15 ms·
> Bullshit. Shoddy analogy at best, wilfully stupid attention whoring at worst. how did you get so many karma points using such coarse language? It brings dow
by jgalt212 13y ago
> Bullshit. Shoddy analogy at best, wilfully stupid attention whoring at worst.
how did you get so many karma points using such coarse language? It brings down the level of discourse.
- mcphilip 13y agoEven pg noted that top comments are largely awful. I find just skipping the first one makes reading HN a much more interesting experience.
- megrimlock 13y agoYour observation reminded me of the Million Short search engine that skips past the first N ranked hits. Is there a name for the phenomenon that the first entries in any contested ranking tend to be less interesting? There's something about the ranking systems used on the web in the way they tally the nearly-effort-free actions of hordes (clicks, likes, upvotes, star ratings) that means they represent one kind of magnitude (statistical average impulse behavior) but very little of another (deeper reflection & significance). Deeper stuff tends to see less impulse attention and therefore sinks down the ranking, but is there some other way to identify it?
- boomzilla 13y agoIt's intrinsic vs perceived values in ranking. You could have some rough measure of intrinsic value of a comment by analyzing its content: length, grammars, wording sophistication, etc. It's definitely not trivial and maybe open to spams.
- freehunter 13y agoIt's the same phenomenon that creates pop music, pulp literature, prime time TV, summer blockbusters, two-party voting systems, and AAA games. The mainstream tends to be safe, non-threatening, and appeal to a wide variety of audiences. There may be a genre/topic/idea that better suits people, but it takes work to find it and not everyone wants to put in that work. Not everyone will like Thelonious Monk, and the same people who like him might not like Americana or electro house or black metal. But no one complains about smooth or cool jazz. No one complains about mainstream country. No one complains about techno, no one complains about hard rock on the radio. They're watered down, appeal to wide audiences, and are non-offensive in their broad market. It takes no effort to like mainstream culture, and it doesn't demand anything from your intellectually. You're going to like the Billboard Hot 100, or at the very least you're not going to hate it, because it's been manufactured to be liked by everyone. Same thing with high rated comments in a lot of cases. While the poster might not actually be saying anything, might not have a point, might not have any intellectual depth to their comment, their comment offended no one, was easy to understand, and can be appreciated at face value without needing to think about it. If you can get people to like your ideas without making them think, you're going to be popular. If you make them think, they have the chance to decide if they like what you're saying or not, and if you make them think, you give them the chance to decide that they don't like you.
- rhizome 13y agoIs there a name for the phenomenon that the first entries in any contested ranking tend to be less interesting? Sturgeon's Law, maybe.
- whatusername 13y agoThere's also the Wadsworth Constant. (Linking to life-hacker rather than the reddit thread as it gives more background: http://lifehacker.com/5849342/skip-past-the-boring-intro-on-youtube-videos-with-the-wadsworth-constant-bookmarklet http://lifehacker.com/5849342/skip-past-the-boring-intro-on-... )
- mbillie1 13y ago> Is there a name for the phenomenon that the first entries in any contested ranking tend to be less interesting? 'The fanatics are picturesque; mankind prefers to see gestures rather than hear reasons.'
- VMG 13y agothe topic doesn't warrant a high level of discourse
- swombat 13y agoThe level of discourse was brought down to below zero by the article. I'm actually raising it, if anything. This is an appallingly bad "forecast" and I'm slightly ashamed on behalf of Princeton for allowing their name to be associated with it. Also, if you look at my comment history, I don't habitually use "such coarse language". I only use it in appropriate circumstances - like in response to this article. The coarse language has little to do with the karma. Edit: worth noting that the title of the article on Guardian is "Facebook will lose 80% of its users by 2017", not may. That has been editorialised by the submitter. The article is even worse than you may think if all you read was the title.
- smrtinsert 13y agoWell I think ur bullshit. What a great way to communicate.
- swombat 13y agoI wasn't communicating with the authors of the article, just with the commenters here. I was not even insulting the authors (only the "forecast"). You, on the other hand, are throwing insults at people (me in particular) - and doing so in a largely inarticulate manner. Another pretty poor analogy, I suppose. I can see why you liked the article. </sheldon-joke-mode>
- jrs99 13y agoit's only a bad forecast if it doesn't happen. if it does happen, then it's a freaking awesome INTUITIVE forecast. Okay, so there's no science behind it? It doesn't matter. There's no science behind a lot of things, yet they work. When you recognize insane patterns and connections, much like an Artist as opposed to a Scientist, things can work. All that needs to matter is that the intuition has to be right. The science can come after.
- TelmoMenezes 13y agoOh give me a break. He made a very good point -- the article takes the epidemiological model analogy too far and in a non-rigorous fashion. You are the one "lowering the level of discourse" by focusing on form instead of content and by writing in clichés.
- jrs99 13y agowe don't even know yet if it takes it too far. What happens when 2017 comes along and facebook has lost exactly 80.00% of users since 2014? Will it still have been an analogy taken too far?
- mbillie1 13y agoYes - 'a broken clock is still right twice a day', and scientific conclusions cannot be accurately or scientifically applied via analogy.
- jrs99 13y agoi guess that could be true. The other day i was trying to convince someone that you cannot use a mathematical conjecture if a proof has not been found yet. I think I succeeded.