5 ms·
I hate HDMI and wish it would die in favor of DisplayPort for everything. HDMI even makes manufacturers print HDMI on the front of their monitors for a discoun
by jrockway 13y ago
I hate HDMI and wish it would die in favor of DisplayPort for everything. HDMI even makes manufacturers print HDMI on the front of their monitors for a discount on the royalties. That's why your new $3500 monitor says "HDMI" on the front of it for no reason: to save ten fucking sense on licensing HDMI for the unit. Meanwhile, DisplayPort is free.
HDMI must die.
- drakaal 13y agoSort of, not really. HDMI is a flat $10k a year in licensing. The problem with Displayport is that the chips to render it are more expensive unless you built your monitor for direct drive. That would be great if every display was designed with the same subpixel specs, but no 2 manufacturers have the same specs for their displays so this doesn't work. What happens is most DisplayPort displays convert the image and then render it which is also how you allow for brightness, contrast and sharpness adjustments on the display rather than on the device connected to the display. If you used direct drive you'd control brightness and contrast on your Xbox, bluray, or computer rather than on the display.
- Strang 13y agoHDMI is also very unreliable in my experience. The sound on my tv cuts out randomly whenever viewing an HDMI source. And my monitor occasionally blacks out for a few seconds. Sometimes it doesn't come back on, or only displays colored static. I suspect this has something to do with HDCP DRM, but I'm not sure if that's the case.
- brigade 13y agoGet a better cable, or don't bend your current cable so much.
- lucisferre 13y agoOf note though that this has not been a problem I've observed with non-HDMI solutions.
- brigade 13y agoOne problem is that category 1 HDMI cables are only specified to support 1080i signals. They aren't guaranteed to support 1080p60, and a number of cables (especially no-name chinese cables or longer runs) are only tested to this spec, as category 2 has a huge leap in required bandwidth (all of HDMI 2.0's new stuff works with category 2 cables.) So attempting to send 1080p over a category 1 cable isn't uncommon, and it often "works" with occasional dropouts.
- HNaTTY 13y agoI've had this issue and fixed it with a shorter HDMI cable, that also happened to be higher quality than the OEM cable (I also tried a 16' Blue Jeans cable, didn't work). I'm running 4k@30Hz and while I get the occasional black-out on my monitor, it's now a weekly thing instead of hourly or worse.
- gcb0 13y agoThe thing with Blue Jeans cable and most audiophile brands, is that they don't have engineers that understand the digital signals enough to add effective shield/choke to the cable. They mostly know how to produce good analog cables as that is what they build their business on. Just adding a ferrite tube at the end of the cable is not effective choke. and a cable without choke, is a interference antenna.
- chipotle_coyote 13y agoWhile this may be true in general of "audiophile" cable brands, Blue Jeans is not the kind of company that puts out $500 oxygen-free RCA cables pre-digested by civets (or whatever). It's pretty clear from poking around their site that they do, in fact, understand HDMI pretty well. (The Civet Poop Cable Company is not likely to use language like "if the cheapest cable will do everything you ask of it, there's no picture improvement to be had in going to the best cable (this is, after all, a digital signal)" on their web site.) I don't know which of their cables the previous poster had trouble with, but I'm pretty sure he could have returned it for a refund. (Disclosure: I have no relationship with BJC other than being quite happy with the speaker cables I've bought from them. Which I'm sure the Monoprice fans would tell me I overpaid for anyway, but, well.)
- HNaTTY 13y agoWe use the BJC 16 footers at work for 1080p monitors that are mounted in the ceiling and generally the player is in a closet far away. It was just a cable that was handy. I read that people having an identical issue had better results with shorter cables. I don't know any of the details but the shorter cable had a huge effect.
- sliverstorm 13y agoHonestly I like that things are always clearly labeled "HDMI". No digging around to see, "Is it VGA? DVI? S-Video?". I can see how it might upset some people's delicate design sensibilities to have letters on the corner, but that's never mattered to me. (That said I use DP whenever possible)
- magicalist 13y ago> No digging around to see, "Is it VGA? DVI? S-Video?" I'd definitely appreciate that like 8 years ago, but if a device is old enough to worry about that, it still might not even support HDCP, in which case a large chunk of modern media wouldn't play on it anyway. I don't have an everlasting flame of hatred for it in my heart, but yes, I do find it inane and a bit annoying to have marketing labels for the thing I already bought on the thing itself.
- gcb0 13y agoI'd appreciate that TODAY for dvi... is that connector DVI-I, DVI-D? does it support the analog vga passby? i have no idea? i don't even know all the options i have with DVI, let alone which one is available compatible or incompatible on each device!
- TorKlingberg 13y agoWhy are displayport cables so much more expensive than HDMI cables?
- sliverstorm 13y agoMy first guess would be, because they are less popular.
- rz2k 13y agoAre you looking at Thunderbolt cables? Otherewise, it looks like it is about $3 for 3ft or $5 for 10ft whether it is an HDMI or DisplayPort cable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- freehunter 13y agoMy laptop (Thinkpad) outputs over DisplayPort. I tried to pick up a DP to HDMI cable from Best Buy when my DVD player died right before we were trying to have a movie night, and the sales clerks had never heard of DisplayPort. Every time I brought it up, they handed me either a VGA or HDMI cable, or insisted that DisplayPort didn't exist, that there was only Mini DisplayPort. Why the hell would they name it Mini DisplayPort if a full size DisplayPort never existed?! So yeah, in the "real world", DisplayPort doesn't exist outside of last-gen Macbooks.
- coldtea 13y agoWell, "Best Buy" is not the real world though. Beyond your DisplayPort incident, Best Buy in general is a provincial consumer electronics store, with ignorant sales personel and quite narrow selection. It might have been good enough for 1995, but not in 2014. It's like visiting a Walmart for delicatessen items.
- freehunter 13y agoPeople do go to Wal Mart for delicatessen items. Wal Mart sells packages lunch meats, sliced cheese, etc. Wal Mart even has ready to eat sandwiches available. They're terrible, but it's cheap and they're not bad enough to make people stop eating them. Likewise, Best Buy is indeed the real world. Mom is going to go to Best Buy to pick up a new laptop. Dad's getting his new TV there (with Monster cables so he doesn't get an HDMI virus). Your cousin was there last weekend buying the camera that looks the best on the display stand. Because, if Best Buy doesn't have it, there's no one to sell it to me. That means I need to go on Amazon and shop around, or ask the family tech guy, and he always gives weird suggestions or asks questions around what I'm really looking for. Best Buy just tells me what to buy. There's a reason your local deli has one store with three clerks and is only open until 9pm, while Wal Mart is bigger than Jesus and open 24/7. We don't live in the real world. The real world doesn't demand 4K with cables that can carry the signal at full color because they have different priorities than we do.
- coldtea 13y ago
- riobard 13y agoAnything the TV/disc player industry touches is very likely to suck, like HDMI.