg 13y agoIf I use your reasoning then Americans should be as afraid to write paper checks since each check has the owner account number on it, hence anybody who gets a paper check can syphon money using ACH. Not really! (Paper checks - even today - move more money than Credit/Debit cards) ACH is far more complex then being able to withdraw money from someone's bank account with just their account number. To be able to initiate an ACH transaction bank level authentication is needed and it can only be done from an authorized bank. Can you give me a use case where someone can withdraw money from my bank account using just my bank account number ? Any ideas ? There is no logical reason for someone not to give out their bank account number anymore than their Credit/Debit card number. In both cases consumers are indemnified by federal regulations. However perception is bigger than reality - just like in the early days of the Internet/e-commerce people were afraid of using their credit card numbers online so are they wary of using their bank account numbers online.
- ac29 13y agoI'm an american, and I've never paid to transfer money to another bank account, even at another bank. Im not sure why people would pay for that, other than not knowing they dont have to. edit: If people are curious, its this: https://home.capitalone360.com/p2p https://home.capitalone360.com/p2p
- dangrossman 13y ago> Im not sure why people would pay for that, other than not knowing they dont have to. That's an odd thing to say. For those of us that aren't Capital One customers, we do have to pay, because the Capital One service you use is not available to us. It's not some web service like PayPal we can sign up for on a whim either; opening a 360 account with Capital One requires an application, a credit check, an existing checking account with another bank, etc.
- prplhaz4 13y agoat rentsent, we've been using Dwolla as an abstraction layer for bank accounts - it's not fast, but it is pretty cheap, and a lot easier than having to remember someone else's bank account number
- pjg 13y agoWire transfers != ACH transfers Wire transfers are (almost) real-time and use Fedwire (domestic) and SWIFT (international) for communication in real-time. Usually banks charge hefty fees for this. ACH is a batch network that takes minimum of 2 business days and generally costs mush less - often free too if you go through the bank's site. The 2 are separate networks and regulated completely differently and hence different charges. Bottom line: if you want money transferred ASAP i.e. real-time/same-day it's likely to cost you. If you can wait for 2-3 days its likely to be free
- 178 13y agoTransfers are not usually free for business accounts.