4 ms·
The point of the protest isn't to destroy a person's life, the point of the protest is to (1) make Google's employees reluctant to continue being Google's emplo
by tomp 13y ago
The point of the protest isn't to destroy a person's life, the point of the protest is to (1) make Google's employees reluctant to continue being Google's employees and as a result (2) make Google rethink their official and unofficial policies, in order to (3) make the world a better place.
AFAIK, they haven't really hurt anybody (this time). They are just pressing the points that (they think will) hurt the most.
- walls 13y agoYou'd have to be completely insane to believe #3 is in any way related to #1 and #2. I personally feel the world is a much better place (certainly Oakland is) with highly skilled employees flushing out the trash.
- ForHackernews 13y ago> I personally feel the world is a much better place (certainly Oakland is) with highly skilled employees flushing out the trash. To what or whom does "the trash" refer in your comment?
- kenrikm 13y agoI think he's referring to the people who make Oakland one of the most dangerous cities in country to live in.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoCops?
- g333k 13y agoThe people taken in by this movement are worse then insane, and they are worse than morons. They are articulate enough to be dangerous. However, comments like the one you make here just strengthens their movement. "Trash" ? No one is trash! If you refer to criminality, know that good hearted and decent poor people are also adversely affected. Please, do not call anyone 'trash'.
- nollidge 13y agoNo one deserves to feel unsafe, especially in their own home. Just because they haven't literally harmed his person doesn't mean that they're acting morally.
- tomp 13y agoThat's not a particularly good argument, because one of the main point of people protesting the NSA surveillance (which Google is a part of) is that it makes them feel unsafe. It's all a matter of perspective.
- arebop 13y agoThese protesters are themselves just as much a part of the NSA surveillance as Google is.
- nollidge 13y agoI'm not sure how I feel about the protest in general, but I was reacting to the idea that they "haven't hurt anyone". As far as my system of morals is concerned, making someone feel unsafe is still hurting them.
- tomp 13y agoIsn't that kind of the point of a protest? The threat of revolution?
- aaronem 13y agoOf course. The essence of the argument is whether or not threatening to maim and murder as necessary, to produce whatever result the protesters hold dear, is a morally sound tactic.
- diydsp 13y agoIf one takes "kind of" to mean "not," then yes. Otherwise, no, the point of protest is not to threaten anything or anyone, including revolution. Seriously, just look up protest in a dictionary. It's an expression, a communication. It's a chance for people to respond. It's a visible, recordable effort, as opposed to an anecdote.
- aaronem 13y ago> they haven't really hurt anybody (this time) The implicit threat, made explicit.
- baconner 13y agoThey haven't really hurt anybody physically this time would be a more accurate way to put it. Its hard to imagine that he and his family aren't going to be up late nights worrying about what comes next. I'm truly stunned to see folks on hn defending this behavior.
- aaronem 13y agoI wish I were. They agree with the protesters, don't you see? And, because they feel themselves to be on the "right side of history", whatever that means, they are utterly innocent of fear that they should ever themselves awaken to find a shouting mob on their doorstep. Of course, they're also utterly ignorant of history, or they'd know what happens, in a revolution, to people who consider themselves on the "right side of history", but are found insufficiently so by those to whom all weapons are friends. Little Dantons, all of them! -- and I'd be perfectly sanguine about the sanguinary fate to which they'd unknowingly consign themselves, did it not take such enormities to slake the thirst of the mob; one of the Terror's distinguishing characteristics, after all, is that it is always so very hard to steer.
- npsimons 13y agoThey agree with the protesters, don't you see? And, because they feel themselves to be on the "right side of history", whatever that means, This sounds so familiar, where have I heard it before? Seems to have a lot in common with the anti-abortionists who bomb clinics and kill doctors . . .
- ceph_ 13y agoI really can't believe people are trying to justify bullying like this. The points they're trying to smear him on are outlandish like saying he's personally responsible for NSA surveillance, or because he made an app for construction blueprints he's personnally kicking people out of their homes? Are you really defending this shit?
- g333k 13y agoThey are passionate ideologues. Reason, facts, and fairness have nothing to do with it. Plus, isn't it obvious that envy DOES have a lot to do with this?
- lfuller 13y agoIs this not the very definition of domestic terrorism?