3 ms·
Which force are you talking about? I'm talking about the one that mandates that people pay for contraception with tax dollars.
by humanrebar 13y ago
Which force are you talking about? I'm talking about the one that mandates that people pay for contraception with tax dollars.
- sdegutis 13y agoThat (combined with your comment right above it) is completely and utterly surprising to hear from someone on HN.
- humanrebar 13y agoFor the record, I don't agree with you about contraception. I'm all for building wells in Africa and setting bins of free condoms right next to them. But people started talking about force, and the only force I can see in this case is the IRS (or the equivalent). I'm frankly dismayed that HN seems so opposed to conscientious objection in this case. I presume it's an irrational prejudice against different (or maybe particular?) ethical worldviews.
- sdegutis 13y agoThey're just taking the mindset of: "Such and such things are inherently wrong, and I'm 100% certain that I'm right about this; therefore anyone who disagrees about it is an enemy to humanity and the common good, and therefore must be silenced and must not be allowed to affect legislation." That's all they're doing. And it's understandable. But that's not the part I take issue with.
- mikeash 13y agoSeems pretty negligible compared to the one that mandates people to pay for unjustified foreign wars, incarcerating people because they put a certain molecule into their own bodies, etc. There's an argument to be made against taxation there, but if we're going to have it, you should probably start with the better part of a trillion dollars Americans pay each year for killing brown people (or building the capability to kill them in the future), rather than the relatively negligible amount spent on contraception. It still amazes me that people can make a fuss about being forced to pay for contraception with their tax dollars but those same people have no problem with their tax dollars being spent on war.
- sdegutis 13y agoAs one of those people who doesn't want my tax dollars spent on war, I have no idea what more I can do to stop it from happening. As far as I can tell, the government will spend my money on whatever it wants to, and I have no control over it.
- mikeash 13y agoThere's plenty of room for debate and argument, but ultimately the whole point of taxes is that you don't get to decide what they're spent on. If this stuff worked when everyone decided for themselves, we wouldn't need taxes in the first place. The good thing is that it means we can pool our resources and e.g. build a bridge that none of us would individually contribute towards, but then we get bad stuff too.
- humanrebar 13y agoIt's not worth debating over, but there's clearly a difference in category between drug laws, war policy, and philanthropic aid programs. Opting out of war funding sounds great, but I'm not sure how that would work. As far as drugs, it's harder but we could make drug prohibitions state laws and let people move or make changes at the state level. Philanthropic aid programs, on the other hand, are clearly optional (even if they are amazingly beneficial). If minorities object to contraception, let them opt out of paying for it on their tax form or something. And let other people choose to pay triple. Like you said, it's not a lot of money, so I don't know why we should grief a minority of people on this point.
- mikeash 13y agoI don't understand what this supposed difference is. In what way are government aid programs optional that war and drug laws aren't? Why does it make sense to allow people to opt out of one but not another? You say "clearly", but it's definitely not, at least not to me.
- humanrebar 13y ago